If you grew up in a certain kind of American church, you have seen the chart. It hangs in a fellowship hall or folds out of the back of a study Bible, and it shows all of history as a row of boxes running from Eden on the left to eternity on the right. Near the right-hand end is a box labeled “The Millennium,” and under it, in small print, something like “Christ reigns on the throne of David in Jerusalem for 1,000 years.”
Readers who know that chart have been waiting for me to mention it, because it seems to offer a way around this entire book. Granted, they will say, Jesus did not take the throne of David when he came. He is going to take it when he comes back. The promise to Israel was never canceled. It was postponed.
Millions of Christians believe this, and they include some very careful students of the Bible. It is the church’s most serious reply to the question on the cover of this book, and it gets a full hearing here.
An Old Hope With a New Chart
The idea is far older than the chart. Tertullian held a version of it. In the same pages where he reports the Marcionite hope of a heavenly kingdom, he sets down his own: “For we also confess that a kingdom is promised to us on earth, but before heaven, but in another state, as it were after the resurrection, for a thousand years in the city of divine workmanship, Jerusalem, brought down from heaven” (Against Marcion 3.24.3). Several other Christian teachers of the second century said much the same.
The modern form took shape in the 1800s. John Nelson Darby, an Irish clergyman who left the Church of Ireland to teach among the group known as the Plymouth Brethren, worked out a system in which God has two distinct peoples with two distinct programs: Israel, with earthly promises, and the church, with heavenly ones. On his account Jesus came offering Israel its kingdom, Israel refused, and the kingdom was put on hold. The age of the church is a long pause. When it ends, the clock of Israel’s prophecies starts again, and Christ returns, takes the throne of David in Jerusalem and rules the world from there for a thousand years.
Darby’s system reached ordinary readers through the Scofield Reference Bible, published in 1909, which printed the scheme in notes on the same pages as the scripture. A generation later Lewis Sperry Chafer, who founded the school now called Dallas Theological Seminary, set it out in eight volumes of systematic theology. Its formal name is dispensational premillennialism. “Dispensational” refers to the separate ages, or dispensations, into which it divides history, and “premillennial” means that Christ returns before the thousand years begin.
What It Gets Right
I have more sympathy for this teaching than you might expect, because on the question of Part One it agrees with me against most of the church. It insists that the prophets meant what they said. A throne is a throne and Jerusalem is Jerusalem. Israel means Israel and does not mean the church. Its teachers have spent two centuries telling other Christians to stop turning the promises to David into figures of speech, and on that point they are right.
It also makes an admission the rest of the church avoids. If the kingdom was postponed, then the first coming of Jesus did not fulfil the promise of a king. Nothing was restored and no throne was taken. The chart says so in its own way, since the box marked “Kingdom” stands a long way to the right of the box marked “Cross.”
Where we part is over what follows from that. The chart concludes that Jesus must be coming back to do what he did not do the first time. I conclude that he was never sent to do it.
Where Its Verses Come From
The case for the postponed throne rests on a short list of passages.
- The angel’s promise to Mary that her son will be given “the throne of his father David,” which we met in Chapter 7 (Luke 1:32, King James Version).
- The disciples’ question in the book of Acts about restoring the kingdom to Israel, with Jesus’ reply: “It is not for you to know the times or the seasons” (Acts 1:7, King James Version). The reply does not deny that the restoration will come, and so it is taken to confirm it.
- A saying at the last supper in the church’s Luke: “I appoint unto you a kingdom,” so that the disciples may “sit on thrones judging the twelve tribes of Israel” (Luke 22:29–30, King James Version).
- A line in the speech Jesus gives about the future: “Jerusalem shall be trodden down of the Gentiles, until the times of the Gentiles be fulfilled” (Luke 21:24, King James Version), which implies a day when it will be trodden down no longer.
- The passage that gives the Millennium its name, from the book of Revelation, where the faithful “lived and reigned with Christ a thousand years” (Revelation 20:4, King James Version).
