John the Immerser had spent his life preparing people for someone. The Jewish historian Josephus, writing late in the first century, remembered him as a good man who drew great crowds and called the people to righteousness, until Herod Antipas had him arrested and put to death (Josephus, Antiquities of the Jews 18.116–119). He was the last and greatest of the old prophets, and the first Gospel introduces him at the moment reports about Jesus reach him.
The church’s Luke tells this part of the story politely. The first Gospel is blunter. “When John heard what Jesus was doing, he was offended. He called two of his disciples and told them, ‘Go ask him, “Are you the one who’s supposed to come, or should we wait for someone else?”’” (Evangelion 4:14–15 TT).
John was offended. The man he was hearing about did not match the one he had been announcing. John stood in the line of the prophets, and the prophets had promised a king. Instead he heard about a teacher who ate with sinners and healed on the Sabbath. So he asked the question that this whole book is about: are you the one we were promised, or do we keep waiting?
Second-century readers argued over that word. The Marcionites said John took offense because he belonged to the Creator and was looking for the Creator’s king. Tertullian could not deny that the offense stood in the text, so he explained it another way. The portion of the Spirit that had rested on John had by then returned to Christ, he said, which left John “an ordinary man” who could be offended like anyone else (Against Marcion 4.18). Both sides were reading the same sentence, and both agreed on what it reported: the greatest of the prophets looked at Jesus and did not find what he expected.
Jesus’ Answer
Jesus did not say yes. He told the messengers to report what they had seen: “blind people are seeing again, the lame are walking, those with leprosy are made clean, the deaf are hearing, the dead are being awoken, and the poor are hearing the good news.” Then he added a line that was meant for John personally: “Fortunate is John if he doesn’t stumble over me.” (Evangelion 4:16 and 4:16a TT).
After the messengers left, Jesus spoke about John to the crowd, and what he said was both a compliment and a boundary. John was a prophet, he said, “and I tell you, more than a prophet” (Evangelion 4:18 TT). He was the messenger sent ahead. “I tell you, among those born of women there is no one greater than John; yet the one who is least in the kingdom of God is greater than he.” (Evangelion 4:19a TT).
John was the greatest of everything that came before. And the least person in the kingdom Jesus was announcing was greater than John. Something had changed, and John stood on the far side of the change.
Until John
Later in the Gospel, Jesus says what changed. “The Law and the Prophets were in effect until John. Since then, the kingdom of God is being announced, and everyone is pushing to get in.” (Evangelion 10:20 TT).
The Law and the Prophets were the two great parts of Israel’s scriptures. The Law was the five books of Moses, with their covenant and their commandments. The Prophets were the books of Isaiah, Jeremiah, Ezekiel, Micah and the others, the books that carried the promise of a king from David’s line. Jesus says that both of them were in effect until John. They had a term, the way a lease has a term or a law has a sunset clause, and the term ran out.
The promise of a Davidic Messiah lives inside the Prophets. It is the Prophets that promise the throne, the gathering of the exiles and the restored kingdom. If the Prophets were in effect until John, then their promises were in effect until John. After that, something else is being announced, and it is called the kingdom of God.
Jesus makes the contrast even sharper in the next breath. “But it’s easier for heaven and earth to pass away than for even the smallest part of my words to fail.” (Evangelion 10:21 TT). The church’s Luke has “the law” at the end of that sentence, so that it is the Law that will never fail. In the first Gospel, it is Jesus’ own words that will outlast heaven and earth. The Law and the Prophets had their time. His words have no expiration date.
Ended or Fulfilled
The church has an answer to this verse, and Tertullian gave it first. He agreed with more of the verse than you might expect. John, he wrote, was set as “a sort of dividing-line between old things and new,” the point at which Judaism was to stop and Christianity to begin (Against Marcion 4.33). His only quarrel was over who drew the line. In his view the Creator had planned all along to retire his own Law and Prophets, and Christ arrived as the fulfilment they had been pointing to. On that reading, “until John” means the Prophets stopped because they had come true.
It is a tidy answer, and three things in the first Gospel stand in its way.
