In 1947 a Bedouin shepherd looking for a stray goat near the northwestern shore of the Dead Sea threw a stone into a cave and heard pottery break. Inside were clay jars, and inside the jars were scrolls. Over the next decade the caves around a ruin called Qumran gave up the remains of some nine hundred manuscripts, the library of a Jewish community that had lived there from about two centuries before Jesus until the Romans destroyed the settlement in the year 68.
The Dead Sea Scrolls matter for this book because of who did not handle them. No church copied them and no later rabbi edited them. They let us hear Jews of the time of Jesus speaking about the Messiah in their own words, and what they say can be set beside the other Jewish writings of those centuries.
A King and a Priest
The people of Qumran were stricter than almost anyone else in Israel, and they had withdrawn to the desert because they considered the priests in Jerusalem corrupt. Their rule book looks forward to the day when there will come “the Messiahs of Aaron and Israel” (Community Rule 9.11). They expected two anointed figures, a high priest from the line of Aaron, the brother of Moses, and beside him a king.
Other scrolls say who the king is. They call him “the Branch of David,” taking the title from the prophecies we looked at in the last chapter, and they have him arise in Zion at the end of days to save Israel. One of them describes a final war in which he leads Israel against the armies of the nations and puts their commander to death.
These were people who disagreed with the rest of Judaism about nearly everything, including the calendar. On the royal Messiah they said what everyone else said. He would be David’s descendant, he would appear in Jerusalem, and he would win.
The Prayer After Pompey
We met the Psalms of Solomon briefly in Chapter 1. They come from a different quarter of Jewish life, probably from circles close to the Pharisees, a movement devoted to strict observance of the Law, and they were written after the Roman general Pompey walked into the temple in 63 BC. The seventeenth of them is the fullest description of the Messiah to survive from before the time of Jesus, and its central plea is that God would “raise up for them their king, the son of David” (Psalms of Solomon 17:21).
The poet then lists what this king will do. He will shatter unrighteous rulers and clear Jerusalem of the foreigners who trample it. He will gather a holy people and divide them by their tribes upon the land, and the nations will come from the ends of the earth to see his glory. The poet is careful to say that the king will not put his trust in horses or stockpile gold for war, because his strength comes from God. He is a righteous king and a devout one. He is also, without any ambiguity, a king.
The Oracle That Started a War
The strongest evidence of what people expected is what they were willing to do about it. In the year 66 Judea rose in revolt against Rome. The Jewish historian Josephus had been a commander on the rebel side before he surrendered, and afterward he looked back and asked what had driven his countrymen into a war they could not win. More than anything else, he wrote, it was an oracle in their sacred writings, to the effect that at about that time “one from their country would become ruler of the world” (Josephus, The Jewish War 6.312).
Two Roman historians who had no sympathy for the rebels report the same belief. Tacitus and Suetonius both say that a conviction had spread through the East that men from Judea were destined to rule the world, and that the Jews took it to refer to themselves.
Josephus, who by then was living in Rome on an imperial pension, decided that the oracle had really been about the Roman general Vespasian, who was proclaimed emperor while commanding the army in Judea. His countrymen had read it the way their prophets wrote it. They believed a ruler was about to arise from Israel, and they staked the nation on it. In the year 70 the Romans took Jerusalem and burned the temple to the ground.
One Hope in Many Voices
Take these witnesses together. A desert sect that despised the Jerusalem priesthood, a circle of devout poets under Roman occupation and a nation of rebels in the year 66 agreed on very little, and they shared this one expectation. So did the people who composed the daily prayers, and so, sixty years after the temple fell, did Rabbi Akiva, whom we will meet later in this book.
None of them describes the son of David as a man who would be rejected by his own leaders and put to death by the Romans before he had reigned a single day. The idea is absent from the Scrolls, from the Psalms of Solomon and from the hopes of the rebels. Whatever people in the first century meant when they said “Messiah,” that was not part of it.
This is the setting in which the first Gospel has to be read. When Peter says to Jesus, “You are the Christ,” he is using a word whose meaning was settled, and every person within earshot knew what it promised. If Jesus meant something else by it, or did not accept it at all, he would have had to say so. As we will see, he did.
