A careful reader will have a question by now, and it is a fair one to put to a book that leans so heavily on Marcion. He had the same Gospel I have been quoting and the same letters of Paul. If those pages close the door on the Creator’s Messiah, why did Marcion himself leave it open?
The answer shapes the rest of Part Four, so it gets a chapter of its own. I am not going to claim that Marcion secretly agreed with me, or that his opponents misreported him. As far as the evidence goes, he and his followers expected the king of Israel to arrive one day, and they said so.
What the Marcionites Expected
We met the first report in Chapter 5. Tertullian says the Marcionites assigned the “Jewish Christ” to the Creator “for gathering the dispersed people alone” (Against Marcion 3.21.1), and that they spoke of him as a figure still to come.
Two more passages confirm it. In his fourth volume Tertullian reaches the warning Jesus gives about people who will come saying “I am the Christ,” and he turns it into a taunt. You Marcionites admit, he says, that the true owner of that title, the Creator’s Christ, is still on his way. When he arrives, “Shall you reject him?” (Against Marcion 4.39). The taunt only works if the Marcionites did in fact expect that arrival.
In the fifth volume he comes to a passage in Paul’s second letter to the Thessalonians about a figure who will one day exalt himself above everything that is called a god. The church calls this figure the Antichrist. Tertullian remarks in passing that he suspects Marcion took the figure to be the Creator’s Christ, since on Marcion’s view that Christ “has not yet come” (Against Marcion 5.16).
So three separate remarks, in three different volumes of the same work, tell the same story. The Marcionites of Tertullian’s day believed in two Christs and in two arrivals. One had happened in the fifteenth year of Tiberius. The other was still ahead.
Why He May Have Thought So
Nobody recorded Marcion’s reasons, so what follows is inference, and I offer it as that. Three things would have pulled him in this direction.
The first is that he took the Creator seriously. Marcion never taught that the God of Israel was imaginary or that his prophets were frauds. He taught that the Creator was real, that he made this world and governs it, and that his word to Israel was sincerely meant. Tertullian puts the Marcionite position in one line: “The Creator remains, entirely as he is; and Christ will come, as he is also written” (Against Marcion 3.4.4). If you believe the Creator is still in charge of his own world and that he gave his word, the natural conclusion is that he will keep it.
The second is the time he lived in. Marcion was a grown man when the last great Jewish war against Rome was fought in the 130s, under a commander whom many Jews hailed as the promised king. We will come to that war in Chapter 20. For a man of his generation, the hope of a Messiah for Israel was no faded line in an old book. It was current events, and it had an army. It would have been odd for him to treat the matter as closed.
The third is that the expectation was useful. Marcion’s chief argument against the church was that Jesus did not match the Christ of the prophets. An unfulfilled promise made that argument for him. As long as the son of David was still expected, nobody could say Jesus had been that man.
None of these is a bad reason, and together they explain how an intelligent man could hold the position. They do not show that the position is right. The test of that is the scripture he handed on.
How Little We Have
The evidence has limits, and they should be stated before we go on. Marcion wrote a book called the Antitheses, in which he set the sayings of the Creator beside the sayings of Jesus. It is lost. No letter or sermon of his has survived. Everything we know about his expectation of a Jewish Messiah comes from a few sentences written by an opponent more than sixty years after Marcion arrived in Rome, and that opponent was summarizing in order to refute.
This means we cannot say how much weight Marcion gave the idea. It may have been a central teaching. It may have been a concession he made in debate and never developed. On the passage in Thessalonians, Tertullian says only that he suspects what Marcion thought, which is how a man writes when he is guessing. We know the expectation existed. We do not know what Marcion would have answered if someone had pressed him with his own Gospel.
The Rule He Left Behind
How a question like this has to be handled is settled by a rule in Marcion’s own Bible. Paul writes to the Galatians: “Even if we or an angel from heaven should proclaim a message contrary to what we proclaimed to you, let him be condemned.” (Galatians 1:7 TT).
Paul includes himself in that sentence. The message outranks the messenger, even when the messenger is an apostle or an angel. A collection of scripture gathered under that rule cannot treat its own collector as the last word. If the Gospel and the letters say one thing and Marcion expected another, the Gospel and the letters win. Marcion would have had to agree, because the rule is in the book he published.
So the next five chapters do not ask what Marcion expected. They ask what Jesus and Paul said, in the text Marcion preserved, about the arrangement that produced the promise of a king. I have found five places where they speak to it, and each one closes the question from a different side.
- Jesus says the Law and the Prophets were in effect until John, which gives the promise an end date.
- Jesus describes a strong man overpowered and disarmed in his own house.
- Paul says the wall between Israel and the nations has been broken down, and the Law that built it abolished.
- Paul lays out the order of events to the very end, and there is no place in it for a throne in Jerusalem.
- Jesus tells his followers what to do when someone arrives claiming the title, and the instruction is not to follow.
One caution before we start. Nothing in these chapters says the Creator lacks the power to send a king, and nothing says his promise was insincere. The argument is about what the Father has done through his own Christ, and about what that leaves standing. Marcion saw the two Gods and the two Christs more clearly than anyone else in his century. Where he stopped was at the next question, which is what the arrival of the second Christ did to the plans made for the first.
