Chapter 12 of 14

    Could Herod Have Done It?

    12 min read

    Some years before the trial, a prophet had been drawing crowds in Herod’s territory. Herod had him arrested and held in the fortress of Machaerus, east of the Dead Sea, and in the end had him killed. The prophet was John the Immerser, whom most Bibles call John the Baptist.

    The story is told by the gospels, which say that John had denounced the ruler’s marriage (Mark 6:17 to 29). It is told also by the Jewish historian Josephus, who had no Christian reason to tell it and who gives a colder motive. Herod, he says, feared that John’s great influence over the people might lead to an uprising, and thought it better to strike first and be rid of him than to wait and regret it (Antiquities 18.116 to 119).

    So when the Evangelion says that a second prophet was brought before this same ruler and did not come out alive, it is not describing a man acting out of character. A text can still say what could not have happened, however, and it is fair to test this one against what is known of the time.

    The Tetrarch

    His full name was Herod Antipas. He was a son of Herod the Great, and when his father died in 4 BC the kingdom was divided. Antipas received Galilee and Perea, the land across the Jordan, and governed them for more than forty years as a dependent prince of Rome with the title of tetrarch. He built the city of Tiberias on the Sea of Galilee and named it for the emperor. His rule ended in the year 39, in a way we will come to in a moment (Antiquities 18.240 to 255).

    Jesus grew up and taught in Galilee, which made him Herod’s subject. That is exactly the reason the Evangelion gives for what Pilate does: “Learning he was under Herod’s authority, he sent him to Herod, who was in Jerusalem at the time.” Josephus records Antipas going up to Jerusalem for a festival in the company of the Roman governor of Syria (Antiquities 18.122).

    Herod had the motive as well as the standing. The Evangelion says he had wanted to see Jesus for a long time. A ruler who has already put down one popular preacher, for fear of where his following might lead, keeps an eye on the next. Even the church’s Luke preserves a memory of this. In a passage peculiar to it, some Pharisees come to Jesus and say, “Get away from here, for Herod wants to kill you” (Luke 13:31).

    The author of Luke and Acts seems, moreover, to have had sources close to Herod’s court. He alone of the four mentions Joanna, “the wife of Chuza, Herod’s steward,” among the women who followed Jesus (Luke 8:3; the Evangelion has the same woman, without the names, at 4:28), and Manaen, “who had been brought up with Herod the tetrarch,” among the leaders of the church at Antioch (Acts 13:1). Commentators have long suggested that the account of a hearing before Herod came through people like these, who were in a position to know. The fullest study of the man, and of this hearing, is Harold Hoehner’s Herod Antipas (1972).

    The King He Wanted to Be

    One more fact about Antipas explains a good deal in the sources we have read.

    His father had been a king. Antipas was not. Rome gave him the lesser title of tetrarch, and he spent his reign wanting the greater one. In the end the wanting ruined him. When his nephew Agrippa was made a king by the emperor Gaius, Antipas, urged on by his wife Herodias, sailed to Italy to ask for the same honor. Agrippa sent accusations after him, and instead of a crown he received a sentence of exile (Antiquities 18.240 to 255).

    His subjects, it seems, gave him the title Rome withheld. We saw in Chapter 10 that Mark, the Gospel of Peter and Justin all call him king. The church’s Luke and the Evangelion are more exact and call him the tetrarch.

    This matters for the trial in two ways. A prince who thought of himself as the heir of the kings of the Jews, and was treated as such by the people around him, did not think of Jerusalem as foreign ground. His father had built its temple and its palace. He came up to Jerusalem at festival time, as Josephus records. And a prisoner accused of calling himself “the Christ, a king,” which is the last and gravest of the charges in the Evangelion, was accused of claiming the very thing Antipas wanted for himself. Pilate, having heard it and found nothing in it, could afford to let it go. Herod could not.

    The Hard Question

    Now for the real difficulty, which we will state as strongly as an opponent would. Jerusalem is not in Galilee. It lay in the province of Judea, and Judea was Pilate’s. Herod was in the city as a visitor. He held no office there. How could a prince of Galilee dispose of a prisoner’s life in another man’s province?