Now ask where each of these stands in the first Christian Bible. The angel’s promise belongs to the opening chapters of the church’s Luke, and the Evangelion begins at Capernaum without them. The book of Acts was not part of that Bible, and neither was Revelation. The thrones judging the twelve tribes and the “times of the Gentiles” are lines in the church’s Luke that the True Testament does not include.
So every Christian text on the list comes from a book or a passage outside the Gospel and the letters that Marcion published. What remains is the Creator’s own prophets, and nobody disputes that they promise a throne. The postponed kingdom is built from the prophets and from material that ties Jesus to the prophets. It has no footing in the first Gospel or in the ten letters of Paul.
How Jesus Describes His Coming
The first Gospel does speak of Jesus coming again, and what it says is different in kind. “Then they will see the Son of Man coming from heaven with great power. When these things happen, look up and lift your heads, because your liberation is near.” (Evangelion 13:41–42 TT).
He comes from heaven, and his people are told to look up. What draws near is their liberation. The passage has no city in it, no throne and no nation gathered inside its borders. It agrees with what Paul told the Thessalonians about meeting the Lord in the air, and with the timetable in which the coming of Christ is followed by the end.
Someone may point to a parable Jesus tells near Jericho, which the first Gospel does include. “A man of noble birth traveled to a distant land to secure a kingship for himself and then return.” (Evangelion 12:20 TT). The church reads this as Jesus going away to heaven and coming back as king. Take the story as it stands. The nobleman receives his kingship in the distant land. When he returns, he does not travel to a capital or take a seat on anyone’s throne. He calls in his own servants and asks what they have done with what he left them. The parable is about a master’s dealings with his household. Jerusalem, David and Israel do not come into it.
A Step Down
Paul gives one more reason the postponed throne will not work, and it has to do with where Christ is now. The Father, he writes, “raised him from the dead and seated him at his right hand in the heavenly places, far above every rule and authority and power and dominion and every name that is named, not only in this aeon but also in the one to come” (Laodiceans 1:11–12 TT).
Consider what the chart asks of a Christ who holds that position. He is seated above every rule and every authority, in this age and in the next. The chart has him leave that seat for a chair in one city, as the king of one nation, in the line of one family, for a fixed term of years. For a son of Jesse that throne was the highest honor the world could give. For the one Paul describes, it would be a step down.
The postponement also creates a puzzle it cannot solve. If Jesus always intended to sit on David’s throne in the end, then he is the son of David after all, and everything in Part Two of this book is left unexplained. A man who knows he will one day be crowned in Jerusalem as David’s heir has no reason to silence the title, to forbid his disciples to use it, or to stand in the temple asking how the Christ can be David’s son.
Watching the Clock
There is a practical cost as well. A postponed kingdom has to be watched for, and the watching has not gone well. William Miller, a Baptist preacher in New York State, convinced tens of thousands of Americans that Christ would return in 1844, and the day it failed to happen is remembered as the Great Disappointment. In 1988 a retired engineer named Edgar Whisenant published a booklet called 88 Reasons Why the Rapture Will Be in 1988, which circulated in the millions. He followed it with a revised date in 1989.
Since 1948 many believers have treated the founding of the modern State of Israel as the signal for the last boxes on the chart. This book has no political argument to make, and nothing in it is a comment on that state or its people. The point here is narrower. A modern republic with a parliament is not the throne of David, nobody claims its leaders are David’s heirs, and the Christians who watch it most eagerly are themselves still waiting for a king.
Paul’s advice on the subject was brief. “Now concerning the times and the seasons, brothers and sisters, you have no need that anything be written to you. For you yourselves know well that the day of the Lord will come like a thief in the night.” (1 Thessalonians 5:1–2 TT). A thief does not send a schedule ahead.
No Palace
Tertullian found the Marcionite hope hard to take seriously, because it came with nothing to look at. “You allege a kingdom,” he told them, “but point out no palace” (Against Marcion 3.24.13).
He was right about the facts. There is no palace. The kingdom the Father gives cannot be visited or photographed, and it will not appear on any chart of the Middle East. Tertullian took that for the weakness of the Marcionite hope. I take it for the substance of it. The palace was promised by another God to another people, and the Christ who came never asked for the keys.
