This is a novel. The conversations in it are imagined. The dates and the books are not.
Marcion of Sinope was a shipowner from Pontus who came to Rome in the reign of Antoninus Pius. He gave the Roman assembly a large sum, which Tertullian puts at two hundred thousand sesterces, was for a time within that assembly, and was put out of it. The Marcionites themselves dated the break at one hundred and fifteen years and six and a half months after the fifteenth year of Tiberius, which is the summer of 144. He published a gospel with no birth narrative and ten letters of Paul as one book, with a work of his own called the Antitheses beside it. Justin, writing in Rome about 155, says he was still alive and teaching and had followers in every race of men. Irenaeus records that Cerdo taught in Rome before him under Hyginus and was put out, that Marcion flourished under Anicetus, and that Polycarp, in Rome in those years, answered Marcion’s “Do you know me?” with “I know you, the firstborn of Satan.” Tertullian records that Apelles was Marcion’s disciple and left him, went to Alexandria, and later returned to Rome, where he followed a prophetess named Philumene. Rhodo, quoted by Eusebius, met Apelles in his old age and records that he taught one principle and said the question of God should not be examined too closely. The novel keeps Apelles and Philumene in Alexandria for the whole of his account. No source gives the date or place of Marcion’s death; about 160 is the usual estimate. Most scholars date Polycarp’s death to 155 or 156; the novel places it a year later, in February 157. All of that is in the book as the sources have it.
The Roman assembly’s reading of Paul before Marcion, the dust on the chest, the hearing, Stephanus’s speech about antiquity and the magistrate, Hermas’s loaf, the night the money was counted, the dinner with Valentinus, the letter to Flora read aloud, and every word spoken by every person, are invented. So are the storm on the Euxine, the customs search at Ostia, the raid on the room on the quay, Ezra’s visit to Rome, the leaf carried out of Polemon’s room, Valentinus being put out of the Roman assembly, Ptolemy’s letter reaching Marcion, the Vicus Tuscus as the place where Marcion met Polycarp, Marcion’s presence at Polycarp’s death, and the teacher in the Cappadocian village. Philologus, Marcellus, Dionysios the grammarian, Kallias, Chrysis, Vahan, Argos, Theodorus, Lysander, Nikomedes, Thaddeus, Ezra and Yosef, Nikias and Melitta, Valeria, Agathon, Polemon, Linus, Trophimus, Gaius, Lydia, Prisca, Rufus, Demas, Nerissa, Stephanus, Demetrius, Corvinus, Florens, Hyacinthus, Tobias, Tertia and Felix, Attalos, Helena, Artemidoros, and Marcella are invented. Lucan is a real disciple of Marcion, named by Tertullian and Hippolytus, but his character here is invented. Epiphanius, writing two centuries later, says Marcion’s father was bishop of Sinope and put his son out for seducing a virgin; this book does not use that story and the reader should know it exists. Eusebius names a Marcionite presbyter, Metrodorus, burned at Smyrna, and places him beside Polycarp; most scholars now set him with Pionius a century later, so the book gives Helena an invented husband and tells the reader here.
One thing in this book is neither sourced nor invented but argued. The assembly that produced it holds that the Evangelion Marcion published was older than the four gospels of the church, and that he received it from the assemblies of Asia and did not compose or cut it. It holds that Luke, the Acts, and the letters to Timothy and Titus were written in answer to his publication. That is a minority position among historians, most of whom hold that Luke came first and Marcion shortened it. The ancient writers also report that Marcion expected the Creator’s Christ to come one day for the Jews. The assembly does not hold that view, and the novel follows the assembly. The novel tells the story the assembly’s way, with the books arriving in Rome after the publication, because that is the assembly’s account and the book is honest about whose account it is. Tertullian, two generations after these events, calls Paul “the apostle of the heretics” and complains that Marcion accepted a letter to one man and rejected three about the church. Both are in Against Marcion, and both are in this book because they were too good to leave out.
The quotations from the Evangelion and the ten letters follow the True Testament, the assembly’s reconstruction of Marcion’s text from the quotations of his enemies. That is what the last page of the story says would one day be done.
