Conclusion

    After the Account

    5 min read

    Alexandria, in the fifteenth year of Marcus Aurelius (AD 175)

    It is finished, and I have not answered the question, and I said I would tell you at the end if I knew.

    I do not know. I will tell you which way I lean, which is more than I have told anyone.

    Philumene is in the next room. I have not written about her and I am not going to, except to say this. She is a prophetess. She sees things, and what she sees is one God and a Son who put on a body of the elements and gave it back when he was done. I believe her, mostly. I have built a school on her seeing the way Marcion built one on a book, and the difference is that nobody can lay her seeing on the left and a scroll on the right and put a finger on each. I have thought about that more than I have thought about anything else in twenty years. He gave me a method and I left him for a vision, and the method was what I loved him for.

    I promised to say what I did with the Hebrews my father sent. I kept it on the shelf with the ten letters. When young men ask what it is, I say it is a letter some say is Paul’s. I do not say I know it is not. I do not say that a man I loved told me not to teach it. I let it sit there under his name because it is beautiful and because the young men like it. I have one God now, and a letter that gives the Creator’s whole temple to Christ is a comfort to a man with one God. That is not to my credit. He would have said it in three sentences. I have taken five.

    With the three letters to the two men I did nothing. I have never taught them. I have never let them be copied in this house. When Rhodo comes, which he will, he will ask why a man who teaches one God and rejects the prophets as the work of an adverse spirit will not touch three short letters that have one God in every line. I will not be able to tell him. The answer is that an old Pontic in a room over a leather-worker’s said do not. It is the only thing he ever asked of me, and I have kept it, and I do not know why I have kept that and not the rest. Rhodo will write down that I said the question of God should not be examined too closely. I will have said it. It will be true. It is the sentence of a man who has examined it for twenty years and found that it is not a question with one answer in it, whatever he teaches at the front of the room.

    What I want to leave you with is his and not mine.

    The books are winning. The letter from Rome says four gospels, bound, with the Acts after them and the three letters inside Paul and a bishop’s name on every city. Irenaeus is gathering what he can against us in Gaul, I am told, and he has Polycarp’s sentence word for word. He does not have what came after, because he was not in the Vicus Tuscus and I was. Justin’s book against us was written and I do not think it will last. There will be others. There will be a great many others. In a hundred years, in two hundred, there will be men in every city from Carthage to Edessa who have never seen a chest, who have only ever seen four books with the Evangelion third. They will write that Marcion took the third and cut it, and they will quote him. They will have to. You cannot say what a man said wrong without saying what he said. They will quote the Antitheses to refute them, line by line, left and right. They will quote the ten letters to show where he cut, and they will quote the Evangelion to show what he left out. They will quote his letter to the Roman assembly to prove he was once one of them. They will do it thoroughly. They will do it for centuries. Every copy of his will be burned, and every copy of theirs will be kept. One day a careful man, in a language I will not know, will sit down with nothing but the enemies and read him out of them.

    He said that on the twelfth day. He said, a careful man will be able to read me out of them. I have thought it was a dying man’s comfort. I think now it was a merchant’s calculation. He had spent his life putting the older text on the left and the newer on the right and finding the clause that was in the interest of the man with the pen. He knew that a man who quotes you to condemn you has put you on the left of his own page, and that the next careful reader will find you there.

    So I lean, and I lean toward thinking that I was the one who made it simpler than it is. I could not hold two in my hands and so I made one of them small, and called it an angel, and called the Law a spirit’s lie. What I could not hold was not two gods but one Father large enough to reach the other one. He said: you cannot forgive him, so you have made him small enough not to need it. I have been twenty years in Alexandria with one God and a prophetess and a shelf, and I have not forgiven the Creator. Marcion did not need to, because he was not the one doing the reaching.

    That is as far as I can go. It is further than I meant to.

    The lamp is low. Philumene is asleep. The grain fleet goes out in the morning for Rome, and I will put this on it, to Valeria, who did not leave. She will read it and say that I put what I did not want to say at the end, where I could pretend it was not the point, and she will be right. She will send it on to Lucan, who will have it by heart in a week and will say it to shepherds without the parts about me.

    I am sixty-one years old. I was his for fifteen years, from an afternoon when he asked me to read a page three times, and I left him on a morning when he did not ask me to stay. In twenty years I have not stopped hearing him put his finger on the line and look up.

    Do you hear it?