Not Under Pontius Pilate cover

    Not Under Pontius Pilate

    Herod, the Creed, and the Trial the Evangelion Tells

    by W. C. Muenchow IV

    Every Sunday, people in churches on every continent say that Jesus Christ “suffered under Pontius Pilate.” There is a gospel, older than the creed, that tells the story another way. In the Evangelion, the gospel read by the followers of Marcion of Sinope in the second century, Pilate hears the charge against Jesus, finds nothing in it and sends him to Herod Antipas, the ruler of Galilee. After that, Pilate takes no further part in the trial. This book reads that account from the Greek, verse by verse, and sets it beside the church’s Luke, where fourteen verses bring Jesus back to Pilate and give Pilate the sentence. We show the marks those verses left in Luke’s own Greek and in its oldest manuscripts, follow the early Christians who also remembered Herod as the ruler responsible, and trace how Pilate came into the creed, first as a date and then as a judge. We weigh what Roman law allowed, and we answer the objections from Tacitus, Josephus and the other three gospels. The book includes the full text of the night as the Evangelion tells it and a verse-by-verse table of the trial in both gospels. Written for readers with no background, with every person and term explained.