A Doctrine Placed Late
With this chapter we come to the fourth part of our reply, and to the doctrine for which Calvin is best known and least loved. Calvin did not set predestination beside providence in his first Book, where a reader who had followed his account of God's government of every event might expect it. In the final edition he placed it near the end of the third Book, after faith, repentance, justification, Christian liberty and prayer. For Calvin election is not a speculation about heaven. It answers a question that faith itself raises: why do some believe and others not?
He opens with that question. "The covenant of life is not preached equally among all people, and among those to whom it is preached it does not find the same place, either equally or permanently" (III.21.1). The difference, he says, shows the depth of God's judgment and serves his purpose of eternal election. He knows how it sounds. "To many it seems a perplexing question, because they think nothing less fitting than that, out of the common multitude of mankind, some should be predestined to salvation and others to destruction" (III.21.1). But he insists that the doctrine is useful and even sweet, and he gives his reason in a sentence that governs everything after it. "We shall never be clearly persuaded, as we ought to be, that our salvation flows from the fountain of God's free mercy, until his eternal election has become known to us," and grace is shown by contrast, because God "does not adopt all without distinction into the hope of salvation, but gives to some what he denies to others" (III.21.1).
We will return to that idea of contrast, because it is where Calvin and the Evangelion part. To the curious he says that Scripture is the only path (III.21.1 to III.21.2); to the timid, who would rather the subject were never mentioned, he says that "This will be the best limit of sobriety: that we not only follow God as he always goes before us in learning, but, when he himself makes an end of teaching, stop wanting to be wise" (III.21.3). The distinction he needs for the whole matter comes from Moses: the secret things belong to God, and the revealed things to us and our children (III.21.3).
Here we say at once where Calvin deserves respect. Many theologians have taught some form of predestination and then spent their energy making it sound like something else. Calvin will not. Profane men mock the doctrine, he grants, but they mock the Trinity and the creation too (III.21.4). Then he turns the charge of carelessness back on the cautious. "Whoever, therefore, loads the doctrine of predestination with odium openly reviles God, as though something harmful to the church had slipped from him through carelessness" (III.21.4). That what God has said must be taught, we accept without reservation. Our disagreement is not with Calvin's nerve. It is with what he believes God has said, and with which God he believes has said it.
The Definition
The definition comes in III.21.5. Many say that God predestines because he foresees who will believe. Calvin grants God foreknowledge in the fullest sense, all things present to him without past or future, but he will not make predestination hang on it (III.21.5). Then he gives the definition that the whole of our fourth part must answer.
"We call predestination the eternal decree of God by which he determined with himself what he willed to become of each human being." And next: "For not all are created in the same condition; rather, eternal life is foreordained for some and eternal damnation for others. Therefore, as each has been created for one end or the other, so we say that he has been predestined either to life or to death" (III.21.5).
Readers of Calvin's first Book will recognise this God. He is the God of providence without remainder, who governs every event and uses the wicked as his instruments (I.16 to I.18). A God who determines whatever happens must determine how each life ends, and Calvin does not pretend otherwise. The definition is his theology arriving at its last question and answering it the way it answered every other. We do not think Calvin enjoys saying so. We think he says it because his God is one, and the one God who made the world and gave Israel the Law is also, for him, the one who saves.
One Nation Out of All
Where does Calvin first see this decree at work? Not in the Evangelion, and not first in Paul. He sees it in the election of Israel. The decree, he says, is shown not only in single persons but in the whole posterity of Abraham, and his first witness is the Song of Moses: when the Most High divided the nations, he set their bounds by the number of Israel's sons, for the Lord's portion is his people (III.21.5, from Deuteronomy 32:8 to 9). Then come Deuteronomy's sayings that the Lord chose Israel not because they were many but because he loved their fathers, and a run of psalms that celebrate the chosen nation and its land (III.21.5). Calvin draws the lesson: "in the person of Abraham, as in a dry stock, one people is specially chosen and the others rejected; but the cause does not appear," except that Moses ascribes it wholly to God's free love (III.21.5).
