Marcion Did Not Write the Evangelion: An Answer to Markus Vinzent
    Scholarship
    Replies to Critics
    The Evangelion

    Marcion Did Not Write the Evangelion: An Answer to Markus Vinzent

    October 3, 2026
    Listen to this article

    Few living scholars have done more than Markus Vinzent to put Marcion back at the start of the gospel story. In Marcion and the Dating of the Synoptic Gospels (2014) and the books that followed, he argues that the Evangelion came before Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John, and that those four were written in reaction to it. We agree with him on both points.

    He also argues that Marcion wrote the Evangelion. We don’t agree with that, and the disagreement matters. Our position is that Marcion received the Evangelion, that it was already the gospel of assemblies before he ever reached Rome, and that his act was to publish it with ten letters of Paul. The four church gospels answer that publication. This article explains why we think the evidence Vinzent uses points to a man who inherited a book, and away from a man who composed one.

    Where we stand with Vinzent

    Three agreements come first, so that nobody takes this for a wider quarrel than it is.

    The Evangelion is earlier than canonical Luke. The fathers’ story that Marcion took the church’s Luke and cut it is their theory of why his gospel was shorter, and it rests on the premise that the church’s copy had to be the original. Vinzent rejects that story, and so do we.

    The church’s gospels are late. Vinzent asks where they were hidden if they had existed for decades, since on his reading no writer before the middle of the second century plainly uses them. The usual answer is Papias, who speaks of writings by Mark and Matthew (Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History 3.39). That answer presses on Vinzent and on us alike. We think it settles less than it is asked to, because it only works if the books Papias meant are the church’s gospels in the form we have.

    The four are replies to Marcion’s gospel. Klinghardt also puts the Evangelion first, but for him the other gospels were made by copying and reworking it in stages, and as we read him that process does not hinge on Marcion issuing the book in Rome. Vinzent is the one who says the four exist because Marcion’s gospel was in front of their authors. We take that from him.

    What we leave with him is the claim about who wrote it.

    What Vinzent claims

    As we understand him, the account runs in two stages. Marcion composed a gospel as a tool for his school. Vinzent describes it as written “for his classroom (without Antitheses and perhaps without Paul’s letters).” It carried no title and no author’s name because it was not meant for the public. Copies got out. Others took the text and reworked it into gospels of their own, and those are the beginnings of Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John. Marcion then answered. He wrote the Antitheses, charged the others with tampering, and issued his gospel a second time, now under the bare title Gospel and with the ten letters, as a new testament.

    Vinzent writes that in that book he proposed Marcion as “the very first author who wrote a Gospel and created this literary genre.” Against those of us who say Marcion used an older text, he says it is a claim “for which we have not a single evidence, just as for the four later canonical gospels.”

    His evidence, as far as we have followed it, comes largely from Tertullian’s fourth book. The gospel had no author’s name and no title, which he takes as the sign of a text not meant for publication (Against Marcion 4.2.3). Marcion works to pull down the standing of the gospels published under the names of apostles (4.3.2). The Antitheses complain of interpolation (4.4.4). It is a serious reading of a difficult source. We think it reads that source against its grain, and the next four sections say where.

    Neither side in the second century said he composed it

    Start with what the two ancient parties said. The men who wrote against Marcion said he took a gospel that already existed and cut it. The Marcionites said he restored what had been adulterated. Neither described a man composing a gospel of his own from nothing.

    Tertullian preserves the Marcionite side in their own voice. “For they say that Marcion did not so much innovate the rule of the separation of the Law and the Gospel as he restored it after it had been adulterated in the past” (Against Marcion 1.20.1). The Latin is retro adulteratam recurasse. Then he mocks them for it. Christ, he says, “for so many years endured the subversion of your preaching until, of course, Marcion should come to your rescue!” What they say he restored is the rule, the separation of Law and Gospel, and they place the adulteration in the past. The mockery only lands if the Marcionites really did say the corruption was old.

    He puts the same claim into his own sarcastic words in the fourth book, where Marcion comes forward as “the corrector of the gospel, which had been overthrown from the time of Tiberius even to the times of Antoninus” (4.4.5). By Tertullian’s own count that span is about 115 and a half years (1.19.2). People who say the gospel was damaged across a century are not describing a draft that left a classroom a few years earlier. On Vinzent’s account the tampering happened in Marcion’s own lifetime, to Marcion’s own book. The Marcionite claim Tertullian is answering reaches back to the apostles, because they bring up Peter and the other pillars as men Paul rebuked (1.20.2).

    The fourth-book sentence is sarcasm, and we don’t lean on it alone. The weight is on 1.20.1–2, where Tertullian introduces the words with “they say.”

