Your Church says openly where the list of books came from. Your Catechism states: “It was by the apostolic Tradition that the Church discerned which writings are to be included in the list of the sacred books” (paragraph 120). Many churches never say where their list came from. You and we agree that the books did not list themselves.
Your Church has also always taught that faith must work, and so did Paul. In the Douay-Rheims, the old Catholic translation, he writes (Galatians 5:6):
For in Christ Jesus neither circumcision availeth any thing, nor uncircumcision: but faith that worketh by charity.
My questions are about the authority that made the list. The quotations below are from the Catechism of the Catholic Church and the Douay-Rheims Bible.
1. What did the rock do at Antioch?
Your Catechism says: “The Lord made Simon alone, whom he named Peter, the ‘rock’ of his Church” (paragraph 881), and it teaches that his office continues in the Pope. Paul tells of a day in Antioch (Galatians 2:11 and 2:14):
But when Cephas was come to Antioch, I withstood him to the face, because he was to be blamed.
But when I saw that they walked not uprightly unto the truth of the gospel, I said to Cephas before them all: If thou, being a Jew, livest after the manner of the Gentiles, and not as the Jews do, how dost thou compel the Gentiles to live as do the Jews?
The True Testament has the scene too (Galatians 2:9 TT):
But when Peter came to Antioch, I opposed him to his face, because he stood condemned.
This is the one place in Paul’s letters where we watch Peter act under pressure. He gets it wrong, in public, on a matter Paul calls “the truth of the gospel,” and the man who corrects him was never one of the Twelve. Paul does not tell us that Peter accepted the correction. If the office of Peter exists to guard the truth of the gospel, then Paul records a test of it, and Peter did not pass.
May I ask: Peter was “to be blamed” over the truth of the gospel, and Paul was there to say so. Who has the standing to say so to Peter’s successors?
Catholic writers have long answered that Peter’s fault was in his conduct, while his teaching stayed sound. Paul says the fault touched “the truth of the gospel,” and that Peter was compelling others to follow him in it.
2. Did Paul need the Twelve?
Your Church teaches that the gospel is handed on through the apostles and their successors, the bishops. Paul describes how the gospel reached him (Galatians 1:11 to 1:12 and 2:6):
For I give you to understand, brethren, that the gospel which was preached by me is not according to man. For neither did I receive it of man, nor did I learn it; but by the revelation of Jesus Christ.
But of them who seemed to be some thing, (what they were some time, it is nothing to me, God accepteth not the person of man,) for to me they that seemed to be some thing added nothing.
Apostolic succession is a chain, and Paul tells us he is not a link in it. He neither received the gospel from Peter nor learned it from him. When he finally met the leaders in Jerusalem, they “added nothing.” If the gospel reached Paul without the Twelve, then it does not have to come through the Twelve, or through the men who sit in their chairs.
May I ask: why must my gospel come through Peter’s chair, when Paul’s did not come through Peter?
The usual Catholic reading is that Paul went up to Jerusalem to have his gospel approved, since he laid it before the leaders “lest perhaps I had run, or should be running, in vain” (2:2), and they gave him “the right hands of fellowship” (2:9). Paul says he went up “according to revelation,” and what he reports of the meeting is that they added nothing. What he describes is a handshake between men who kept to separate fields, and two verses later he is correcting Peter to his face.
3. Can a party to the dispute be its judge?
The Catechism says: “The Church has always vigorously opposed the idea of rejecting the Old Testament under the pretext that the New has rendered it void (Marcionism)” (paragraph 123). It names us in the section that explains how the list of sacred books was settled.
Our list is the oldest one known. The Church’s list was drawn up afterward, by the side that had already expelled us, and it is now offered as the proof that we were wrong. In any other dispute we would not let one party write the evidence and also sit as judge.
I grant that the evidence for our text comes from the same hands. No ancient copy of the Evangelion survives, and it is rebuilt from the quotations of the men who wrote against it. For what our gospel said, their testimony is all that either of us has, and it comes from one side.
May I ask: what evidence, apart from the Church’s verdict, shows that her list is truer than ours?