This is a fair reading of those books. Deuteronomy does say that Israel was not chosen for its size or virtue, and Calvin notes that Moses also calls them stiff-necked (III.21.5). When he adds that the prophets reminded the Jews of their election as a reproach (III.21.5), he is reporting rebukes spoken by Israel's prophets to their own people, in their God's name. We do not take them up against anyone.
Then Calvin adds what he calls a second step (III.21.6). Within Abraham's family God chose again. Of Ishmael, who at first stood level with Isaac, Calvin writes, "He is cut off; then Esau; at last a countless multitude and almost the whole of Israel" (III.21.6). Saul too was rejected, and Judah chosen over Ephraim (III.21.6). He explains why he marks the two steps apart, and his reason is one of the most candid sentences in this part of the Institutes: "Already in the election of the whole nation God showed that in his mere liberality he is bound by no laws but is free, so that an equal distribution of grace is by no means to be demanded of him; its very inequality proves that it is truly gratuitous" (III.21.6).
Then he goes further, to individual persons, without whom, he says, election is only half explained (III.21.7). God gave the outward covenant to many but the Spirit who keeps people in it only to some. "The outward invitation, without the inward efficacy of grace that would be strong enough to keep them, is a kind of middle state between the rejection of the human race and the election of the small number of the godly" (III.21.7). The whole people was called the Lord's inheritance, and Calvin says that "it was not for nothing that God had covenanted to be their Father and Redeemer," and the promise held because God kept a remnant (III.21.7).
So election, in Calvin's account, is a narrowing funnel: the nations passed by, one nation chosen, one son preferred to another, a remnant, a small number. Every step is drawn from Israel's history and Israel's books, and Calvin is open about it.
That is where our answer begins. Marcion's churches did not deny that Israel's God chose Israel. We accept Deuteronomy's witness about its own God: that he chose one people from among the nations, loved them for no reason they could name, rebuked them through his prophets, and kept a remnant. What we deny is that this God is the Father of whom the Son spoke. Our Lord did not come to divide the nations again by a better number. He said that no one knows the Father except the Son, "and anyone to whom the Son reveals him" (Evangelion 6:30 TT). The Father's choosing, in our Gospel, begins where the Creator's choosing of a nation left everyone else: among those who had never known him.
Jacob and Esau
Calvin's sharpest example comes from the second step. In III.21.6 he quotes Malachi: "Was not Esau Jacob's brother? Yet I loved Jacob, but Esau I hated" (III.21.6). In Malachi the saying rebukes Israel's ingratitude: they were preferred to Esau's descendants and still despised their God. Calvin grants that the prophet speaks of two peoples, the whole progeny of Jacob against the posterity of Esau (III.21.7). But he follows Paul, who in the church's Romans 9 sets the same words beside two unborn sons, and in III.22.4 he lays out that argument in full.
His opponents here say that God chose Jacob because he foresaw his faith and refused Esau because he foresaw his unbelief. Calvin answers from the church's Romans 9:11 to 13: the children were not yet born and had done neither good nor evil when it was said that the elder would serve the younger. His argument is acute. "If foreknowledge counted for anything in this distinction between the brothers, the mention of time would certainly be out of place" (III.22.4). Everything is present to God anyway; Paul names the time in order to exclude works, past or future, and so makes the change of birthright a witness to the election of one brother and the reprobation of the other (III.22.4).
The brothers had the same parents and lay in the same womb (III.22.5). "In them all things are equal, yet God's judgment concerning them is different. He takes the one and casts off the other" (III.22.5). He anticipates the reply that the birthright was only an earthly honour, and notes that some objectors do not spare Paul himself but "treat him as though, in citing these testimonies, he had twisted Scripture to a sense not its own" (III.22.6). Calvin answers that the earthly sign stood for a heavenly reality. Jacob's blessing, if it meant only this life, would be ridiculous, "since nothing came to him from it but manifold hardships, troubles, a sad exile, and many bitter sorrows and cares" (III.22.6). Therefore it must point beyond this world. "This too must be kept in mind: a pledge of the heavenly dwelling was annexed to the land of Canaan" (III.22.6). His conclusion follows. "Jacob, therefore, is chosen and Esau rejected, and by God's predestination Jacob is set apart from one from whom he differed in no merit" (III.22.6).