    The charge in the Antitheses points the same way. Tertullian reports that Marcion criticized the gospel the church assigns to Luke as “interpolated by the defenders of Judaism for the purpose of incorporating the law and the prophets” (4.4.4). Where did Marcion learn that there were such defenders? Tertullian tells us. It was from Galatians, where he found the apostles reproached as “not walking with a straight foot toward the truth of the Gospel” and false apostles accused of “perverting the Gospel of Christ” (4.3.2). The corrupters Marcion had in view were the men Paul fought, so his complaint reaches back to a first-century quarrel over the gospel.

    Vinzent has an answer to this, as Godfrey reports him. Marcion only cited Paul’s rebuke, and the picture of apostles tampering with gospels is Tertullian “drawing consequences on assumptions purely made for rhetorical reasons.” That may be right about 4.3. It does not remove 1.20.1–2, where the Marcionites themselves are reported bringing up Peter and the pillars.

    Tertullian’s own verbs deserve a look. Marcion “could not have criticized it unless he had found it” (4.4.4), and he was “correcting what he found” (4.4.5). Tertullian means the church’s Luke, and Vinzent can fairly answer that what Marcion found and criticized were the rival gospels. So we don’t rest our case on that verb. We rest it on the kind of charge Tertullian brings. He calls Marcion’s book the gospel “which he has by manipulation made his own” (4.1.1, in Evans’s translation) and says he made it “his own and new by composing it from the correction of ours” (4.4.5). The accusation is alteration of a gospel that existed. Tertullian’s corrector and the Marcionites’ restorer are both men working on something they received.

    If any sentence in Tertullian could be read in favor of a leaked draft, it is 4.4.2, where he says it would be absurd for Marcion’s gospel to be “believed to have experienced rivalry from ours before it was even published.” But he is building a reductio from his own premise that the church’s Luke is older. He isn’t reporting a Marcionite memory of a draft that got out, and nothing in the sentence says Marcion composed anything.

    He signed what he wrote

    Vinzent takes the missing name as the mark of a school text. Tertullian’s words are, “Marcion attributes no author to his gospel” (4.2.3).

    Set that beside what Tertullian says of the other book. “Certainly, the Antitheses not only confess Marcion’s authorship but also display it” (4.4.4). Marcion put his name on his own work. He wrote a letter, and it went out as his (4.4.3). The one book that carried no name is the book Vinzent says he composed.

    He had every reason to name it if it was his to name. Tertullian notices that he didn’t even borrow Paul’s name for it, and writes, “even if Marcion had introduced a gospel under the very name of Paul” (4.2.4). On Vinzent’s account Marcion issued the gospel a second time precisely to defend it against rivals that carried apostles’ names. Even then, on Vinzent’s own telling, it went out under the bare title Gospel. That was the moment to put an author’s name on it, and he let it pass. A man handing on a book that came to him without a name leaves it as it came.

    His assemblies went on reading it that way. In the Dialogue of Adamantius, generations later, the Marcionite Megethius argues that the church’s four are false and that there is one Gospel (1.5–8). Asked who wrote it, he answers “Christ.” Pressed on the crucifixion, he says “The Apostle Paul added that,” and that Paul “plainly wrote the Gospel” (1.8, in Pretty’s translation). The dialogue is a late and hostile composition, so it shows what Marcionites were understood to say and is no transcript. What they were understood to say is that the gospel came from Christ and Paul. In that exchange nobody claims it for Marcion.

    The Apostolikon already knows an Evangelion

    Marcion’s reading of Galatians is ours too. In the Apostolikon the Evangelion is something received and handed on long before Marcion was born. Paul writes, “I make known to you, brothers and sisters, that the Evangelion proclaimed by me is not according to man. For I neither received it from man nor was I taught it, but I received it through a revelation of Christ Jesus” (Galatians 1:10–11 TT). He went up to Jerusalem and “set before them the Evangelion that I proclaim among the nations” (Galatians 2:2 TT). He would not yield, “so that the truth of the Evangelion might remain with you” (Galatians 2:5 TT). And he already knows people who “wish to change it into a different message of Christ” (Galatians 1:6 TT).

    What Paul hands on has a story in it. “For I received from the Lord what I also delivered to you, that the Lord Jesus on the night he was betrayed took bread” (1 Corinthians 11:17 TT). “For I handed on to you first of all that Christ died for our sins” (1 Corinthians 15:3 TT).

    We aren’t claiming these verses prove that a written book lay on Paul’s table. Paul’s Evangelion is first a proclamation. What the verses do show is that the assemblies Paul founded had a gospel with a narrative of the Lord in it, that it was passed from hand to hand, and that people who wanted to fit it to the Law were already working on it. That is the situation the Antitheses described.

