Chapter 5 of 24

    Two Christs

    7 min read

    0:008:12

    🎧 Listen while you read

    Most of what we know about Marcion comes from the people who wrote against him, and the most determined of them was Tertullian, a lawyer turned church writer who lived in Carthage, on the coast of North Africa. Around the year 207 he finished a five-volume attack called Against Marcion. It is long, clever and frequently rude, and it is one of the best sources we have, because Tertullian quoted the Marcionite position before he tried to tear it down.

    His third volume is devoted to a single question: was the Christ who came the same as the Christ the prophets promised? Tertullian thought the answer was obviously yes. The Marcionites said no, and Tertullian set down their reasons in their own terms.

    The Shipowner From Pontus

    Marcion needs a proper introduction, since most people have never heard his name, and those who have were usually told only that he was a heretic. He was born around the end of the first century in Sinope, a port on the southern shore of the Black Sea, in the Roman province of Pontus. He made his living in shipping and evidently did well at it. When he came to Rome around the year 140 he joined the church there and made it a gift of two hundred thousand sesterces, which was a small fortune. About four years later, after he had laid out his teaching before the leaders of the Roman church, they returned the money and showed him the door.

    He did not fade into obscurity. Justin, whom we met in the last chapter, lived in Rome during the same years, and he complained that Marcion was still alive and teaching, and that he had won over many people “of every nation” (Justin Martyr, First Apology 26). Marcionite assemblies spread from Italy to Mesopotamia and lasted for centuries. An inscription carved in the year 318 on a stone lintel in a village south of Damascus, one of the oldest dated inscriptions from any Christian meeting place, announces that the building is “the meeting-house of the Marcionites.”

    What set Marcion apart from the other teachers of his time was that he published. He issued a Gospel and ten letters of Paul as a fixed collection, and with them a work of his own called the Antitheses, a word that means “oppositions.” In it he set sayings and acts of the Creator side by side with sayings and acts of Jesus, and let the reader see the difference.

    One Pair From the Antitheses

    The Antitheses is lost, but Tertullian quotes enough of it to show how it worked, and one example will do. The Hebrew scriptures tell how the prophet Elijah, when a king sent soldiers to arrest him, called down fire from heaven and burned up a captain and his fifty men, and then did the same to a second fifty (2 Kings 1:9–12). In the first Gospel, Jesus and his disciples are refused lodging in a village of the Samaritans, and two of the disciples remember that story. “Lord, do you want us to call down fire from the sky to destroy them, like Elijah did?” The Gospel goes on: “But Jesus turned and warned them sharply. He said, ‘You don’t know what kind of spirit you belong to.’” (Evangelion 6:11–12 TT).

    Marcion set those two scenes next to each other and asked whether they could come from the same source. Tertullian knew the comparison and tried to answer it (Against Marcion 4.23). The disciples in the story assumed that Jesus stood in the line of Elijah and would act as Elijah had. Jesus told them they had mistaken the spirit they belonged to.

    The two Christs are the largest of Marcion’s antitheses. On one side stands the king the Creator promised, and on the other the Son the Father sent.

    What the Marcionites Taught

    According to Tertullian, the Marcionites drew “a distinction between two Christs, on the grounds that the Jewish Christ was indeed destined by the Creator for gathering the dispersed people alone, while your Christ was bestowed by the best God for liberating the whole human race” (Against Marcion 3.21.1).

    That one sentence holds the whole idea. The Creator, the God of Israel, had promised his people a Christ, an anointed king, whose work was to gather the scattered nation and restore it. That promise belonged to Israel and to no one else. The Christ who actually came in the fifteenth year of Tiberius was someone else, sent by someone else, and his work was not to restore a nation but to set every human being free.

    A few chapters later Tertullian lets a Marcionite speak in the first person. “I hope from him that which also makes for the testimony of diversity, the kingdom of God, of eternal and heavenly possession. But your Christ promises the former state to the Jews from the restoration of the land” (Against Marcion 3.24.1). There are two hopes in that sentence. The Jews were promised their land back. The Marcionite hoped for a kingdom that had never been anyone’s land at all.

    Siding With the Synagogue

    The most surprising thing about this teaching is whom it agreed with. Tertullian and the church read the prophets as hidden pictures of Jesus and the church. The swords that would be beaten into ploughshares were really, Tertullian said, the “inclinations of harmful minds and hostile tongues” (Against Marcion 3.21.3). The restored Judea was a figure for something spiritual. The Jews, he complained, were “led on by the names of places and regions” (Against Marcion 3.24.2), as if taking a place name to mean a place were a foolish mistake.

    The Marcionites took the place names to mean places. On this point they stood with the synagogue against the church. The Jews hoped for the restoration of Judea, Tertullian admits, “as it is described” (Against Marcion 3.24.2), and the Marcionites agreed that this was what was described. Where they parted from the synagogue was in what they made of it. The Jews took the promise as the word of the one true God. The Marcionites took it as the word of the Creator, who was real and powerful but was not the Father of Jesus.

    This matters for everything that follows. The Marcionite case never depended on twisting the prophets. It depended on reading them honestly and noticing that the man in the Gospel did not match them.

    The Two Side by Side

    It helps to see the two figures in one place before going further.

    The Creator’s Christ The Christ who came
    Sent by The Creator, the God of Israel The Father, unknown until Jesus revealed him
    Announced by The Law and the Prophets No one; he arrives unannounced
    Sent for Israel Everyone
    His work To gather the exiles, defeat Israel’s enemies and rule from Jerusalem To reveal the Father and rescue what was lost
    His credential Descent from David His own word and what he did
    His kingdom A land with a capital and borders A kingdom that cannot be pointed to on a map

    Part Two of this book checks the right-hand column against the first Gospel. Part Four asks whether the left-hand column still has a future.

    Where This Book Parts From Marcion

    There is one point on which I part company with the Marcionites of Tertullian’s day, and since it is the subject on the cover, it belongs here.

    The ancient Marcionites, by Tertullian’s account, believed the Creator’s Christ was still to come. Tertullian even frames their position that way while arguing against it: “The Creator remains, entirely as he is; and Christ will come, as he is also written” (Against Marcion 3.4.4). In their view, the Creator would one day keep his word to Israel. A king of David’s line would appear, gather the scattered people and restore their land, and that would be a real event in this world, separate from anything the Father was doing.

    I do not believe that king is coming. The Marcionites were right that the promise was real and that Jesus was not its fulfilment. Where I think they did not follow their own scriptures far enough is in what the coming of Jesus did to the Creator’s plans. The Gospel and the letters of Paul that Marcion himself handed down say that the Law and the Prophets had a term that ended with John. They say that the house of the strong man has been plundered, that the wall between Israel and the nations has been broken down, and that every rule and authority will be abolished when the kingdom is handed to the Father. If those things are true, then the Creator’s Christ has no throne left to take.

    That is the argument of Part Four of this book. Before we get there, we need to meet the Christ who did come, as the first Gospel presents him, and see what he did with the title everyone kept trying to give him.