One Sabbath in Capernaum, soon after Jesus began teaching there, a man in the synagogue started shouting. He was possessed by a demon, and the demon knew exactly who had walked in. “What do you want with us, Jesus? Did you come here to destroy us? I know who you are: the holy one of God!” (Evangelion 1:5 TT).
If Jesus had come to be acclaimed as Israel’s promised king, this was free publicity in the most public place in town. He did not take it. “But Jesus rebuked him, saying, ‘Be quiet, and come out of him!’” (Evangelion 1:6 TT).
Soon afterward it happened again, on a larger scale. As he healed the sick one evening, demons came out of many people shouting, “You are the Son of God!” The Evangelion tells us what Jesus did and why. “But Jesus stopped them and wouldn’t let them speak, because they knew he was the Christ.” (Evangelion 1:12 TT).
The demons are not wrong about who he is. They know he is the Christ, and that is precisely why he shuts them up. He does not want the title spread around, and by the end of this chapter we will see why.
Peter Gets It Right and Is Told to Keep Quiet
The most famous moment comes some time later. Jesus is praying with his disciples and asks them who the crowds think he is. They give him the popular guesses: John the Immerser, whom the church calls John the Baptist; Elijah; or one of the old prophets come back to life. Then he asks them directly. “‘But who do you say I am?’ Peter answered, ‘You are the Christ.’” (Evangelion 5:31 TT).
In most churches this is the climax of the story, the moment the penny drops. You would expect Jesus to say “yes” and tell them to go and announce it. Instead, “Jesus warned them sharply and ordered them not to tell anyone” (Evangelion 5:32 TT). Then he tells them what is actually going to happen to him: “The Son of Man must suffer many things, be rejected by the elders, the scribes and the chief priests, be killed, and after three days be awakened.” (Evangelion 5:33 TT).
A Messiah of David’s line does not get rejected by the elders and killed. He defeats his enemies and takes the throne. Peter has the right word but the wrong picture, and Jesus answers the wrong picture by forbidding the word and describing his death.
This was not a new reading in the second century. Tertullian argued that Jesus kept Peter quiet only because the time was not yet right, and in making that argument he reported what the Marcionites said instead. “Quite so, you say: because that supposition was incorrect, and he did not wish a lie to be spread abroad” (Against Marcion 4.21). The Marcionites read the silence as a correction, and Tertullian knew it.
Before the Council and Before Pilate
The last time the title comes up is at his trial, and here Jesus is cornered. The council asks him outright: “If you are the Christ, tell us.” He replies, “If I told you, you wouldn’t believe it.” (Evangelion 15:16 TT). They press him: “So you are the Son of God then?” And he answers, “Those are your words.” (Evangelion 15:18 TT).
Then they take him to Pilate with a list of charges, and the last of them is “claiming to be the Christ, a king” (Evangelion 15:20 TT). Pilate asks him, “Are you the Christ?” Jesus answers, “You say so.” (Evangelion 15:21 TT).
Only one group uses the word “king” in that scene. In the whole of the first Gospel, the only people who call Jesus a king are the men accusing him in front of Pilate. The church’s Luke has more. It has the crowd at his entry into Jerusalem crying “Blessed be the King that cometh in the name of the Lord” (Luke 19:38, King James Version), and it has the sign fixed over his head at his death, “This is the King of the Jews” (Luke 23:38, King James Version). Neither line is in the True Testament.
What He Was Charged With
The list of charges read out to Pilate is longer in the first Gospel than in the church’s Luke, and the additional lines matter. “We found this man misleading the people, opposing the Law and the Prophets, telling them not to pay taxes, turning wives and children away, and claiming to be the Christ, a king.” (Evangelion 15:20 TT).
Set the second item beside the last. His accusers say he opposes the Law and the Prophets, and they also say he claims to be the Christ, a king. Both charges cannot be true of the Messiah Israel expected. The promised king was the champion of the Law and the fulfilment of the Prophets. A man who opposed them could not be their Christ, and a man who was their Christ would not oppose them. The accusers were throwing everything they had at the governor, and in doing so they left a record of how Jesus had come across to them, as someone who stood against the Law and the Prophets.
The charge about taxes was false, and readers of the Gospel know it. When Jesus was asked in the temple whether taxes should be paid to the emperor, he asked for a coin, pointed to the emperor’s image on it and said, “Then give to Caesar what belongs to Caesar, and give to God what belongs to God.” (Evangelion 13:13 TT). No Messiah of David’s line could have given that answer. Freeing Israel from tribute to foreign rulers was close to the center of his task. Jesus hands the coin back as if the question of who collects the taxes had nothing to do with why he came.
The Man the Crowd Preferred
Pilate found nothing wrong with him, and on learning that he was a Galilean, he sent him to Herod Antipas, the ruler of Galilee, who was in Jerusalem at the time. Herod “hoped to see him perform some sign.” He questioned him at length, “but Jesus gave him no answer.” (Evangelion 15:26–27 TT). Herod belonged to the family Rome had set over the Jews, a family without a drop of David’s blood. A claimant to that throne, brought face to face with him, might have been expected to say something. Jesus says nothing at all.
Then the crowd makes its choice. “Take this man away, but release Barabbas for us!” (Evangelion 15:28 TT). The Gospel identifies Barabbas as a man “thrown into prison for insurrection and murder” (Evangelion 15:29 TT). He had taken up arms. Whatever else he was, he was the kind of man who fights for Israel’s freedom, and that was the kind of deliverer the crowd understood. Offered a teacher who would not claim the crown and a rebel who had already shed blood for the cause, they asked for the rebel.
At the Stake
The church’s Luke fills the scene of the execution with royal language. The rulers jeer, “let him save himself, if he be Christ, the chosen of God.” The soldiers call out, “If thou be the king of the Jews, save thyself.” One of the criminals dying beside him asks, “Lord, remember me when thou comest into thy kingdom” (Luke 23:35, 37, 42, King James Version).
The True Testament does not include any of those lines. The words it records from Jesus at the stake are addressed to one person. “Father, forgive them, for they don’t know what they’re doing.” (Evangelion 15:32 TT). And at the end: “Father, I entrust my spirit into your hands!” (Evangelion 15:35 TT). He dies speaking to the Father who sent him. Nobody at the scene mentions a kingdom, and neither does he.
Why the Silence
Put these scenes together and a pattern appears. When demons name him, he silences them. When his closest friend names him, he forbids the disciples to repeat it and talks about his death instead. When his judges demand the title, he hands it back to them as their own words. The only time he is called a king, it is a charge against him.
If Jesus were the Messiah of the prophets, this would be very strange behavior. The whole point of that Messiah is to be recognized, crowned and obeyed. A king who keeps refusing his own title is like a groom who keeps telling the guests the wedding is somebody else’s.
But if Jesus was sent by a different God for a different purpose, the silence makes sense. Every time someone used the word “Christ,” they meant the Creator’s king, the son of David who would sit on the throne in Jerusalem. That was the one thing he was not. He could not accept the title on those terms without accepting a mission he had never been given.
There is one scene, though, where he seems to let the title stand, and it is the scene every defender of the church’s view will point to. A blind man by the road calls him Son of David, and Jesus heals him without a word of correction. The next chapter takes it up.