    The Roman historian A. N. Sherwin-White examined the legal side of this in Roman Society and Roman Law in the New Testament (1963). Roman practice in this period, he showed, was to try an offender where the offense was committed. A governor was not obliged to send a prisoner to the ruler of his home territory. But he could, and Sherwin-White judged that Pilate’s sending Jesus to Herod was the kind of courtesy a governor might well extend to a neighboring prince.

    The Evangelion’s own wording points the same way. Herod does not seize the case. The governor hands it to him. The Greek word for what Pilate does is ἀνέπεμψεν, “he sent him up” or “sent him on,” the word used elsewhere for referring a prisoner to a higher or a proper authority. It is the word Festus uses in Acts for sending Paul on to Caesar (Acts 25:21). Justin remembered the sending as something done “as a favor” to Herod. A prisoner delivered by the governor himself is not a prisoner taken behind the governor’s back. Whatever Herod then did with him, he did with a man the governor had put in his hands.

    Nor does the gospel say that Herod’s soldiers carried out the death. It says he “handed Jesus over to their will.” What Herod does is withdraw his protection from his own subject and give him to the people who are shouting for him.

    Why a Governor Would Let Go

    It may still seem unlikely that a Roman governor would let a capital case pass out of his hands in his own province. What is known of Pilate makes it less unlikely than it sounds.

    Josephus records three collisions between Pilate and the people he governed, and all three were about religion. He brought military standards bearing the emperor’s image into Jerusalem by night, and withdrew them after a crowd lay down before his soldiers and bared their necks (Antiquities 18.55 to 59). He took money from the temple treasury to build an aqueduct, and put down the protest with clubs (18.60 to 62). And at the end he sent cavalry against a gathering of Samaritans on their holy mountain, for which the governor of Syria ordered him to Rome to answer to the emperor (18.85 to 89). He never returned.

    Philo adds the affair of the shields, which we met in Chapter 5. That time the complaint went over Pilate’s head to Tiberius, and it was carried by four sons of Herod the Great. Antipas was almost certainly one of them. The emperor took their side and rebuked his governor in writing.

    So consider the position of this governor on the morning the Evangelion describes. A prisoner is brought to him by the chief priests on charges that mix the Law and the household with Caesar’s taxes and a claim to kingship. Pilate asks one question, about the claim to be the Christ, and finds nothing in it for a Roman court. But the accusers insist, the city is full for the festival, and earlier clashes over religion have already cost him. Then he learns that the man is a Galilean, and that the ruler of Galilee, a prince with the emperor’s ear who had very likely reported him once already, is in the city.

    To send the prisoner to Herod costs Pilate nothing. It removes a religious dispute from a Roman court that had no interest in it. It pays a compliment to a dangerous neighbor. And it leaves whatever follows on another man’s account. Far from being out of character, it is what a governor with Pilate’s record would be glad to do.

    Whose Prisoner Was Barabbas?

    There is one more difficulty of this kind, and it concerns the other man in the verse. If Herod is the one who “released the man who had been thrown into prison,” then Barabbas was Herod’s to release. Yet most readers picture Barabbas in a Roman cell in Jerusalem. How could a visiting prince set free a prisoner of the governor?

    The picture of the Roman cell comes from the other gospels. In Mark, Barabbas lies bound “with the rebels who had committed murder in the insurrection,” and it is Pilate who offers him to the crowd (Mark 15:6 to 9). The church’s Luke says that the insurrection “took place in the city.” But that phrase stands in one of the six verses the Evangelion does not have. The Evangelion itself says only that the man had been thrown into prison for insurrection and murder. It does not say where the insurrection was, or whose prison it was.

    Nothing forbids a prisoner of Herod’s. Herod had prisons and used them. He held John in one until he killed him. And Galilee had a name for insurrection in those years. When Herod the Great died, a rebel named Judas seized the weapons stored in the royal palace at Sepphoris, the chief city of Galilee (Antiquities 17.271 to 272). Ten years later a Judas called the Galilean led a rising against the Roman census, and Josephus traces to him the movement that ended in the great revolt (Antiquities 18.4 to 10). A man jailed for insurrection and murder could as well have been a prisoner of the ruler of Galilee as of the governor of Judea.

