Is The God Of The Old Testament Really Good? #heresy #theology #biblicaltruth #biblehistory
Published May 7, 2026
Marcion of Sinope didn't call the Creator evil. He called him just — and said that was the whole problem.
This short walks through the central contradiction the orthodox Church has spent two millennia trying to harmonize away: the God who floods the earth, kills Egypt's firstborn, and commands total destruction in Deuteronomy is a god of strict justice. You break the Law, you pay. Every sin has a price. That system is coherent — but it is not rescue.
Then Jesus speaks. Love your enemies. Lend expecting nothing back. Be merciful as your Father is merciful. This is not the same voice. It is the opposite voice. Justice gives you what you earned. The Father gives you what you never could have earned.
The orthodox solution — "progressive revelation," the same God in different moods — requires theological gymnastics Marcion rejected. The simpler reading, attested by Tertullian's own polemics and preserved in the manuscript tradition, is that the Father invaded the Creator's territory. He did not evolve out of him.
By works of law, no flesh will be declared righteous. The Law was a cage. Christ broke it open.
The Creator is just. The Father is good. Marcion knew the difference.
Read the Evangelion yourself at TrueTestament.org — the Bible before Rome rewrote it.
Watch on YouTube