The journal of the True Testament Assembly

    Studies in Marcionite Christianity, Canon, and Origins. Edited by W. C. Muenchow IV

    Topic

    Replies to Critics

    14 articles, newest first

    Halfway Out: Mark Driscoll Left Calvin and Kept the SwaggerIn 2019 Mark Driscoll called the five points of Calvinism garbage, and on God he moved closer to us than to Calvin. But he kept his picture of a man. We checked his verses for men against our canon: some are there, the sharpest are not, and the ones that remain ask for something he does not preach.Nov 10 Jordan Peterson Wrestles With the Wrong GodJordan Peterson's We Who Wrestle with God reads Genesis and Exodus with real insight into the God of order, Law and sacrifice. That is exactly the problem: the God he describes is the Creator, and the Father Christ revealed was never in those books at all.Nov 10 John Piper's God Wants the CreditJohn Piper teaches, more honestly than most, that God governs every calamity for his own glory: the night the 35W bridge fell he told his daughter God had a purpose in letting it fall. Marcion read the same God in Isaiah 45 and agreed with the description. What he denied was the name. This article grants Piper's reading of the Creator, shows that the texts his system leans on, Luke 13:1–5, Romans 9 and Romans 11:36, are not in our edition, and sets his God beside the Father of the Evangelion, who is kind even to the ungrateful and the wicked.Nov 4 Philemon and the Missing Names: How Bilby's Marcionite Paul Reads Silence as HistoryMark Bilby’s 2023 translation of Marcion’s Paul argues that Marcion’s letters came first and the church enlarged them. But it measures Marcion’s Paul by what his enemies quoted, and treats the gaps as history. Philemon exposes the method: Tertullian says it was the one letter Marcion never touched, yet Bilby’s edition leaves its names and “the elder” blank, then counts those blanks as later church additions. The early writers were silent about Philemon because it gave them nothing to fight over. Our True Testament prints it whole, on Tertullian’s word.Oct 22 Nietzsche Buried the Wrong GodNietzsche announced that God is dead but never asked which God. The God he buried was the Law's hard, vengeful judge, a God Marcionites also reject. He then worshipped that same God's world, and never heard of the Father whose goodness was the very standard he used to condemn the old God. He was right that the old God deserved to die, and wrong that there was no other.Oct 22 The Witness for the Defense: What Epiphanius's Own Notebook Shows About Marcion's BibleEpiphanius accused Marcion of mutilating Scripture, but his own notebook of 118 passages from Marcion’s Bible tells against him. He calls most of them true and unaltered and admits his charges of tampering do “no harm.” The German scholars reject his one charge of a changed word, and his final argument rests on a Gospel Marcion never had. Read whole, the church’s star witness testifies for the defense.Oct 22 DeGrasse Tyson Proved Marcion RightIn 2005 Neil deGrasse Tyson wrote an essay against intelligent design. Along the way he made a case that the universe is a violent place and the human body is poorly built, and he joked that "stupid design" could be a movement of its own. Eighteen hundred years earlier, Marcion's followers made the same complaint about the Creator's work, and Tertullian answered them with the same argument from design that Tyson was attacking. This article sets the two debates side by side. Tyson's evidence is good, and I accept it. His conclusion assumes the one thing Marcion denied: that if there is a God at all, he must be the one who made this world.Oct 18 James White Already Believes in Two GodsNobody beats James White on Calvinism, because everyone who debates him on predestination grants his premise before they start: that the God who hardens Pharaoh is the Father of Jesus Christ. This article grants his exegesis instead. The Creator does decree, does harden, did prepare vessels for destruction, and White is right about all of it. What it denies is the identification. The church's one full defense of the Creator against Marcion, Tertullian's Book Two, rests on free will, bare permission, and a Pharaoh who deserved his hardening. White rejects all three in print, so every debate he has won against an Arminian is a debate Marcion wins against Tertullian. The article sets the 1689 Confession's two glories beside Tertullian's two gods, answers secondary causation and the appeal to the cross, and closes with a resolution White has never had to defend: the God who hardened Pharaoh is the Father of Jesus Christ.Oct 12 Marcion Did Not Write the Evangelion: An Answer to Markus VinzentMarkus Vinzent has done more than any living scholar to put Marcion back at the start of the gospel story. In Marcion and the Dating of the Synoptic Gospels (2014) and the books that followed, he argues that the Evangelion came before Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John, and that those four were written in reaction to it. We agree with him on both points. He also argues that Marcion wrote the Evangelion. We don’t agree with that, and the disagreement matters. Oct 3 Nobody’s Got That Kind of Time: Asbury Seminary, the True Testament, and a Canon They Would Not OpenAsbury Theological Seminary devoted an episode to calling Marcionism an old heresy that never dies. Their refusal to receive the eleven books as scripture is expected and unremarkable for a Wesleyan house. This reply answers the smaller and more telling refusal: the decision not to open the canon they were dismissing, and the claims made about a text they would not read.Oct 1 A Response to M. David Litwa on the True TestamentA scholar-to-scholar response to M. David Litwa's review of the True Testament 5th Edition. The author concedes every place the review improved the book, including Laodiceans 5:11-14, and the missing citations for women as elders, and then answers Litwa's charge that printing Probable verses as scripture is spiritually harmful. It sets out the concrete tests a Probable verse must pass, the pastoral rule for reading the two stamps in an assembly, and a defense of printing Galatians 5, 1 Corinthians 2, the unattested letter closes, and Romans 9:1-3.Oct 1 Evidence, Not Epithets: A Point-by-Point Reply to PatristicaPatristica published a ten-part judgment of the True Testament project and asked to be corrected if any evaluation proved false. This article accepts that invitation. Insults establish nothing historical or textual, so each allegation is answered with the reading, source, manuscript, and dataset behind it, along with the honest limits of every claim.Sep 1 Marcionism — And the Scholars Who FlinchedMarcionism is the structural opposite of antisemitism. The split is theological — two gods, two covenants, two aeons — never two peoples. The Evangelion's passion narrative cannot produce a Christ-killer libel, and the modern scholarly flinch that softens Christ's descent out of fear of being called antisemitic gets the argument exactly backward.Aug 24 We Are Not Gnostics: Why Marcionism Is Not, and Has Never Been, GnosticismFor nearly two thousand years, Marcionites have been filed under "Gnostic" by heresy-hunters who could not be bothered to read us. The label is wrong. We have no Pleroma, no thirty Aeons, no Sophia myth, no caste of pneumatics, no salvation by secret knowledge. We have faith in a Good Father who rescues without a curriculum.May 12

    Other topics

    Get NotifiedNew article alerts