Chapter 4 of 24

    How the Church Changed the Promise

    5 min read

    0:006:13

    🎧 Listen while you read

    Around the year 160 a Christian philosopher named Justin published a debate he said he had held with a Jewish teacher called Trypho. Justin wrote it to win the argument, and for the most part Trypho is given the weaker lines. But at one point Justin lets him state the Jewish objection to Jesus at full strength. The scriptures, Trypho says, “compel us to wait for Him who, as Son of man, receives from the Ancient of days the everlasting kingdom. But this so-called Christ of yours was dishonourable and inglorious” (Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 32).

    That is the problem of the last three chapters in two sentences. The prophets describe a figure who receives an everlasting kingdom. Jesus received a Roman execution. The church had staked everything on the claim that Jesus was the Christ of the prophets, so it could not concede the point. Over the next three centuries it worked out three answers, one on top of another, and together they became what most Christians believe today without knowing it was ever argued.

    The First Answer: He Is Coming Twice

    Justin’s own reply to Trypho was that the Messiah has two comings. In the first he arrives humble and is put to death. In the second he returns in glory and does everything the prophets said. The prophecies of suffering belong to the first visit and the prophecies of the throne to the second.

    It is a clever answer, and Tertullian, a church writer of North Africa whom we will meet in the next chapter, used it against the Marcionites a generation later. Its difficulty is that no prophet says it. Isaiah, Micah and Jeremiah do not describe a king who comes, fails to take the throne, leaves for an unstated number of centuries and then comes back. They describe one arrival. The two comings are a way of dealing with the fact that the one arrival people witnessed did not produce the kingdom.

    Set Justin’s solution beside Marcion’s, because they are answers to the same question, written in the same city in the same years. Both men saw that the prophecies of the throne had not come true in Jesus. Justin kept one Christ and gave him two comings. Marcion kept one coming and recognized two Christs.

    The Second Answer: It Was Never Meant Literally

    The second answer came from Alexandria in Egypt, where Christian scholars had learned from Greek philosophers how to read old texts as allegories. Its great name is Origen, who wrote in the first half of the third century.

    Origen describes the situation with unusual candor. The Jews, he says, did not believe in Jesus because they read the prophets according to the letter. They expected to see captives released, the war chariots removed and the wolf feeding beside the lamb, and when they saw none of it at his coming they concluded he was not the Christ. Origen does not dispute what they saw. He agrees that none of those things happened in the form the prophets described. His conclusion is that the prophets must not have meant them in that form. The chariots, the captives and the wolf are figures for spiritual realities (Origen, On First Principles 4.2.1).

    In the same passage he mentions a second group who also read the scriptures according to the letter. These were the heretics, by whom he chiefly means the followers of Marcion. They took the prophets and the Law at face value, he says, and concluded that such writings belonged to the Creator, the God of the Jews, and that the Savior had come to announce a different and more perfect God.

    So Origen lays out the choice himself. If you read the prophets as they are written, either you wait for another Messiah as the Jews do, or you conclude with Marcion that the Messiah of the prophets and the Christ who came are not the same. Only if you read them as allegory can you keep Jesus on the throne of David. Origen chose allegory, and the church followed him.

    The Third Answer: The Kingdom Is the Church

    The third answer followed from the second. If the throne and the kingdom are spiritual, something has to be named as the thing they stand for, and the candidate nearest to hand was the church.

    For a time some Christians went further. In the year 325 the emperor Constantine, the first Roman ruler to favor Christianity, gave a banquet for the bishops who had gathered at the Council of Nicaea, the first great meeting of bishops from across the empire. Eusebius, a bishop and historian who was there, wrote that as the guests passed between the ranks of the imperial guard and reclined at the emperor’s table, one might have thought it “a picture of Christ’s kingdom” (Eusebius, Life of Constantine 3.15). Bishops whose predecessors had been hunted by the empire were now dining with it, and the kingdom the prophets promised seemed to have arrived in the form of a Christian government.

    A century later Augustine, the bishop of Hippo in North Africa and the most influential theologian the Western church ever produced, put the matter in the form it would keep for the next thousand years. The reign of Christ foretold in the scriptures, he taught, is not a future kingdom on earth. It is going on now, in the church. “The Church even now is the kingdom of Christ, and the kingdom of heaven” (Augustine, The City of God 20.9).

    What the Three Answers Admit

    Each of these answers was the work of a serious and gifted man, and I do not doubt the sincerity of any of them. Each one also begins by granting the point Trypho made. Justin grants that the first coming did not bring the kingdom, and adds a second. Origen grants that the prophecies were not fulfilled as written, and reads them another way. Augustine grants that there is no throne in Jerusalem, and finds the kingdom in the church.

    None of them says the simple thing, which is that a promise of a king, a throne and a restored nation, made in ordinary words, was not kept by a man who was never a king, never sat on a throne and restored no nation. They could not say it, because they were committed in advance to the belief that the God of the prophets and the Father of Jesus are one and the same. Given that belief, Jesus had to be the promised Christ, and the promise had to be adjusted until it fit him.

    One group of Christians in the second century was not committed to that belief, and they were free to say the simple thing.