The first is the wording. Jesus does not say that since John the Prophets are being fulfilled. He says that since John “the kingdom of God is being announced.” An announcement is news. Nobody announces what has been public knowledge for seven hundred years.
The second is what Jesus says about how much the prophets knew. Turning to his disciples in private, he tells them, “Blessed are the eyes that see what you see. For I tell you, the prophets did not see what you see.” (Evangelion 6:31–32 TT). The church’s Luke turns this into a compliment to the prophets: “many prophets and kings have desired to see those things which ye see, and have not seen them” (Luke 10:24, King James Version). In that version the prophets were straining toward the very thing the disciples now enjoyed. The first Gospel has no straining in it. The prophets did not see it, and men cannot have spent centuries promising a thing they never saw.
The third is the picture Jesus himself gives of how old and new relate. “No one pours new wine into old wineskins. If they do, the new wine will split the skins, the wine spills out, and the skins are ruined.” (Evangelion 3:4 TT). And in the same breath: “No one patches an old coat with new fabric that hasn’t been washed yet. If they do, the new patch will pull away, it will not match the old, and the old coat will tear even worse.” (Evangelion 3:6 TT). Fulfilment would be new wine poured into the old skins and filling them at last. Jesus says the two cannot be combined without ruining both. “It will not match the old” is about as far as a sentence can get from “this is what the old was waiting for.”
The End of the Law
Paul says the same thing in a single line. “For Christ is the end of the Law for righteousness to everyone who believes.” (Romans 10:3 TT).
The Greek word Paul uses for “end” can mean a goal, and the church has often read the verse that way, as if Christ were the destination the Law was heading toward. But it is also the ordinary word for the end of something, the point where it stops. Read alongside “until John,” the meaning is not hard to find. The Law had a term, and Christ brought it to an end.
A Glory That Faded
Paul comes back to the subject in his second letter to the Corinthians, and there he reaches for a scene from the book of Exodus. When Moses came down from Mount Sinai with the commandments, his face shone so brightly that he covered it with a veil. Paul reads the scene as a picture of the whole arrangement Moses delivered. He calls it “the ministry of death, in letters engraved on stones,” and he says its glory “was fading” (2 Corinthians 3:3 TT). Then he draws the comparison: “For if what faded was with glory, much more what remains is in glory.” (2 Corinthians 3:7 TT). A verse later he speaks of “the end of what was perishing” (2 Corinthians 3:8 TT).
Paul grants that the old arrangement had glory, and he puts that glory in the past tense. One thing faded and another remains. He never suggests that the two are a single thing at different stages of growth.
He says the same to the Romans in the language of death and release. “You also were made to die to the Law through the body of Christ, that you might belong to another” (Romans 7:1 TT), and “now we have been released from the Law, having died to that by which we were bound” (Romans 7:3 TT). People do not die to an arrangement and then wait around for its remaining promises to be paid out.
The Throne Was Part of the Law
One gap remains that someone might try to slip through. Could the Law come to an end while the promise to David carries on without it? The Hebrew scriptures do not allow that. The king of Israel was a creature of the Law. Moses required every king to write out his own copy of it and to “read therein all the days of his life” (Deuteronomy 17:19, King James Version). When David lay dying, he handed the promise on to his son Solomon with its condition attached. Solomon was to keep what was written in “the law of Moses,” and on that footing David’s house would never lack “a man on the throne of Israel” (1 Kings 2:3–4, King James Version).
The throne and the Law came as one package. The son of David was to be the Law’s king, ruling the Law’s people in the Law’s land. If the Law and the Prophets were in effect until John, then the throne they provided for went out of effect with them.
This is the first reason the Creator’s Messiah is not coming. He was promised by the Law and the Prophets, and the Law and the Prophets were in effect until John. A promise made under an arrangement that has ended does not survive the arrangement. Waiting for the son of David now is like waiting for a train on a line that has been closed. The tracks may still be there, but the service ended long ago, and the announcement was made by the one person with the authority to make it.
John, to his credit, asked his question openly. Jesus’ answer was not “I am the one,” and it was not “wait for someone else.” It was, in effect, “look at what is happening, and do not stumble over me.” The old order had reached its end, and something new had come in its place.
