Chapter 3 of 11

    Part One, First Division: Outlines of Marcion’s Doctrine

    7 min read

    [p. 25]

    Part One. The Decision of the Main Question

    First Division. Outlines of Marcion’s Doctrine

    Sources:

    Justini Martyris Apol. [Justin Martyr, Apology.] [Author’s addition: see p. 178; Irenaeus, Against Heresies 1, ch. 28 (otherwise 1, ch. 27).]

    Tertulliani adversus Marcionem L. I—V. [Tertullian, Against Marcion, Books 1–5.]

    Irenaei contra Haereses L. I, c. 28. [Irenaeus, Against Heresies, Book 1, ch. 28.]1

    The twofold character which Christianity had from its origin, that it went out from one particular people, the Jewish, but had its destination for all mankind, all peoples, that it was connected with the Old Testament order of things, proceeded from it, but was nevertheless something new, universal, has in the nature of the case not only, immediately after its emergence, brought about the opposition between the apostles of Israel, especially Peter, and the apostle of the Gentiles, Paul, between Jewish Christianity and Gentile Christianity, but also, after both sides, in the innermost consciousness that they belonged together to the one great principle in its historical mediation, had found a certain mediation with one another, has still further, and then only in ever sharper contrast, called forth oppositions, upon the constant mediation and overcoming of which the universal Christian community, “the Church of Peter and Paul”, which is also the evangelical one, has built itself up.

    Over against the exclusive Judaism, Ebionitism, which found in Jesus nothing but the Messiah for the Jewish people, the Son of David, the one born of Judah, who wanted only to make the Law firm, only fulfilled the Prophets, there formed itself an exclusive Hellenism, a Christianity that wanted to be absolutely universal, which emphasized what was new in it, the reconciliation, the redemption, the salvation, the final revelation of the truth, the knowledge (γνῶσις) of the depths of the Godhead, and for which Christ, proceeding immediately from God, was the revealer of what was formerly unknown, of the wholly new, of the God of grace for all, unknown until then, in whom

    Volkmar’s notes [p. 25]

    1. [p. 25, n. 1] Compare Epiphanius, Panarion 42. Dialogus (Adamantii) de recta dei fide [Dialogue (of Adamantius) on the Right Faith in God], Sections 1–3. ↩

    [p. 26]

    the abolition of the particular Jewish nature, hateful toward the others, and of its Law in particular, was found.

    To this absorption in the universal, in the depths of the divine being as of the being of the world, there belonged, however, in particular the question: whence the ill and the evil in it, this hatred, this discord? And the less it seemed that the pure divine being could be the cause of this impurity and division, the more one was intent on regarding it as the higher being, standing above all discord in the world, above the world itself, but on separating the creator of the latter (δημιουργός, Creator, κοςμοκράτωρ, θεὸς τῆς γενέσεως [Demiurge, Creator, ruler of the world, god of generation]) from it just as much as spirit stands over against matter, the good against the evil, love against hatefulness, blessedness against torment.

    And indeed the first step now was to set over against the God of the spirit, as the good one, the God through whom evil comes, as himself evil from the ground up, so that then, however, at the same time the good God was represented as formerly unknown, first proclaimed through Christ.

    On the other hand a closer consideration, in particular the comparison of the earlier revelation, the Old Testament, could after all not fail to recognize that the God revealed in it is after all not so bad from the ground up, that he is indeed cruel and harsh (deus saevus [a savage god]), a being that inflicts ill, divides and brings about dissension, humanly passionate, lower, in relation to the God of grace and love who embraces all peoples and stands high above this, whom Christianity taught (or ought to teach); but even if the Demiurge in the Old Testament is weak, even partial and in conflict with himself, he nevertheless has the will to be just, and precisely as a just judge he is so harsh and cruel in his inexorability. This advance in the closer definition of the Old Testament God was made by Cerdon and, carrying out his separation of the just and the good God, by Marcion in particular.2 Only in this way is the Demiurge the author of evil, that he was able to create only an imperfect world at all, the material one, given over to sensuality, and in particular created a world of spirits, angels, who fell wholly into sensuality (at their head Lucifer, who then became Satan) and now unceasingly seduced man, took possession of him and tormented him.

