Chapter 20 of 24

    He Told You Not to Follow Them

    7 min read

    0:008:18

    🎧 Listen while you read

    In the year 132, a man named Simon bar Kosiba led Judea into its last great war against Rome. He was a capable commander, and for a while he succeeded beyond anyone’s expectations. His forces drove the Romans out of much of the country, he minted his own coins, and he dated his documents by the years of Israel’s redemption.

    The most respected teacher of his generation, Rabbi Akiva, looked at him and saw the fulfilment of the prophets. He gave Simon a new name, Bar Kokhba, “son of the star,” after the prophecy in the book of Numbers that “there shall come a Star out of Jacob” (Numbers 24:17, King James Version). According to a story preserved in the Jerusalem Talmud, whenever Akiva saw him he would say, “This is the King Messiah!” Another rabbi, Yohanan ben Torta, answered him, “Akiva, grass will grow on your cheeks and still the Son of David will not have come” (Jerusalem Talmud, tractate Taanit, chapter 4).

    Yohanan was right. Rome sent its best generals and a huge army, and the revolt was ground down town by town. In 135 the last stronghold, Betar, fell, and Simon died there. The emperor Hadrian rebuilt Jerusalem as a Roman city called Aelia Capitolina and barred Jews from entering it. He renamed the province as well, so that the name Judea disappeared from the Roman map.

    Marcion was alive when this happened. Within a few years he was in Rome, publishing a Gospel in which Jesus had already given a warning about men like Simon.

    The Warning

    “He said, ‘Watch out that you aren’t deceived. Many will come in my name, saying, “I am the Christ,” and, “The time is near.” Don’t follow them. When you hear of wars and uprisings, don’t be afraid. These things must happen first, but the end will not come right away.’” (Evangelion 13:27–28 TT).

    The warning has two parts. People will come claiming to be the Christ, and people will announce that the time has arrived. Jesus gives one instruction for both: do not follow them. He does not say, “Wait for the right one.” He does not give a test for telling a true Messiah from a false one. He simply says that those who come saying “I am the Christ” are to be ignored.

    If the Creator’s Messiah were still to come, this would be very strange advice. It would mean that when the real son of David finally appeared, the followers of Jesus would be under orders to refuse him. But if no such Messiah is coming, the warning makes perfect sense. Every man who claims the title will be one more Simon, and the right response to all of them is the same.

    “In My Name”

    The church reads this warning narrowly. Since Jesus says the claimants will come “in my name,” the argument goes, he must mean people who pretend to be Jesus himself, returned. A Jewish claimant like Simon never used the name of Jesus, so the warning would have nothing to say about him, and nothing to say about a true son of David either.

    The words the claimants use in the verse point another way. They do not say “I am Jesus.” They say “I am the Christ.” The name they borrow is the title, and in the first Gospel that title belongs to the one the Father sent. Anyone who arrives announcing himself as the Christ is coming in a name that is already taken.

    Tertullian read the verse this way too. He understood the warning to be about claimants to the title, and he saw at once where that left his opponents. The Marcionites believed the Creator’s Christ was still to come. Yet here was their own Gospel ordering them not to follow anyone who comes saying “I am the Christ.” So when the genuine owner of the title appears, he asked them, “Shall you reject him?” (Against Marcion 4.39).

    He meant it as a trap. I think it is simply the correct reading, and the answer to his question is yes. The warning has no exception clause. It covers the frauds, and it would cover a real king of David’s line if one ever came, because the instruction does not depend on whether the claimant is sincere or whether his family tree is in order. The people of Jesus already have their Christ. They are not looking for another.

    The Marcionites of Tertullian’s day could not say that cleanly, because they still expected the other Christ to arrive. Their Gospel told them not to follow him and their teachers told them he was coming, and the two sat awkwardly together. Once you conclude that he is not coming at all, the awkwardness disappears, and the warning can be read the way it was written.

    The Long Line of Claimants

    Simon was not the first to raise such hopes. Josephus describes several men like him in the decades before Jerusalem fell in the year 70. One, named Theudas, led a crowd to the River Jordan and promised that the water would part at his command, as it parts in the book of Joshua. Roman cavalry reached them first. A few years later a man known only as “the Egyptian” gathered a large following on the Mount of Olives and promised that the walls of Jerusalem would fall when he gave the word. The governor’s troops scattered his followers, and he slipped away and was never heard of again (Josephus, Antiquities of the Jews 20.97–98 and 20.169–172).

    Simon was the most famous, but he was not the last. Three centuries later, on the island of Crete, a man calling himself Moses persuaded the Jewish community that he would lead them across the sea to the promised land on dry ground, as the first Moses had led Israel through the Red Sea. On the appointed day, according to the church historian Socrates Scholasticus, many of them followed him to a headland and threw themselves into the water, and many were dashed on the rocks or drowned before fishermen could pull the rest out (Socrates, Ecclesiastical History 7.38).

    In 1172 the Jews of Yemen were in turmoil over a man who was proclaiming that the days of the Messiah were at hand. Their leaders wrote for advice to Moses Maimonides, the most learned rabbi of the Middle Ages, who was then living in Egypt. His long reply, known as the Letter to Yemen, urged them with great tenderness to hold on to their hope and to keep well away from the man.

    The most dramatic case came in 1665, when Sabbatai Zevi, a rabbi from Smyrna on the coast of what is now Turkey, was proclaimed the Messiah. News of him swept through Jewish communities from Yemen to Amsterdam. Families sold their homes and prepared to travel to the Holy Land. The next year the Ottoman sultan had him arrested and gave him a choice between death and conversion to Islam. Sabbatai chose to convert, and the hopes of hundreds of thousands of people collapsed in a single day.

    There have been many others between and since, and in every case the pattern is the same. A man appears, someone declares that the prophecies are being fulfilled, and people who have waited faithfully for generations give him everything they have. Then the promise fails, and the people are left with grief instead of a king.

    It would be easy to read those stories with a sense of superiority, and that would be a mistake. The people who followed Simon and Sabbatai were not foolish. They were faithful. They believed the promise in the prophets meant what it said, and in that they were right. What they could not know was that the promise had no future.

    Nineteen Centuries

    From the fall of Betar to the present day is close to nineteen hundred years. In all that time, the throne of David has stayed empty. Jerusalem has been ruled by Romans, Byzantines, Arabs, Crusaders, Mamluks, Ottomans and the British, and in our own time by a modern state, but never by a king of David’s line. The exiles have been scattered and partly gathered and scattered again. Every generation has had its candidates, and every one of them has been a Simon.

    Jesus also said this to his disciples: “The days are coming when you’ll long to see even one of the days of the Son of Man, but you won’t see it.” (Evangelion 11:15 TT). The longing for a visible deliverer, someone you can point to and say “there he is,” is one of the deepest longings people have, and it is not going to be satisfied in this world.

    This is the fifth reason the Creator’s Messiah is not coming, and it is the one history has added to the other four. The promise was given in ordinary words, and it has been tested over and over for nineteen centuries. It has failed every time, and every time the warning in the Evangelion has proved true. Jesus did not say “wait.” He said “don’t follow them.”