In 1871 a French archaeologist named Charles Clermont-Ganneau was exploring near the Temple Mount in Jerusalem when he came across a block of limestone with a Greek inscription carved into it. It turned out to be one of the warning signs that had stood in Herod’s temple in the time of Jesus. Its message was short and to the point. No foreigner, it said, was to pass the barrier around the sanctuary, and anyone who was caught doing so would have only himself to blame for the death that followed. The stone is now in the Istanbul Archaeology Museums, and it is about as clear a no-entry sign as has ever been made.
That barrier was more than a fence. It marked the line the Law drew through the middle of the human race. On one side stood Israel, the people the Creator had chosen, with their covenant, their commandments and their promises. On the other side stood everyone else.
The warning stones guarded the outer line. Deeper inside the temple there were further barriers, each one admitting fewer people, and at the center hung a heavy curtain in front of the room where the God of Israel was said to dwell. Only the high priest passed that curtain, and only once a year. The first Gospel reports that at the hour Jesus died, “the temple curtain was torn down the middle” (Evangelion 15:34 TT). The innermost barrier of the whole system gave way first.
What Was on the Other Side
Paul describes what life on the far side of that barrier was like, and he does it in the letter the True Testament calls Laodiceans, known in the church’s Bible as Ephesians. He reminds his readers, who were not Jews, of where they had stood. They “were in that time apart from Christ, alienated from the commonwealth of Israel, strangers to the covenants of the promise, having no hope and without God in the world.” (Laodiceans 2:12 TT).
The covenants of the promise belonged to Israel. The rest of the world stood outside them, strangers with no share in the Creator’s plans for his people. If the promised Messiah had come, the nations would still have been on the far side of the wall, watching Israel be gathered and restored.
What Christ Did to the Wall
Then Paul tells them what changed:
“But now in Christ you, who were once far off, have been brought near by his blood. For he is our peace, who made both into one and broke down the wall of enmity in the flesh, abolishing the Law of commandments in decrees, so that he might create the two in himself into one new humanity, making peace, and might reconcile both in one body to God through the stake, putting to death the enmity in it.” (Laodiceans 2:13–16 TT).
Every item in that list has already been done. He made the two into one. He broke down the wall. He abolished “the Law of commandments in decrees.” He created one new humanity out of the two. Paul then draws the conclusion for his readers: “So then you are no longer strangers and aliens, but fellow citizens with the holy ones and members of God’s household” (Laodiceans 2:19 TT).
Why a Messiah for Israel Would Undo It
According to the prophets, the Creator’s Messiah had a definite task. He would gather Israel as a nation, settle it in its land and rule it under the Law. He would restore the distinction between Israel and the nations, with Israel restored and the nations either serving it or kept at a distance. He would rebuild everything the wall stood for.
The prophets spell this out. In Isaiah’s vision of the restored Jerusalem, “the sons of strangers shall build up thy walls, and their kings shall minister unto thee,” and “the nation and kingdom that will not serve thee shall perish” (Isaiah 60:10, 12, King James Version). The prophet Zechariah has the surviving nations travel to Jerusalem every year to worship the king and keep the Feast of Tabernacles, one of Israel’s festivals under the Law, and any nation that stays home gets no rain (Zechariah 14:16–17). The nations have a place in the Messiah’s kingdom, but they come as servants and pilgrims to a house that belongs to someone else. The line between Israel and everyone else is never erased. It is the organizing principle of the whole arrangement.
Paul says Christ has already torn that wall down and abolished the Law that built it. For a Messiah of the old kind to come now, one of two things would have to happen. Either he would have to rebuild the wall the Father’s Christ broke down, splitting the one new humanity back into two, or he would have to rule over a nation that no longer exists as a separate people in the Father’s sight.
The Father is not going to undo his own work. A Messiah who restored one nation under the Law would be working directly against what Paul says Christ accomplished “through the stake.” That is the third reason the Creator’s Messiah is not coming: his task was to keep the two apart, and the two have been made one.
Building Again What Was Torn Down
Paul had to face the question of going back in his own lifetime. In Galatians he is arguing with people who wanted believers in Christ to return to the works of the Law, and he says, “For if I build again the things I destroyed, I prove myself a transgressor.” (Galatians 2:15 TT).
For Paul, rebuilding what had been torn down would not be a neutral act, let alone a divine one. It would be a transgression. He says that about himself, an apostle. It applies with greater force to a king whose entire commission would be to rebuild.
He states the result of the demolition twice more in the same letter. “There is no Jew or Greek, no slave or free, no male or female, for all of you are one in Christ Jesus.” (Galatians 3:14 TT). And near the end: “For neither circumcision nor uncircumcision is anything, but a new creation.” (Galatians 6:15 TT). Circumcision was the mark of the covenant, the sign carried in the body by the people the Messiah was to gather. Paul says the mark now counts for nothing either way. A kingdom defined by that mark has lost the thing that defined it.
Tertullian accepted most of this. Commenting on the passage about the wall, he agreed that the two who were made one are “the Jewish people and the gentile,” and that the Law of commandments had been made void (Against Marcion 5.17). His one reservation was that Christ had voided the Law by fulfilling it. However it happened, he and the Marcionites agreed on the result: the wall is gone and the Law of commandments no longer stands. What he never explained is how, with both of them gone, the old promise of a restored and separate Israel could still be waiting to come true.
Two Revelations
Paul says something similar in Galatians, in one of his most surprising passages. He takes the story of Abraham’s two sons, one born to the slave woman Hagar and one to his wife Sarah, and reads it as a picture of two different arrangements. “These things are spoken allegorically, for they are two revelations: one from Mount Sinai, for the synagogue of the Jews according to the Law, bearing children for slavery.” (Galatians 4:16 TT). The other, he says, “bears children above every rule and power and dominion and every name that is named, not only in this aeon but also in the one to come. She is our mother, the holy assembly into which we have made our pledge.” (Galatians 4:17 TT).
One revelation came from Sinai and belongs to the Law. The other is above every rule and power, in this age and in the next. The Messiah of the prophets belongs entirely to the first. The Christ who came belongs to the second, and Paul says the second is our mother.
The stone in Istanbul still says what it said two thousand years ago. Nobody enforces it any more, and the temple it guarded has been gone since the year 70. Paul would say the wall it stood on came down even before that, in the death of Christ.
