Chapter 1 of 24

    What Israel Was Promised

    9 min read

    0:0010:36

    🎧 Listen while you read

    Suppose your grandfather left a letter saying the family farm would one day go to his great-grandson, a boy who would grow up, take over the fields and make the place prosper again. Now suppose a stranger arrives in town. He has never farmed, he owns no land, and he says the farm does not interest him. Then the neighbors announce that he is the great-grandson from the letter, and that “farm” was a figure of speech all along.

    You would have questions, and so should we. Three thousand years ago a prophet named Nathan gave King David a promise much like that letter. It named a son, a throne and a kingdom. This chapter is about what that promise said, because you cannot decide whether someone fulfilled a promise until you have read it.

    A House for a House

    David ruled Israel about a thousand years before Jesus. He had started life as a shepherd, fought his way to the crown, and made Jerusalem his capital. Once he was settled in a fine palace of cedar, it began to bother him that the God of Israel was still worshipped in a tent. So he told the prophet Nathan that he meant to build God a proper house, by which he meant a temple.

    The answer that came back, in the seventh chapter of the second book of Samuel, turns on a play on words. David would not build God a house. God would build David a house, and by that he meant a family of kings. “I will set up thy seed after thee,” the promise runs, “and I will stablish the throne of his kingdom for ever.” And again, a few lines later: “thine house and thy kingdom shall be established for ever before thee: thy throne shall be established for ever” (2 Samuel 7:12–13, 16, King James Version).

    The words are ordinary ones. A seed is a descendant, a child of David’s own body. A throne is a chair that a king sits in, and a kingdom is a country with borders and a capital. Nobody who heard Nathan that day thought he was speaking in riddles. David certainly did not. He thanked God for speaking about his family “for a great while to come,” which is how a man talks when he has just been promised a dynasty.

    Sworn on Oath

    The promise was not left as a single conversation between a prophet and a king. Israel sang it. The book of Psalms, the hymnbook of the temple, returns to it again and again, and in the Psalms the promise takes the form of an oath. “I have made a covenant with my chosen, I have sworn unto David my servant, Thy seed will I establish for ever, and build up thy throne to all generations” (Psalm 89:3–4, King James Version). Later in the same psalm God is heard saying, “Once have I sworn by my holiness that I will not lie unto David. His seed shall endure for ever, and his throne as the sun before me” (Psalm 89:35–36, King James Version).

    Another psalm puts it in the most physical terms available: “The LORD hath sworn in truth unto David; he will not turn from it; Of the fruit of thy body will I set upon thy throne” (Psalm 132:11, King James Version). The fruit of a man’s body is his children. The language was chosen so that nobody could take it for a figure of speech.

    An oath is the strongest form a promise can take. When the God of Israel swears by his own holiness that he will not lie to David, he has left himself no room to mean something else.

    When the Throne Went Empty

    For about four hundred years the promise looked safe. One descendant of David after another ruled in Jerusalem. Some were good kings and a number were dreadful, but there was always a son of David on the throne.

    Then, in 586 BC, the army of Babylon broke through the walls of Jerusalem. The city was burned and the temple was torn down. The last king of David’s line, a man named Zedekiah, was captured, blinded and led away in chains, and much of the nation was marched off into exile with him. The throne that was supposed to last forever stood empty.

    You might expect the promise to have died that day. What happened was the reverse. The emptier the throne became, the louder the prophets spoke about the one who would fill it again. The prophet Jeremiah, who lived through the disaster, wrote that “David shall never want a man to sit upon the throne of the house of Israel” (Jeremiah 33:17, King James Version). The prophet Ezekiel, writing from exile, said, “David my servant shall be king over them,” and that the people “shall dwell in the land” that had been given to their fathers (Ezekiel 37:24–25, King James Version). The prophet Isaiah spoke of a day when God would “assemble the outcasts of Israel, and gather together the dispersed of Judah from the four corners of the earth” (Isaiah 11:12, King James Version).

    The people did not take the disaster quietly, and their protest is preserved in the same psalm that records the oath. After reciting everything God had sworn, the psalmist turns on him: “But thou hast cast off and abhorred, thou hast been wroth with thine anointed. Thou hast made void the covenant of thy servant: thou hast profaned his crown by casting it to the ground” (Psalm 89:38–39, King James Version). Near the end he asks, “Lord, where are thy former lovingkindnesses, which thou swarest unto David in thy truth?” (Psalm 89:49, King James Version).

    Whoever wrote those lines understood the promise the way David had. A real crown had been thrown to the ground, and he wanted to know when a real crown would be picked up again. It did not occur to him to console himself with the thought that the throne had been a spiritual one all along.