    Tertullian saw this and tried to turn it into a trap. If there really was an authentic gospel, he asks, what became of “that authentic instrument of the apostles that suffered adulteration, that enlightened Paul” (4.3.4)? The Marcionite answer was that it was the book in their hands. “I say that mine is true, Marcion says that his is true” (4.4.1). Marcion came from Pontus, in the same Asia Minor where Paul’s assemblies in Galatia and Asia stood. A gospel kept in those assemblies and carried to Rome is a simpler history than a gospel composed in Marcion’s school and then read back onto Paul.

    The Evangelion keeps what its supposed author would not have written

    If Marcion composed the Evangelion around 140 to carry his teaching, the book ought to say what he taught. In a good many places it says things his teaching had to work around. Tertullian’s whole fourth book runs on that fact. He goes through Marcion’s gospel in order and argues, passage after passage, that it refutes Marcion.

    • The leper is told “to go and show himself to the priest, and to give the offering for healing that Moses had commanded” (Evangelion 2:15 TT; Tertullian 4.9).
    • On the mountain, “Suddenly two men appeared, talking with him: Moses and Elijah” (Evangelion 5:38 TT; Tertullian 4.22).
    • Abraham says, “They have Moses and the prophets; they should listen to them” (Evangelion 10:33 TT; Tertullian 4.34).
    • Someone tells him, “Your mother and brothers are standing outside, wanting to see you” (Evangelion 4:35b TT; Tertullian 4.19), and a woman calls out, “Blessed is the mother who gave birth to you and nursed you!” (Evangelion 7:20 TT; Tertullian 4.26).
    • After the resurrection he says, “A spirit doesn’t have bones, as you see I have,” and asks, “Do you have anything here to eat?” (Evangelion 16:30–31 TT; Tertullian 4.43).

    Each of these gave Tertullian something to hold. A teacher writing freely would not have handed his opponents a mother, a priest’s offering, Moses on the mountain, and a risen body that eats. A teacher who had received the book, and held it too sacred to rewrite, would leave those lines standing and explain them. Tertullian reports such explanations (4.9.10; 4.43.7), and he concedes the fact while suspecting the motive: Marcion “deliberately did not want to erase some things from his gospel that contradicted him” (4.43.7).

    Guiding that reading is what the Antitheses were for. Tertullian says Marcion composed that work to divide Law from Gospel and to support his gospel (4.1.1). A gospel that needs a second book beside it to be read rightly is not likely to have come from the author of that second book. He could have written the first one so that it needed no help.

    Vinzent can answer that Marcion’s real theology was not what his enemies said it was, and in places that may be so. But then the Antitheses, the two gods, and the charge of Judaizing interpolation all become uncertain too, and those are the supports of his own account.

    What authorship would cost

    This section is confession more than history, and we mark it that way.

    If Marcion wrote the Evangelion, its words are his. The sayings of Christ become the composition of a second-century teacher in the reign of Antoninus, and Tertullian’s argument from time wins outright. He argued that what first came forward under Antoninus did not come forward under Tiberius (1.19.3), and that “truth must necessarily precede falsehood” (4.4.1). Vinzent’s Marcion gives him the premise he wanted.

    Our assemblies have never read the Evangelion as Marcion’s book. Paul says the Evangelion “is not according to man” (Galatians 1:10 TT). We honor Marcion as the man who refused to let it be merged with the Law and who put it in the open. Authorship is a different honor, and by every report we have he never claimed it.

    There is a plain historical cost as well. Vinzent’s model needs two releases of the same gospel, a leak from a classroom, four separate reworkings, and then a reply, and no ancient writer reports any of it. Ours needs one book that existed before Marcion and one publication.

    Where Roth and Barker stand

    Two critics belong on the table. Both reject Vinzent, and neither would accept our account either.

    Dieter Roth’s The Text of Marcion’s Gospel (2015) is the most cautious modern reconstruction. He reviewed Vinzent’s book in the Journal of Theological Studies. There he quotes Vinzent’s conclusion “that Marcion wrote the very first Gospel and that all four canonical Gospels used Marcion’s Gospel as a source,” and he judges some of Vinzent’s interpretations “idiosyncratic, often debated or debatable, and in some instances simply indefensible.” In his own edition he says the thesis rests on a number of misreadings of Tertullian (p. 164, n. 366). In a shorter notice he states a rule: “arguments from silence based on Marcion’s supposed theological proclivities should not be employed when considering what was or was not present in Marcion’s Gospel.” Roth’s edition leaves open which gospel came first. He wants the wording settled from the sources before anyone builds a history on it.

    Roth helps us on one point and tests us on another. His complaint against Vinzent is the one this article makes, that Tertullian does not say what Vinzent needs him to say. His rule about silence binds us as well. Where we say Luke added and Marcion did not cut, we have to show it from attested wording and not from what suits our teaching.

