All videos

    Against the Four Gospels - The case for the Evangelion as the Oldest Gospel - PT 1

    Published April 7, 2026

    For nearly two thousand years the Church has claimed that the four canonical gospels were written by eyewitnesses in the first century — Matthew the tax collector, Mark the companion of Peter, Luke the physician, and John the beloved disciple. But the historical evidence tells a very different story. The four canonical gospels are anonymous texts. Their authors never identify themselves within the documents. The names Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John were assigned later in the second century by church leaders attempting to attach apostolic authority to writings whose origins were unknown. The earliest manuscript evidence appears well into the second century, and the first generation of Christian writers shows a striking silence about the canonical gospels. Clement, Ignatius, and Barnabas do not clearly quote them. Even Justin Martyr in the mid-second century refers only to anonymous “Memoirs of the Apostles.” At the same time, the Apostle Paul repeatedly refers to “my gospel.” He claims it came not from human teachers but by direct revelation of Jesus Christ, and he pronounces an anathema on anyone who preaches a different gospel. This raises a critical question: If Paul possessed a specific gospel — one he guarded and defended — what written gospel corresponds to it? The Marcionite tradition preserves the answer: the Evangelion, the gospel Marcion of Sinope brought to Rome in 144 AD. Increasingly, modern scholarship is recognizing that this text may stand behind the canonical gospels themselves. Coming Next in the Series Part 2 — The Contradictions They Cannot Explain The irreconcilable conflicts between Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John: the birth narratives, crucifixion timelines, resurrection accounts, and competing theologies of Jesus. Part 3 — The Oldest Gospel The scholarly case for Marcionite priority — how the Evangelion may stand behind the canonical gospels and solve the synoptic problem. Part 4 — The Death of Q & Against Matthew Why the hypothetical Q source collapses once the Evangelion is considered, and how Matthew reshapes the gospel into a Judaizing program. Part 5 — Against Mark, Luke & John How each canonical gospel rewrites the Evangelion — Mark’s truncation, Luke’s domestication, and John’s philosophical overlay. For more information, check out the True Testament and Subscribe! https://truetestament.org #Evangelion #Marcion #ChurchHistory #BiblicalScholarship #EarlyChristianity #theology
    Watch on YouTube