Against the Four Gospels - The Contradictions They Cannot Explain - Part 2
Published April 8, 2026
Part 2 — The Contradictions They Cannot Explain
In our first installment, we examined the problem of Gospel authorship. The four canonical gospels are anonymous texts whose traditional names were assigned later in the second century.
But authorship is only the beginning of the problem. When the gospels themselves are compared, they frequently contradict one another. The differences begin with the birth narratives. Matthew and Luke both describe the birth of Jesus, yet their timelines cannot be reconciled. Matthew places the story during the reign of Herod the Great and includes the flight into Egypt. Luke places the birth during the census of Quirinius and describes the family returning directly to Nazareth. Mark and John contain no birth narrative at all.
The contradictions continue in the crucifixion accounts. The gospels disagree on the timing of the crucifixion in relation to Passover and preserve different final words spoken by Jesus on the cross.
The resurrection narratives contain similar conflicts — different numbers of women at the tomb, different angelic figures, and different locations for the appearances of Jesus.
Taken together, the four canonical gospels do not form a single unified narrative.
They preserve competing traditions about Jesus.
This raises a deeper question:
If the canonical gospels conflict so dramatically, what earlier gospel tradition might stand behind them?
Coming Next in the Series
Part 3 — The Oldest Gospel
The scholarly case for Marcionite priority and the Evangelion.
Part 4 — The Death of Q & Against Matthew
Why the hypothetical Q source collapses once the Evangelion is considered.
Part 5 — Against Mark, Luke & John
How each canonical gospel rewrites earlier traditions.
https://truetestament.org
#Evangelion
#Marcion
#ChurchHistory
#BiblicalScholarship
#EarlyChristianity
#Theology
Watch on YouTube