Chapter 11 of 24

    David’s Lord

    5 min read

    0:005:37

    🎧 Listen while you read

    In Jerusalem the scribes and the religious authorities tried one question after another to trap him. Should people pay taxes to Caesar? If a woman marries seven brothers in turn, whose wife will she be in the resurrection? Jesus answered every one of them, and the questions dried up. Then he asked one of his own.

    “Then Jesus said to them, ‘How can they say that the Christ is David’s son? For David himself says in the book of Psalms, “The Lord said to my Lord, sit at my right hand.” If David calls him Lord, how can he be his son?’” (Evangelion 13:23–25 TT).

    This is the only time in the first Gospel that Jesus brings up the title “Son of David” himself. Nobody asked him about it. He raised it on purpose, in the temple, in front of the people who taught it, and the way he raised it was with a question that has no comfortable answer.

    How the Riddle Works

    The scribes taught, as everyone did, that the Christ would be a descendant of David. Jesus takes a psalm that the scribes themselves believed David wrote, and in which they believed David was speaking about the Christ. In that psalm David calls the Christ “my Lord.”

    In the world of the Bible, a father does not call his own son “my Lord.” The order of honor runs the other way. A son honors his father, and a king’s descendants look back to him as the founder of the house. So if David, the founder of the royal line, addresses the Christ as his superior, how can the Christ be one of David’s own descendants? “If David calls him Lord, how can he be his son?”

    Jesus leaves the question hanging, and nobody answers it.

    The Psalm He Chose

    The psalm Jesus quotes is the one numbered 110 in most Bibles, and the scribes had good reason to treat it as a psalm about the Messiah. It is a coronation poem. After the line Jesus quotes, it goes on, “The LORD shall send the rod of thy strength out of Zion: rule thou in the midst of thine enemies,” and a few verses later the king “shall wound the heads over many countries” (Psalm 110:2, 6, King James Version). It describes a ruler installed in Jerusalem who subdues the nations by force, and no psalm did more to shape the picture of the conquering son of David.

    That makes the choice of text pointed. Jesus goes to the scribes’ strongest passage about the Davidic king, takes its opening line, and uses that line to ask whether the king can be Davidic at all. He quotes none of the conquest.

    The Objection

    Here again we should face the strongest objection head on. Jesus is quoting a psalm. He is treating David as a prophet who spoke about the Christ. Doesn’t that mean he accepts the Hebrew scriptures as a true prophecy of himself, and therefore accepts that he is the Creator’s promised one?

    The answer lies in how arguments work. When you want to show someone that their position does not hold together, the most effective thing you can do is use their own sources against them. If a man tells you his favorite author proves the earth is flat, you do not need to accept that author in order to quote the passage where he describes sailing around the world. You quote it to show the man that his own source does not say what he thinks it says.

    That is what Jesus is doing. The scribes believed the psalm was David’s and that it was about the Christ. Jesus does not argue with either belief. He takes both of them as given and shows that, on their own terms, the Christ cannot be David’s son. The riddle is aimed at the scribes’ teaching, and it uses the scribes’ own text to bring that teaching down.

    What Jesus leaves unsaid matters too. He does not go on to explain how the Christ could be both David’s son and David’s Lord, which is what Tertullian assumed he meant. He does not finish the quotation in a way that sets the Christ up as the conqueror of David’s enemies; the church’s Luke continues with the line about making the enemies a footstool, but the True Testament does not include it, and nothing in this argument depends on that. He asks how the Christ can be David’s son, and he stops.

    An Early Witness

    The Marcionites were not the only early Christians to read the riddle this way. A letter written early in the second century, known as the Epistle of Barnabas, makes the same point directly. “Since therefore they are going to say that the Christ is David’s son,” the author writes, “David himself prophesies, fearing and understanding the error of the sinners.” He quotes the psalm and concludes, “See how David calls him Lord and does not say Son” (Epistle of Barnabas 12.10–11). Barnabas was no Marcionite, and he still read Jesus’ question as a denial that the Christ belonged to David’s line.

    Some modern scholars, studying the same riddle as it appears in the Gospel of Mark, have reached a similar conclusion. In the early 1900s the German scholars William Wrede and Wilhelm Bousset both argued that the saying reflects an early Christian rejection of the idea that the Christ must be David’s son. Theirs has never been the majority view, but it shows that the reading does not depend on being a Marcionite.

    A Different Right Hand

    One more detail carries forward into the trial. When Jesus stands before the council a few days later, he describes where he is going, and he does not mention a throne in Jerusalem. “But from now on, the Son of Man will be seated at the right hand of the power of God.” (Evangelion 15:17 TT).

    The Messiah of the prophets sits on the throne of David, in David’s city, ruling David’s people. The Son of Man in the first Gospel sits at the right hand of the power of God. One is a seat on earth that belongs to a dynasty. The other is a seat beside God that belongs to no family at all.

    The riddle in the temple is the last word Jesus says about David in the first Gospel. After that he is arrested, tried and put to death on a stake, and his followers scatter with all their hopes in pieces.