    Now for redemption from all this torment, which belonged to the imperfect, sensual world of the world-god, who though just was yet imperfect, the God of mercy and of grace sent from his heaven Jesus Christ [that is, the sanctified

    Volkmar’s notes [p. 26]

    1. [p. 26, n. 1] Irenaeus, in the place cited, § 1: Cerdon — quum venisset Romam sub Hygino — docuit eum qui a lege et prophetis annuntiatus sit deus non esse Patrem Domini nostri J. Ch... et alterum quidem iustum alterum autem bonum esse. [Cerdon — when he had come to Rome under Hyginus — taught that the God who was proclaimed by the Law and the Prophets is not the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ ... and that the one is just, but the other good.] § 2. Succedens autem ei Marcion Ponticus adampliavit doctrinam impudice blasphemans eum, qui a lege et prophetis annuntiatus est deus; malorum factorem et bellorum concupiscentem et inconstantem quoque sententia et contrarium sibi ipsi dicens. [But Marcion of Pontus, succeeding him, enlarged the doctrine, shamelessly blaspheming the God who was proclaimed by the Law and the Prophets, calling him a maker of evils and one who lusts after wars and also inconstant in purpose and contrary to himself.] ↩

    [p. 27]

    Savior]; and indeed he had appeared ad salutem omnium gentium [for the salvation of all nations] in this way, that he refuted (arguere, redarguere, ἐλέγχειν [to convict, to refute, to expose]) the revelation of the God of the world and of the Jews, “the Law and the Prophets”, and so dissolved it (καταλύειν [to destroy]). This he did partly by showing the inner contradiction in it, partly already by the revelation of the good God himself, who until then was wholly unknown (deus ignotus [the unknown god]), and of his spiritual kingdom, which stands wholly opposed to the kingdom of the Demiurge. As the creator of the corrupted world, who is revealed in the Old Testament and has chosen out the Jewish people for himself, is in conflict with the God of the spirit who embraces all with mercy and love, so also the Old Testament forms only one great antithesis to the new, this wholly new revelation, or one great series of oppositions (ἀντιθέσεις [antitheses]), which Marcion had then especially brought out. And Christianity is true only when it is purified from every mixture with what belongs to the Old Testament and with the sensual and fleshly nature that goes with it, as the apostle Paul began to do over against the apostles of the Jews, who themselves half adhered to the Demiurge, and as it is to be carried through by strict rejection on the one hand of every use of the Old Testament, on the other of all fleshliness, in particular of marriage — for the creare [creating] is a service of the creator — as well as even of flesh foods, through a purely spiritual striving and living. — The opposition of the two kingdoms is completed by this, that over against the Christ of the good God, who himself cannot stem from this world, has nothing in common with fleshliness, there now also steps a Messiah of the Demiurge, such as the Old Testament is said to announce and who will come first with all terror to judge the peoples (probably also to rescue the people of this God from the power of the heathen); but whoever belongs to the God of the spirit and stands faithful, to him this terrible one can do nothing. Finally, however, the true Christ will come again, in order, as formerly the Law and the Prophets, so now to annul the works and the kingdom of the Demiurge, which has then fully unfolded itself.

    These are the outlines3 of this doctrine of purity, of pure Christianness, of pure grace and spirituality, which did indeed go far beyond Paul, but is nevertheless rooted in his universalistic-pneumatic nature, and so, down to the fifth century, held bound to itself a very large part of Christendom in all Christian regions, not without undergoing manifold developments. Thus Marcionitism later developed, in particular with regard to the doctrine of the origin of evil, to the point that one part, more consistently, set the evil being outright as a third primal being beside the good God and the Demiurge (which Epiphanius, Panarion 42, together with many other later heresiologists, wrongly ascribe to Marcion himself), while others, on the other hand, just as consistently returned to the simpler

    Volkmar’s notes [p. 27]

    1. [p. 27, n. 1] The details will follow at the relevant passages of the Gospel. ↩

    [p. 28]

    doctrine, that the Demiurge is at the same time the evil being itself (as the Marcionite Marcus in the Dialogue adv. M. [against the Marcionites] 3).

    In these essential changes, however, there came to light only the symptoms of the essential inconsistency which was inseparable from these abstract separations, and it is through this conflict within itself and with the nature of things itself that this once so dangerous heresy perished, more than through the ever grimmer attacks of the orthodox teachers of the Church, among whom Marcion’s countryman, Tertullian, by showing on all sides the eternal unity of God in all his revelations, especially distinguished himself by intellect, power and acuteness.