I grew up Lutheran, and three things your church confesses I still confess. Your Augsburg Confession says that people “are freely justified for Christ’s sake, through faith” (Article IV), and that the human will “has no power, without the Holy Ghost, to work the righteousness of God” (Article XVIII). Your Formula of Concord says that “the distinction between the Law and the Gospel is to be maintained in the Church with great diligence as an especially brilliant light” (Epitome V). My questions are about what your church does with that light afterward.
The Bible quoted in this chapter is the King James, and the confessional quotations are from the Book of Concord.
1. Two words, but one speaker?
Lutherans are taught that Law and Gospel are two words from one God. The Law accuses, and the Gospel pardons. Paul sets the two side by side (2 Corinthians 3:6 and 3:9):
Who also hath made us able ministers of the new testament; not of the letter, but of the spirit: for the letter killeth, but the spirit giveth life.
For if the ministration of condemnation be glory, much more doth the ministration of righteousness exceed in glory.
Between those two verses Paul calls what was “written and engraven in stones” a “ministration of death.” He is talking about the Ten Commandments. He grants that ministration a glory, and in verse 11 the King James calls it “that which is done away.”
Luther saw the difficulty. He called the Law’s work of accusing and killing God’s alien work, and the Gospel His proper work. If God must do work that is alien to Him, He begins to look like two characters under one name. The Formula of Concord keeps the two words apart and then says, without showing it, that one God speaks both.
May I ask: what in Paul’s words tells you that the ministration of death and the ministration of the spirit have the same author?
Your Galatians 3:24 will be quoted: “the law was our schoolmaster to bring us unto Christ.” The next verse says: “But after that faith is come, we are no longer under a schoolmaster.” Paul’s point there is that the schoolmaster’s term has ended. He does not say there that the schoolmaster spoke with the Father’s voice.
2. Redeemed from whose curse?
Your Small Catechism explains the close of the Commandments in these words: “God threatens to punish all that transgress these commandments. Therefore we should dread His wrath and not act contrary to these commandments.” Paul says what Christ did about that threat (Galatians 3:13):
Christ hath redeemed us from the curse of the law, being made a curse for us: for it is written, Cursed is every one that hangeth on a tree:
In the True Testament the verse reads (Galatians 3:9 TT):
Christ purchased us from the curse of Law by becoming a curse for us, for it is written: “Cursed is everyone who hangs on a tree.”
To redeem is to buy out, and Paul says what we were bought out of: the curse of the Law. In Lutheran teaching the Father is the one who is owed, the one who sends the payment, and the one who receives it. On that account God pays Himself. That teaching also empties a word Paul uses in Colossians 2:13, where he says God has “forgiven you all trespasses.” If the debt was collected in full, even from His Son, it was not forgiven. We hold that the price is what it cost Christ, and that it was paid to no one.
May I ask: whose curse did Christ redeem you from, if the Law and its curse belong to his Father?
Your Catechism answers that Christ redeemed you “from all sins, from death, and from the power of the devil.” Paul’s verse names something else, the curse of the Law, and your Catechism says the Law’s threat is God’s own.
3. Dead to the Law, or still under it?
Your Formula of Concord says that “the preaching of the Law is to be urged with diligence, not only upon the unbelieving and impenitent, but also upon true believers” (Epitome VI). Set that beside Romans 7:6 and Galatians 3:10:
But now we are delivered from the law, that being dead wherein we were held; that we should serve in newness of spirit, and not in the oldness of the letter.
For as many as are of the works of the law are under the curse: for it is written, Cursed is every one that continueth not in all things which are written in the book of the law to do them.
That Article of the Formula was written because Lutherans could not agree among themselves whether the Law still applies to believers. Its answer is that believers “have been freed and exempted from the curse and coercion of the Law” and must have it preached to them. In Galatians, those who are “of the works of the law” are under its curse. The Formula teaches a Law with the curse taken out. Paul does not, and he goes further than “exempted.” His word is “delivered,” and in our text “released” (Romans 7:3 TT).
May I ask: where does Paul describe a Law that still commands the believer but can no longer curse him?
Two passages will be offered. Romans 7:12 says “the law is holy, and the commandment holy, and just, and good.” Two verses earlier, in your Bible, Paul says that this same commandment “I found to be unto death,” and then that sin “by it slew me.” He calls it holy and says he has been delivered from it. Romans 13:9 does quote commandments to believers, and it does so to say they are “briefly comprehended” in loving your neighbor. Paul hangs no threat on them there, and the Catechism does.
4. What did the Son reveal?
Your church holds that the God of Moses and the prophets is the Father of Jesus Christ, and that the Old Testament had already made Him known. The first chapter quoted Luke 10:22, where Jesus says that no man knows “who the Father is, but the Son, and he to whom the Son will reveal him.”