At the end of III.22 he returns to Esau to speak of reprobation directly. As Jacob was taken into favour before any good work, "so Esau, not yet defiled by any crime, is hated" (III.22.11). Paul could have answered the charge of injustice by saying that God repaid Esau's wickedness, which Calvin admits would have been the surest defence (III.22.11). He did not. He said instead that the reprobate are raised up for God's glory, and that God has mercy on whom he will and hardens whom he will (III.22.11). Calvin draws the inference without flinching. "Therefore, if we cannot give any reason why he grants mercy to his own except that it so pleases him, neither shall we have anything but his will to point to in the reprobation of others" (III.22.11).
Calvin is right about the argument of the church's Romans 9. If those verses are scripture, the foreknowledge reading does not survive them, and Calvin shows why better than his opponents ever answered. He is also right that a grace which waits on foreseen merit is no longer grace.
But we notice two things. The first is a tension in Calvin himself. In III.21.6, speaking of Israel's history, he wrote, "It was by their own fault and guilt, I admit, that Ishmael, Esau and the like fell from adoption," since they broke the covenant (III.21.6). In III.22.11 Esau is hated before any crime. Calvin would say both are true, the one of the visible covenant and the other of the hidden decree. We think the strain shows. Read as history, Israel's story gives him people who fell by their own fault; read as a cipher for eternal destinies, it gives him a child hated in the womb. The second reading needs the first to sound bearable, and the first is undone by the second.
The second is the cost of the Canaan argument. To make Jacob's blessing mean heaven, Calvin must say that a man who received from his God little but exile, sorrow and care was blessed because the blessing was really about another world. That amounts to conceding that the Creator's promises, taken at their word, did not deliver what they seemed to promise. We accept the concession. We do not accept the remedy, which is to read them as promises of the Father's kingdom.
The Chapter Our Romans Lacks
We come now to a fact that bears on the whole argument. The Pauline texts on which Calvin builds reprobation are not in our Paul.
Our Romans moves from the eighth chapter to a short ninth. Paul writes, "I speak the truth in Christ, I am not lying, my conscience bears witness in the Spirit," (Romans 9:1 TT) "that I have great sorrow and unceasing grief in my heart," (Romans 9:2 TT) "for I could wish to be cut off from Christ for the sake of my brothers, my kinsmen according to the flesh" (Romans 9:3 TT). Then our text goes on to what the church numbers as the tenth chapter: "For I bear witness that they have a zeal for God, but not according to knowledge" (Romans 10:1 TT), and "For Christ is the end of the Law for righteousness to everyone who believes" (Romans 10:3 TT). And then directly to the doxology: "Oh, the depth of the riches and of the wisdom of God, and his ways are unfathomable!" (Romans 11:1 TT).
What the church reads as Romans 9:4 to 33 is not there, and neither is Romans 11:1 to 32. Our Romans has no Jacob loved and Esau hated, no children unborn who had done neither good nor evil, no mercy on whom God will have mercy, no Pharaoh raised up, no hardening at God's pleasure, and no remnant chosen by grace. It has no potter and clay either; Calvin keeps that image for his next chapter (III.23.4), and we will meet it there. Calvin's opening proof in III.21.1 is Romans 11:5 to 6, and his central proofs in III.22.4 to III.22.6 and III.22.11 come from Romans 9; none of them is in our text. Ephesians 1:4, chosen in him before the foundation of the world, which Calvin quotes in III.22.1 and III.22.10 and expounds clause by clause in III.22.2 and III.22.3, is not in our Laodiceans. Where the church reads that we were chosen before the world and predestined to adoption, our text has the destining but not the choosing before the world: "He destined us beforehand for adoption as children through Jesus Christ to himself, according to his will of grace" (Laodiceans 1:3 TT). It names a destiny to adoption, and none to destruction. Calvin's other witnesses here are John, Acts, Peter's first letter, the letters to Timothy and Titus, and Israel's scriptures. Of his Pauline proofs in these two chapters, only two stand in our text: the thanksgiving in Colossians for being made fit to share the inheritance of the saints (III.22.1), and the question who has first given to God (III.22.3).