    This is where the word “Messiah” comes in. In Hebrew it is mashiach, and it means “anointed.” Israel’s kings were not crowned the way European kings were. A prophet or priest poured oil on the new king’s head, and from then on he was “the anointed one.” When Jews later began to translate their scriptures into Greek, they used the Greek word for “anointed,” which is christos. So “Messiah” and “Christ” are the same word in two languages, and in the beginning both of them meant something quite simple: the king.

    Five Centuries of Waiting

    About fifty years after the fall of Jerusalem, the Persian king Cyrus allowed the exiles to go home. They rebuilt the temple on a smaller scale, and for a moment it looked as though the throne would follow. The governor of the little province was a man named Zerubbabel, a grandson of one of the last kings and therefore a son of David. The prophet Haggai announced that God “will make thee as a signet: for I have chosen thee” (Haggai 2:23, King James Version). Then Zerubbabel drops out of the record. He was never crowned, and no descendant of David governed after him.

    For the next five hundred years the Jewish people lived under one foreign empire after another: the Persians, then the Greek kings who followed Alexander the Great, then Rome. In the second century BC a family of priests called the Hasmoneans, better known as the Maccabees, won independence for about eighty years and eventually took the title of king. They were not from David’s line, and many devout Jews held it against them. When Rome took control, it gave the crown to Herod, whose family were recent converts from the neighboring land of Idumea. By the time of Jesus the throne in Jerusalem had been held by priests and by a client of Rome, and not once in half a millennium by the family it had been promised to.

    All of this made the hope sharper. Every ruler who was not a son of David was a reminder of the one who was supposed to be.

    The Promise in Four Parts

    If you gather up what the prophets said, the promised king can be described in four parts, and the rest of this book returns to them often.

    1. He is a man of David’s own bloodline, a descendant in the ordinary sense.
    2. He sits on a real throne in Jerusalem and governs a real kingdom.
    3. He gathers the scattered people of Israel and brings them home to their land.
    4. He defeats Israel’s enemies and gives the nation lasting peace.

    This was not one opinion among several. It was what people were praying for. About sixty years before Jesus, the Roman general Pompey marched into Jerusalem, and a Jewish poet answered with a prayer that has come down to us in a collection called the Psalms of Solomon. He asks God to raise up for Israel its king, the son of David, to break the power of the foreign rulers and to clear Jerusalem of the nations that had trampled it. He was asking for a ruler with an army and a capital, and nothing in his prayer points to a teacher or a healer.

    The hope went into the daily prayers as well, and it is still there. The central prayer of the synagogue, which observant Jews recite three times every weekday, includes this petition: “Speedily cause the offspring of David, your servant, to flourish.” A person who has prayed that sentence morning, afternoon and evening for a lifetime does not have a symbolic king in mind.

    Even the church’s own scriptures remember that this is what people expected. In the first chapter of the book of Acts, which the church places after its four Gospels, the disciples are given one last chance to ask the risen Jesus a question, and they ask this: “Lord, wilt thou at this time restore again the kingdom to Israel?” (Acts 1:6, King James Version). After everything they had seen, they were still waiting for the throne.

    What Had to Change

    Compare that list of four with the life of Jesus as the church itself tells it. He held no office and commanded no army. He never sat on a throne in Jerusalem, and when he did enter the city he was executed there within the week. The scattered tribes of Israel were not gathered home. As for peace from Israel’s enemies, about forty years later the Romans destroyed Jerusalem a second time, and its people were scattered more widely than before.

    The church did not respond by concluding that Jesus was someone other than the promised king. It kept the title and changed the promise. The throne in Jerusalem became a throne in heaven, and the kingdom became the church. “Israel” came to mean Christians, and the enemies to be defeated turned into sin and death. Every one of the four parts was kept in name and replaced in substance, which is what the neighbors did with the farm.

    You can admire the ingenuity of that solution and still notice what it costs. It asks you to believe that the God of Israel made a promise to David in ordinary words, repeated it through his prophets for centuries, let his people pray for it under foreign rule, and all the while meant something that none of them could have understood from the words.

    There is another way to read the evidence, and it is much simpler. The promise meant what it said. The prophets were promising a king, a throne and a nation, and the Jewish people have read them correctly all along. If that is so, then the man who came down to Capernaum in the fifteenth year of Tiberius was never that king, and the question becomes who he was.

    Before we can answer that, there is one more piece of ground to clear. Every December the church reads a handful of prophecies that are supposed to settle the matter: a virgin who will conceive, a ruler who will come from Bethlehem, a branch that will grow from the family of David. They are the best evidence the church has, and the next chapter takes them one at a time.