    James Barker, in Writing and Rewriting the Gospels (2025), calls Vinzent’s case “wholly unconvincing” and cites Clare Rothschild’s review, which placed the monograph in “a nonscientific genre.” Barker’s own account, as we understand it, keeps the usual order, with each evangelist rewriting those before him and John using the Synoptics. That leaves no room for a gospel in Marcion’s hands before the four, so Barker stands against Vinzent’s dating and against ours.

    Neither man is arguing our case. We cite them because the objection that Vinzent overreads Tertullian is made by scholars with no stake in Marcion.

    What we can’t show, and what we hold

    We should be as plain about our limits as we have been about his. No manuscript of the Evangelion survives from before Marcion, or from his assemblies at all. Vinzent is right that nobody can produce a witness who names the Evangelion before about 140. Our case is an inference from four things: what both ancient parties said Marcion did, what he signed and what he left unsigned, what Paul’s letters say about a gospel already handed on, and what the Evangelion contains that no Marcionite author would have invented. Most scholars accept neither Vinzent’s account nor ours, and still put Luke first.

    With that said, this is the order as we hold it. The Evangelion was read in assemblies that came from Paul. Marcion received it there. He carried it to Rome, wrote the Antitheses to show how it stands against the Law, and published it with ten letters of Paul. Once it was public, churches that meant to keep one God and one Israel had to answer in books, and Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John are that answer.

    Sources

    Ancient writers

    Tertullian, Against Marcion 1.19.2–3; 1.20.1–2; 4.1.1; 4.2.3–4; 4.3.2; 4.3.4; 4.4.1–5; 4.9.9–10; 4.19.6–7; 4.22.1; 4.26.13; 4.34.10; 4.43.6–8. English from the translation of the Latin in the True Testament library, except 4.1.1, which is from Ernest Evans, Tertullian: Adversus Marcionem (Oxford: Clarendon, 1972).

    Dialogue of Adamantius 1.5–8. The English of 1.8 is from Robert A. Pretty, Adamantius: Dialogue on the True Faith in God (Leuven: Peeters, 1997), 46, as quoted at Adamantius’s Comments on Marcion, and checked against the text in the True Testament library.

    Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History 3.39, for Papias on Mark and Matthew.

    True Testament

    Evangelion 2:15; 4:35b; 5:38; 7:20; 10:33; 16:30–31. Galatians 1:6; 1:10–11; 2:2; 2:5. 1 Corinthians 11:17; 15:3. All by True Testament numbering.

    Modern studies

    Vinzent, Markus. Marcion and the Dating of the Synoptic Gospels. Studia Patristica Supplements 2. Leuven: Peeters, 2014. The “classroom” wording is quoted from this book in the survey at Priority of the Gospel of Marcion. The “not a single evidence” wording is from his later note on the circulated draft at academia.edu.

    Vinzent, Markus. “Marcion’s Gospel and the Beginnings of Early Christianity.” Annali di Storia dell’Esegesi 32, no. 1 (2015): 55–87. The “very first author” wording is from pages 63–65, as quoted by Godfrey.

    Godfrey, Neil. “Finding the Author of the First Gospel?” Vridar, 18 May 2026. Our source for the 2015 quotation, for the “rhetorical reasons” quotation, for Vinzent’s question about where the gospels were hidden (cited there as Vinzent 2023, 159), and for his account of the untitled school text and the retitled second release (cited there as Vinzent 2014, 97, 100, 277).

    Klinghardt, Matthias. The Oldest Gospel and the Formation of the Canonical Gospels. Leuven: Peeters, 2021.

    Almanzar, Jordan. Review of Klinghardt, The Oldest Gospel and the Formation of the Canonical Gospels. Reviews of Biblical and Early Christian Studies, 23 December 2022. Our check on the summary of Klinghardt’s model.

    Roth, Dieter T. Review of Vinzent, Marcion and the Dating of the Synoptic Gospels. Journal of Theological Studies 66, no. 2 (2015): 800–803.

    Roth, Dieter T. “Roth on Vinzent on Marcion.” Guest post on Larry Hurtado’s blog, 11 March 2015. Source of the rule on arguments from silence.

    Roth, Dieter T. The Text of Marcion’s Gospel. New Testament Tools, Studies and Documents 49. Leiden: Brill, 2015. The note on Vinzent is at p. 164, n. 366, as cited in the Wikipedia survey above.

    Barker, James W. Writing and Rewriting the Gospels: John and the Synoptics. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2025. His verdict on Vinzent, and his citation of Clare Rothschild’s review, are quoted from the Wikipedia survey above.

    BeDuhn, Jason D. The First New Testament: Marcion’s Scriptural Canon. Salem, OR: Polebridge, 2013.

    From our own library

    The History of Marcionite Reconstruction, chapter 6. The Marcionite Centuries, chapter 3. The Charges Against Marcion, chapter 4. Christ Without Bloodline, chapter 4.