We do not want to make more of this than it will bear. A doctrine is not false because its proof texts are missing from a particular canon, and why our text differs from the church's here is a question for another book. We say something narrower. The Pauline passages in which Calvin finds a rejection decreed before birth take their material from Israel's history: Jacob and Esau, Moses on the mountain, Pharaoh, the remnant. In our Romans, Paul grieves for his kinsmen, bears witness to their zeal, says that Christ is the end of the Law, and then falls silent before a depth he does not explain. At the hardest point of his argument Calvin borrows Augustine's words: "Do you want to dispute with me? Marvel with me, and cry out, O the depth!" (III.22.10). We can exclaim it with him. But in our text the depth follows the end of the Law, not the hating of Esau.
What Our Paul Says of Choosing
It would be unfair to stop there, as though our Paul knew nothing of choice. He knows a great deal of it.
Paul tells the Thessalonians that he remembers them, "knowing, brothers and sisters beloved by God, his choice of you" (1 Thessalonians 1:4 TT). He asks, "Who will bring charge against God's chosen? God is the one who justifies" (Romans 8:23 TT). He says that "all things work together for good for those who love God, those called according to his purpose" (Romans 8:21 TT). In the church's Romans the next verses speak of those whom God foreknew and predestined, words Calvin hears through Bernard in III.22.10; in ours the next words are "If God is for us, who is against us?" (Romans 8:22 TT). He tells the Laodiceans, "We who first hoped in Christ have been destined and appointed to live for the praise of glory" (Laodiceans 1:6 TT). Of himself he says that God "set me apart from birth and called me through his grace" (Galatians 1:14 TT). And when Calvin explains Paul's question, saying that Paul means "God's goodness so goes before human beings that it finds nothing in them, past or future, by which it might be won over to them" (III.22.3), he is glossing a verse our Romans keeps: "Or who has first given to him that it should be repaid to him again?" (Romans 11:3 TT). On that point Calvin and we stand together. No one earns the Father's choice.
The Evangelion says the same. Our Lord rejoiced in the Spirit and said, "I thank you and praise you, Lord of heaven, because what was hidden from the wise and educated you have revealed to the simple" (Evangelion 6:29 TT), and added, "Yes, Father, because this was pleasing to you" (Evangelion 6:29 TT). He told his disciples, "Don't be afraid, little flock, because the Father is pleased to give you the kingdom" (Evangelion 8:26 TT). Calvin, through Bernard, quotes that very saying as a word to the elect (III.22.10). We do not dispute it. The Father chooses, and his good pleasure is the ground of the gift.
So the question between Calvin and us is not whether God chooses. It is whom he chooses, out of what, and what becomes of the rest. On each point our Paul answers differently from Calvin's Paul.
Whom does he choose? "Look at your calling, brothers and sisters: not many were wise by flesh, not many mighty, not many noble" (1 Corinthians 1:26 TT). "But God chose the foolish things of the world to shame the wise, and God chose the weak things to shame the strong," (1 Corinthians 1:27 TT) "and God chose the least, the low-born, and the despised, the nothings, to nullify the things that are," (1 Corinthians 1:28 TT) "so that no one may boast" (1 Corinthians 1:29 TT). This choice has a direction. Calvin's funnel ran from the nations to one nation to a remnant; this runs from the wise and strong to the nothings of the world.
Out of what does he choose them? The Father "rescued us from the realm of darkness and transferred us into the kingdom of his beloved Son" (Colossians 1:13 TT). Those he adopts were before "enslaved to those who are gods by nature" (Galatians 4:8 TT); now they have come "to know God, or rather to be known by God" (Galatians 4:9 TT). The chosen are taken out of a dominion that was not the Father's.