The Church has long said that Marcion cut down the Gospel of Luke. I take up that charge in the last chapter.
4. Never revoked?
The Catechism calls the Old Testament “an indispensable part of Sacred Scripture” and says that “the Old Covenant has never been revoked” (paragraph 121). Your Hebrews 8:13 says:
Now in saying a new, he hath made the former old. And that which decayeth and groweth old, is near its end.
May I ask: which is it, never revoked or near its end?
Catholic theologians distinguish the two. Hebrews, they say, speaks of the Levitical priesthood and its sacrifices, and the Catechism speaks of God’s calling of Israel, which your Romans 11:29 says is without repentance. But Hebrews says “the former,” meaning the covenant, and the Catechism says “the Old Covenant.” The two sentences are about the same thing. We receive neither Hebrews nor that part of Romans, so the difficulty is not ours.
5. What is left after forgiveness?
According to the Catechism, those who die in God’s grace “but still imperfectly purified” undergo a purification after death, and “the Church gives the name Purgatory to this final purification of the elect” (paragraphs 1030 to 1031). Paul writes in Colossians 2:13:
And you, when you were dead in your sins, and the uncircumcision of your flesh; he hath quickened together with him, forgiving you all offences:
The Catechism also teaches that sin, once forgiven, still leaves a “temporal punishment” to be undergone here or after death, and that indulgences remit it (paragraphs 1471 to 1473). It says that the punishments of sin “must not be conceived of as a kind of vengeance inflicted by God from without, but as following from the very nature of sin.” Paul says that all offences are forgiven. If all are forgiven, there is no penalty left for the dead to bear.
May I ask: what is left to be undergone after death, once God has forgiven all our offences?
The Church distinguishes guilt from its consequences. David was told that his sin was taken away, and the child still died. That is told of the God of the Old Testament. Paul’s sentence about the Father has no such remainder in it.
The passage most often given for purgatory is in 2 Machabees 12, where Judas sends silver to Jerusalem “for sacrifice to be offered for the sins of the dead.” Under the coats of those dead were found “some of the donaries of the idols of Jamnia, which the law forbiddeth to the Jews.” By your Catechism, purgatory is only for those who die in God’s grace and friendship, and those who die in mortal sin go to hell (paragraphs 1030 and 1035). The note in the Douay answers that Judas hoped these men were excused by ignorance, or had repented as they died. Judas did think of them as men “who had fallen asleep with godliness” (12:45). The passage records his hope for men who died wearing the tokens of idols. It gives nothing to support that hope.
Another text offered is 1 Corinthians 3:15, where a man “shall be saved, yet so as by fire.” Two verses before it, in the Douay, the fire tries “every man’s work,” on “the day of the Lord.” Paul says nothing there about souls suffering between death and that day.
6. Who is blessed?
Your Church honors Mary above every other creature and asks for her prayers. There is one moment in your gospels when someone in a crowd, in the hearing of Jesus, calls blessed the mother she takes him to have. Luke records it (11:27 to 11:28):
And it came to pass, as he spoke these things, a certain woman from the crowd, lifting up her voice, said to him: Blessed is the womb that bore thee, and the paps that gave thee suck. But he said: Yea rather, blessed are they who hear the word of God, and keep it.
In the Douay he answers “Yea rather.” In our text he answers “No” (Evangelion 7:21 TT). In Luke 8 he is told that a mother and brethren are standing outside, and he answers that his mother and brethren are those who hear the word of God and do it. In our text he first asks, “Who is my mother, and who are my brothers?” (Evangelion 4:36 TT). Both times a family is claimed for him, and both times he turns from the family to those who hear the word.
May I ask: why does the Church’s devotion point back to Mary, when Jesus, the one time a mother was called blessed in his hearing, pointed to those who hear the word of God and keep it?
In your Luke 1:48 Mary says that all generations shall call her blessed, and Catholics add that she was the first to hear the word and keep it. To call someone blessed is one thing. Prayers, feasts and titles such as Queen of Heaven are a great deal more, and when the subject was raised with Jesus he turned it toward the hearers of the word.