Luther’s theology of the cross says that God is known only in Christ, and that God apart from Christ is hidden and terrifying. We say the first half with him: the Father is known only in Christ. The God who terrifies apart from Christ we take to be another.
May I ask: if Moses and the prophets already knew the Father, what was left for the Son to reveal?
Lutheran teachers say the prophets knew Him through His promises, before Christ was seen. The words of Jesus leave no room for a dim knowledge. No man knows who the Father is except the Son, and the prophets desired to see what the disciples saw and did not see it.
5. Why does the Catechism begin with Moses?
The first chief part of your Catechism is the Ten Commandments, and it closes with the God who visits “the iniquity of the fathers upon the children unto the third and fourth generation.” Luke 16:16 reads:
The law and the prophets were until John: since that time the kingdom of God is preached, and every man presseth into it.
Luther half agreed with that verse. In a sermon of 1525 on how Christians should regard Moses, he said that Moses is dead and that his rule ended when Christ came, and that the Ten Commandments bind Christians only as natural law. Four years later he put those commandments first in the Catechism. The form he used leaves out the words against images and says “the holy-day” in place of the Sabbath day, and it keeps the threat of Exodus 20:5.
May I ask: why is Moses the first thing a Lutheran child memorizes, if Moses’ rule ended when Christ came?
If the Commandments stand in the Catechism only as natural law, the threat that closes them should not be there. It is quoted from Sinai. The objection from Luke 16:17, that no tittle of the Law shall fail, was answered under the fourth question for every church.
6. Guilty, or captive?
Your Augsburg Confession says that “since the fall of Adam all men begotten in the natural way are born with sin,” and that this “is truly sin, even now condemning and bringing eternal death upon those not born again through Baptism and the Holy Ghost” (Article II). Unless he is baptized, a newborn is condemned before he has done anything. Paul describes our condition before Christ differently (Galatians 4:3):
Even so we, when we were children, were in bondage under the elements of the world:
Inherited guilt got its lasting form from Augustine, who leaned heavily on a Latin rendering of Romans 5:12. His Latin read “in whom all sinned,” meaning in Adam. The Greek is most naturally read “because all sinned,” and the King James has it so: “for that all have sinned.” So the sentence Augustine leaned on is not in your Romans. Our Romans does not have the passage.
May I ask: Paul calls our condition before Christ bondage. Where does he say the captive is also condemned before he has done anything?
Your Romans 5:18 is the verse most often raised here. It says that “judgment came upon all men to condemnation.” The same verse goes on to say that “the free gift came upon all men unto justification of life,” so whatever came on all through Adam is answered for all through Christ, and the verse does not make it wait for baptism. Ephesians 2:3 is the other. It says we “were by nature the children of wrath.” The verse before it says under whom we lived then: “according to the prince of the power of the air.” The wrath belongs to the place we are rescued from. In 1 Thessalonians 5:9 Paul says that “God hath not appointed us to wrath.”
7. Who blinds?
Your church teaches that God wants all people to be saved, and that the blindness of unbelievers is their own fault and the devil’s work. Paul writes that “the god of this world hath blinded the minds of them which believe not” (2 Corinthians 4:4).
Lutherans take that god to be the devil. Luther was not content to stop there. In The Bondage of the Will he had to explain how one God could harden some and offer grace to all, and his answer was that behind the God who is preached stands a hidden God, whose will Christians are not to search out. That book is not among your Confessions, though the Formula of Concord cites it with approval. The Formula denies that God wills anyone’s damnation, and it allows blindness only as His punishment for sin already committed. Paul gives one cause for the blindness, and he calls that cause a god.
May I ask: Paul calls the one who blinds a god. Where does he say that this god is a creature of the Father?
One answer is Colossians 1:16 in your Bible, where all thrones and powers are created through Christ. That list does not name a god, and in the verse before us Paul does. Our text does not have your Colossians 1:16.
8. Why keep the four?
You hold to Scripture alone. Luther’s test for a book was that whatever does not teach Christ is not apostolic, even if Peter or Paul does the teaching. In 1522 he set Hebrews, James, Jude and Revelation apart at the back of his New Testament, partly because the ancient church had doubted them and partly by that test. Paul gives a test of the same kind (Galatians 1:8):
But though we, or an angel from heaven, preach any other gospel unto you than that which we have preached unto you, let him be accursed.
“Scripture alone” cannot tell you which books are Scripture, and the Lutheran Confessions never give a list. Luther filled that gap by measuring books against the gospel. He weighed the books, found some wanting, and kept them in the volume anyway.
May I ask: when a book fails the gospel’s test, as Luther judged that James did, why is it still bound in your Bible?
A Lutheran may say that Luther’s prefaces were his private judgment and bind no one. Then the question of who decided the list returns, because the Confessions give none. To rank the books by the gospel is to set the gospel over Scripture as its measure. We hold that measure too, and we do not bind in the books that fail it.