And what of the rest? Here our text is sparing, and we will be too. Paul speaks of "those who are perishing" (1 Corinthians 1:18 TT). He says that the god of this aeon "has blinded the minds of the untrusting" (2 Corinthians 4:1 TT); the blinding is the work of that god, not of the Father. In the second letter to the Thessalonians he speaks of "an impulse of error" (2 Thessalonians 2:8 TT), the nearest our text comes to Calvin's hardening. But the reason is given in the verse before: those who perish "did not receive the love of the truth so as to be rescued" (2 Thessalonians 2:7 TT). There is no child hated in the womb in our Paul. There is no rejection decreed before birth, and no one raised up to be destroyed for a display of glory.
Aliens Made His Own
The most remarkable section of these two chapters is III.22.7, where Calvin lets Christ, the supreme Judge, decide the case. His texts are from John, which we do not read, and from them he draws two sentences we must set down in full (III.22.7).
The elect, he says, belonged to the Father before they were given to the Son. Were they his by nature? "On the contrary, those who were strangers he makes his own by drawing them" (III.22.7). That is very close to our own confession. The Father of the Evangelion has no prior claim on us as maker; he takes for his own those who were not his. Adolf von Harnack called his book on Marcion The Gospel of the Alien God (1921). Calvin's word for the elect is alieni, strangers to God; we would say the Father was a stranger to us, as we to him. Both say that the bond is made, not found in creation: Calvin says by drawing, we say by rescue.
The second sentence follows. "Hence it comes about that the whole world does not belong to its Creator, except in so far as grace snatches not many from the curse, from the wrath of God and from eternal death, who would otherwise have perished, while it leaves the world in the destruction for which it is destined" (III.22.7).
It is one of the bleakest sentences Calvin wrote, and he uses the word Creator himself. He means the curse, wrath and death of the Creator, and the Creator's grace snatching not many from them; and he says flatly that the whole world does not belong to its Creator, except for those few. Read with Marcion's eyes, the sentence describes the case almost exactly, with the ownership turned around. The world that lies under the curse and wrath does belong to its Creator; that is why it lies under them. The grace that snatches a few out of it is not his. It comes from the Father, who did not make the world, and whose Son "came to rescue what was lost" (Evangelion 12:19 TT). The sentence has the right shape and the wrong number of Gods.
The last words of III.22.7 say where Calvin's God finds the cause of it all. "The sum is this: God by free adoption creates those whom he wills to have as children, and the intrinsic cause of this lies in himself, because he is content with his own secret good pleasure" (III.22.7).
The Objections He Answers
Calvin builds his twenty-second chapter as a reply to objectors, and states them fairly. The first hold that God elects according to foreseen merit. Calvin admits that the view has had great supporters in every age (III.22.1). In III.22.8 he names Ambrose, Origen and Jerome as holding "that God dispenses his grace among men according as he has foreseen that each will use it well," and adds that Augustine held it for a time before he retracted it (III.22.8). Against them he sets the later Augustine and the logic of the text he reads as Ephesians 1: we were chosen that we might be holy, so "If he chose us that we might be holy, he did not choose us because he foresaw that we would be such" (III.22.3). Augustine's maxim closes the matter for him: "God's grace does not find those who are to be chosen, but makes them" (III.22.8). Thomas Aquinas's middle way he dismisses as a subtlety (III.22.9).
On this objection Calvin wins. A choice made on foreseen merit is a reward, and a reward is not grace. Our Paul says the same: God chose the nothings "so that no one may boast" (1 Corinthians 1:29 TT).
The second objectors complain that God is unfair to elect some and pass by others. Calvin's first answer is an argument from creation. Let them say "why human beings are more than oxen or asses: why, when it was in God's hand to fashion them as dogs, he formed them in his own image" (III.22.1). His second answer is Christ himself, in whom, with Augustine, he sees a mirror of free election, since the man born of David's line did nothing to deserve to be the Son (III.22.1).