    Seen that way, the scene before Herod has its own logic. The accusers have followed a Galilean prisoner to the ruler of Galilee. They ask that ruler to let one prisoner go and to do away with the other, and he grants both.

    We do not press this. The Evangelion does not say that Barabbas was Herod’s prisoner, and a reader is free to think that the other gospels knew something it does not tell. We say only that the Evangelion, read by itself, leaves the question open, and that the one detail which would close it stands in a verse the Evangelion does not have.

    Deaths the Governor Did Not Order

    Could the accusers have put a man to death without a Roman sentence? Here the evidence is divided, and both sides should be heard.

    Against it stands a line in the Gospel of John. When Pilate tells the accusers to judge Jesus by their own law, they answer, “It is not lawful for us to put anyone to death” (John 18:31). Sherwin-White and many others take this as an accurate statement of the law: Rome reserved capital punishment to its governors.

    On the other side stands a series of cases. The book of Acts describes the stoning of Stephen in Jerusalem after a hearing before the council, with no governor in sight (7:54 to 60). Josephus records that in the year 62 the high priest Ananus convened the council and had James, the brother of Jesus, stoned with certain others, in the interval after one governor had died and before the next arrived (Antiquities 20.200). Acts tells how a later Herod, Agrippa, “had James the brother of John killed with the sword” (12:2). And a Greek inscription from the temple, a copy of which was found in 1871, warned any foreigner who passed the barrier that he would have himself to blame for his death. Paul Winter and others have argued from such evidence that the Jewish authorities kept more power over life and death than the line in John allows.

    These are not the same case as ours, and we do not pretend they are. Ananus was removed from office for what he did. But they show that in Jerusalem, in that generation, Jewish authorities and Herodian princes did put to death men they regarded as offenders, that it happened more than once, and that Rome did not always prevent it.

    The Stake

    One objection remains, and it is the one most often heard. Fastening a man to a stake to die was a Roman punishment, people say, so a death of that kind proves a Roman sentence.

    The first half of that is mistaken. More than a hundred years before the death of Jesus, Alexander Jannaeus, who was both king and high priest of the Jews, put down a revolt among his own people. Josephus tells what followed. While he feasted with his concubines in full view of the city, Jannaeus had some eight hundred of his captives fastened to stakes, and while they still lived he had their wives and children killed before their eyes (Antiquities 13.380; Jewish War 1.97). Josephus tells the story with horror. The punishment was known in Judea, and a Jewish ruler had used it on a large scale in Jerusalem itself.

    There is evidence, too, that some Jews of the period regarded such a death as a penalty of their own Law. The Law of Moses says that when a man guilty of a capital offense is put to death and hung on a tree, his body must not remain there overnight, “for a hanged man is accursed by God” (Deuteronomy 21:22 to 23). The Temple Scroll, found among the Dead Sea Scrolls, rewrites that law so that the hanging is the means of death: a man who betrays his people “you shall hang him on the tree, and he shall die” (column 64).

    The earliest Christian language about the death of Jesus is the language of that law. In Acts the apostles speak of Jesus “whom you killed by hanging him on a tree” (5:30; compare 10:39). The Herod of the Gospel of Peter cites the same law when he speaks of burying the body before sunset. And Paul, in a verse that both Tertullian and Epiphanius report for Marcion’s text of Galatians, describes the death in exactly these terms: “Christ purchased us from the curse of Law by becoming a curse for us, for it is written: ‘Cursed is everyone who hangs on a tree’” (Galatians 3:13).

    Paul’s point depends on the death being the death the Law curses. He does not describe a Roman penalty to which a text of the Law happens to apply. He describes the Law’s own curse falling on Christ. That reading is at least as natural if the death was carried out by those who lived under the Law as if it was carried out by Rome.

    How Much This Proves

    It proves that the Evangelion’s account is possible. Herod was the prisoner’s own ruler. He had already killed one prophet and had long wanted to see this one. He receives him from the governor’s own hand and gives him up to the accusers. They do what such accusers did on other occasions, by a form of death that their own history and their own Law knew.

    It does not prove that this is what took place. The difficulty about Jerusalem is real, the question of Barabbas is open, the line in John stands against us, and a reader may give these more weight than we do. Our claim is the smaller one. This is what the oldest gospel says, and nothing we know of the time forbids it.