Jericho lies in the Jordan valley, some fifteen miles below Jerusalem, and in the days of Jesus the road through it was the usual route for pilgrims going up to the city. Beggars worked that road for the same reason they work busy streets today.
“As Jesus was approaching Jericho, a blind man was sitting by the road begging. When he heard a crowd going by, he asked what was happening. They told him, ‘Jesus is passing by!’” (Evangelion 12:7–9 TT).
The man does what anyone in his position would do. He shouts. “Jesus, Son of David, have mercy on me!” (Evangelion 12:10 TT). The people at the front of the procession try to hush him, which only makes him louder: “And those going ahead were rebuking him, telling him to be silent, but he shouted all the more, ‘Son of David, have mercy on me!’” (Evangelion 12:10a TT).
Jesus stops. He has the man brought to him and asks what he wants. The man says he wants to see again. “Jesus said, ‘Receive your sight. Your faith has made you well.’” (Evangelion 12:13 TT). The man can see, he follows Jesus praising God, and the crowd joins in.
The Objection
This is the strongest passage the church has against the argument of this book, and it cannot be passed over. A man calls Jesus “Son of David” twice, at the top of his voice, in front of a crowd. Jesus does not silence him the way he silenced the demons, and he does not correct him the way he corrected Peter. He heals him and praises his faith. Surely, the church says, that means Jesus accepted the title.
Tertullian made this very argument. Why did the blind man shout “Son of David,” he asked, “except that he was with good reason regarded as the son of David”? And when the people at the front tried to quiet him, Tertullian insisted they were doing it “because he was making a noise, not because he was wrong about the son of David” (Against Marcion 4.36).
It is a fair point, and it needs a real answer.
Mercy Does Not Wait for Correct Doctrine
The first part of the answer is that this is a man in desperate need asking for help, and the Father Jesus came to reveal is not in the habit of checking people’s theology before he helps them. “For he is kind even to the ungrateful and the wicked.” (Evangelion 3:35 TT). If the Father is kind to the ungrateful and the wicked, he can certainly be kind to a blind beggar who has the wrong title for his healer.
A nurse in an emergency room is sometimes called “Doctor” by a frightened patient. She does not stop to explain the difference between the two professions before she starts treatment. The patient is wrong about her title and right about the thing that matters, which is that she can help. Jesus does not stop on the road to Jericho to deliver a lecture on the house of David. A man is calling for mercy, and he receives it.
The Evangelion itself shows you what Jesus praised. He did not say, “You have called me by my correct name.” He said, “Your faith has made you well.” It was the man’s trust that mattered, not his vocabulary. And when the man finally comes face to face with Jesus and speaks to him directly, he uses a different title altogether: “Lord, I want to see again.” (Evangelion 12:12 TT).
Two Titles in One Chapter
The chapter of the Evangelion that contains the blind man also shows that Jesus was quite willing to correct a title when the moment called for it. A few paragraphs earlier a wealthy man approaches him with a question about life in the age to come and addresses him as “Good Teacher.” Jesus stops him at the first two words. “Don’t call me good. Only one is good: the Father.” (Evangelion 12:2 TT).
The difference between the two encounters lies in who is asking and what is being asked. The rich man has come for a discussion, and with him Jesus is exact about words. The beggar has come for his sight. With him Jesus asks a single question, “What do you want me to do for you?”, and then does it.
Who He Says He Is at Jericho
The first Gospel does not leave the blind man’s title as the last word at Jericho. In the very next scene Jesus goes into the town and is welcomed by Zacchaeus, a chief tax collector, who promises on the spot to give half his possessions to the poor. Jesus answers him, “Today rescue has come to this house, because the Son of Man came to rescue what was lost.” (Evangelion 12:18–19 TT).
The church’s Luke has a reason in the middle of that sentence which the True Testament does not include: “forsomuch as he also is a son of Abraham” (Luke 19:9, King James Version). In the church’s version Zacchaeus is rescued on account of his ancestry. In the first Gospel he is rescued because he was lost, and the Son of Man came for the lost.
So within a few lines of being hailed as Son of David, Jesus states in his own words who he is and what he came to do. He calls himself the Son of Man, and he describes his work as rescue. Neither the title nor the task belongs to the king of the prophets.
The Correction Comes Later
The second part of the answer is that Jesus did correct the title, only not on the road and not to a beggar. He corrected it in Jerusalem, in the temple courts, in front of the scribes, the professional teachers of the Law, who taught it.
We will look at that scene in the next chapter, and Tertullian himself connected the two. Discussing the riddle Jesus put to the scribes about David, Tertullian wrote that Jesus “had recently been called upon by that blind man as son of David: what he then refrained from saying, as he had no scribes present, he now in their presence brings forward” (Against Marcion 4.38).
Even the church’s most determined defender saw that Jesus held back on the road and spoke up later, and he saw that the two scenes belong together. Where we differ from Tertullian is in what Jesus said when he did speak up. Tertullian thought Jesus was adding a higher title to the lower one, so that the Christ was both David’s son and David’s Lord. The words Jesus actually used point the other way.
The blind man had learned “Son of David” from the scribes. It was what everybody said about the coming king. Jesus did not shame a beggar for repeating it. He took the question to the people responsible for the teaching, and he asked them how it could possibly be true.