The first answer shows which God Calvin is defending. It is a maker's answer. The one who could have made us dogs owes us nothing, as the potter owes the clay nothing. It is not how our Lord described the Father. The Father of the Evangelion does not stand on his rights over what he made, because he did not make it; he comes as a stranger and gives what he owes no one. That is why the Son can say, "Be compassionate, just as your Father has shown you compassion" (Evangelion 3:36 TT), and why he can say of him that "he is kind even to the ungrateful and the wicked" (Evangelion 3:35 TT).
The third objection is the hardest, and Calvin gives it its full weight. "Some object that God would be contrary to himself if he invited all universally to himself but admitted only a few chosen ones" (III.22.10). Some moderate men, he says, take this line to avoid hard questions, and he refuses their peace. "The intention is praiseworthy, but the plan is by no means to be approved, because evasion is never excusable" (III.22.10). His answer, from Amos, is that the God who sends rain on one city and drought on another, and threatens a famine of the word, never bound himself to call all equally (III.22.10). He asks the question himself. "How, then, will it be consistent for God to call to himself those whom he knows will not come?" (III.22.10). He answers with Augustine's cry of wonder, and with a sentence that leaves no doubt about his meaning. "If he willed all to be saved, he would set his Son over them as their guardian and would graft them all into his body by the sacred bond of faith" (III.22.10).
We admire the refusal to evade. Calvin will not say that God wills all to be saved and then explain why he does not save them. He says that God does not will it, and that faith is "a singular pledge of fatherly love, laid up for the children whom he has adopted" (III.22.10). Fatherly love, for Calvin, is real, and it is reserved.
Our Gospel does not reserve it. The Son asks which of his hearers, having lost one sheep of a hundred, would not "go looking for the lost one until you find it" (Evangelion 10:1 TT), and says that "there is more joy in heaven over one sinner who repents than over ninety-nine righteous people who have no need to repent!" (Evangelion 10:3 TT). Calvin's God loves the sons and leaves the world; our Lord's Father goes out after the one who strayed. The Evangelion does not answer every question Calvin raises about why some believe. It tells us which way the Father's love runs, and it runs outward toward the lost, not inward toward a number fixed before the world.
A Decree Without Softening
Calvin ends III.22 where he began III.21, with a decree that has no cause outside God's will. He has not once pretended that it is gentler than it is. "What Scripture clearly shows, then, we affirm: that God by his eternal and unchangeable counsel determined once for all whom he willed one day to take up into salvation, and whom, on the other hand, he willed to devote to destruction" (III.21.7). The rejected, he says, are shut out "by his just and blameless, but incomprehensible, judgment" (III.21.7). He calls the judgment just, and he confesses that he cannot comprehend it.
We respect that confession. Calvin could have stopped at election and left reprobation in shadow, as many have. He could have said that God merely permits the lost to go their way. He did not, and in his next chapter he will call the decree dreadful in so many words (III.23.7). A theologian who tells you the worst thing he believes, in clear sentences, is a better partner in argument than one who hides it, and we are in Calvin's debt for it.
But the God whose decree he describes is the God of his first Book: the maker who owes nothing to what he makes, who divided the nations and kept one, who loved Jacob and hated Esau. Calvin learned this God's way of choosing from Israel's books and describes it faithfully. Then he finds in him the Father of our Lord. The Son did not describe the Father that way. In our Gospel the Father hides his things from the wise and shows them to the simple; he is pleased to give the little flock the kingdom; he is kind to the ungrateful and the wicked; and he is known only through the Son, by those to whom the Son reveals him (Evangelion 6:30 TT). In our Paul he chooses the despised and the nothings of the world, rescues them from the realm of darkness, and destines them for adoption "according to his will of grace" (Laodiceans 1:3 TT).
Calvin was right that grace is free and that no one earns it. He was right that a doctrine taught in scripture should not be hidden. He was wrong, we believe, about whose grace it is. The decree that sorts the unborn into two ends belongs to the God who made them. The Father of the Evangelion did not write that decree. He sent his Son into the world it governs, a stranger, to rescue what was lost.
