Chapter 17 of 24

    The House Has Been Plundered

    6 min read

    0:007:16

    🎧 Listen while you read

    One day Jesus freed a man who could not speak, and the man began to talk. Most of the crowd was amazed. A few of them had a different explanation. “He drives out demons by the power of Beelzebul, the ruler of the demons.” (Evangelion 7:13 TT). They meant that he was in league with the devil.

    Jesus’ reply begins with simple logic. If the Adversary were driving out his own demons, he would be working against himself, and no kingdom lasts that way. Then Jesus tells a very short story.

    “When a strong man, fully armed, guards his house, his possessions are safe. But when someone stronger comes and overpowers him, he takes away the weapons he was relying on and divides up the plunder.” (Evangelion 7:18–19 TT).

    Who Is the Strong Man?

    The parable is about a break-in. A powerful man is guarding his house, and as long as he is armed, nobody can touch what is inside. Then someone stronger arrives, overpowers him, takes his weapons and carries off his belongings to share them out.

    Jesus is the stronger one, the one who breaks in. The question is who the strong man is, and whose house it is.

    The church has always said the strong man is the devil. The Marcionites read the parable differently. We know this because Tertullian argued against their reading. The parable, he insisted, shows the prince of demons “overcome” by the finger of God, “not that the Creator had been suppressed by some other god.” And if Marcion’s God really had overpowered the Creator, Tertullian asked, “how could the Creator’s kingdom still be standing, with its own boundaries and laws and functionaries?” (Against Marcion 4.26).

    Tertullian would not have needed to argue the point if the Marcionites had not made it. They read the strong man as the ruler of this world, the one whose house the human race lives in, and they believed Jesus had come to break into that house and carry its people out.

    The text has limits here, and they should be stated. Jesus does not name the strong man. Nothing in the parable says “the Creator” in so many words, and the reading I am giving is Marcion’s, reported by his opponent. But it is not a reading pulled from nowhere. Paul speaks of “the god of this aeon” who “has blinded the minds of the untrusting” (2 Corinthians 4:1 TT). He says that before Christ “we were enslaved under the elements of the world” (Galatians 4:3 TT), and that the Son was sent “so that he might purchase those under Law” (Galatians 4:5 TT). Paul describes a world held by a power, and people bought out of it. That is the strong man’s house.

    Paul has more to say about that power in the same passage of Galatians. Before his readers knew God, he tells them, “you were enslaved to those who are gods by nature” (Galatians 4:8 TT). He then asks how they can think of going back, and his description of what they would be going back to is not flattering: “how do you turn again to the weak and poor elements, to which you want to be enslaved once more?” (Galatians 4:9 TT). The Galatians were being urged to take up the Law of Moses, with its “days and months and seasons and years” (Galatians 4:10 TT). Paul calls that a return to slavery under powers that are weak and poor. A Messiah sent to restore the rule of that Law over a nation would be restoring what Paul calls the weak and poor elements.

    What a Break-In Means for a King

    In the parable, all of this has already happened. The stronger one has come. He has overpowered the owner of the house, taken away “the weapons he was relying on” and divided up the plunder. The plunder is the belongings of the house, and in the scene where Jesus tells the story, those belongings are people, like the man who had just been set free to speak.

    The Messiah the prophets promised was supposed to be the Creator’s instrument for restoring his house: his people, his land, his throne and his Law. He was going to come as the strong man’s champion, armed with the strong man’s authority.

    But according to Jesus, the strong man has already been overpowered and disarmed, and his household has been divided up. A king sent to restore a house that has already been broken into and emptied would be arriving to defend a building with nobody in it, carrying weapons that have already been taken away. There is nothing left for him to do.

    This is the second reason the Creator’s Messiah is not coming. It is not that the Creator has run out of time, as with the Law and the Prophets. It is that the stronger one has already come into his house. The rescue the prophets never imagined has already happened, and it left no place for the plan they did imagine.

    The Kingdom Has Already Arrived

    Jesus finishes his answer to the crowd with a line that ties all this together. “But if I drive out demons by the finger of God, then the kingdom of God has come upon you.” (Evangelion 7:17 TT).

    The kingdom of God is not waiting in the future for a son of David to establish it. It has come upon them, there in the crowd, in the person of the one who is setting captives free. And the people he frees are no longer the strong man’s possessions.

    Then Why Is the House Still Standing

    Tertullian put a question to the Marcionites that I quoted earlier and have not yet answered. If the Creator has been overpowered, how is his kingdom still standing, with its boundaries, its laws and its officials? The sun still rises on schedule. People are still born and still die, and the Law is still read aloud every week in synagogues around the world. It does not look like a house that has been broken into.

    The parable gives the first part of the answer. The stronger man does not burn the house down. He does three things: he overpowers the owner, he takes away “the weapons he was relying on,” and he divides the plunder. The building is left where it was. What changes is who can be held inside it.

    Paul supplies the rest, and he is careful with his tenses. Writing to Corinth, he speaks of “the rulers of this aeon, who are being nullified” (1 Corinthians 2:6 TT). They are being nullified, which means the work is under way and not yet complete. Its completion is the scene we will reach in Chapter 19, when Christ abolishes every rule and authority and hands the kingdom to the Father.

    In his letter to the Colossians, Paul describes the decisive blow as already struck: “having canceled the certificate of debt with its decrees against us, which was hostile to us; he took it out of the way, nailing it to the stake. He disarmed the rulers and the authorities and exposed them openly, triumphing over them through him.” (Colossians 2:7–8 TT).

    “Disarmed” is the parable’s “takes away the weapons” in Paul’s vocabulary, and the weapon turns out to be a document, a certificate of debt with decrees attached. The owner of the house held people by a legal claim. Once the claim is canceled, he can no longer keep anyone who wishes to leave.

    Anyone who has watched a business change hands has seen something like this. On the day the sale closes, the old name is still over the door, the old staff still come to work, and the old forms are still in the drawers. For a while very little looks different. But the former owner can no longer sign for anything, and a date has been set for the sign to come down. That is the state Paul describes: rulers who have been disarmed and are being nullified, with an end appointed.

    So Tertullian’s question has an answer. The Creator’s kingdom is still standing in the way a building stands after its owner has lost his claim on what is inside. That makes the point of this chapter sharper. A Messiah of David’s line would be a new officer appointed by rulers who are in the middle of being nullified, sent to enforce decrees that have been nailed to the stake.