Chapter 12 of 56

    The Unknown God

    24 min read

    Thesis

    Part 4 turns from scripture to the God our scripture reveals. Its first chapter states the attribute the others assume.

    The Father was not known through Moses, the prophets or creation, and he was first revealed by the Son. He is new in the sense the Marcionites themselves gave the word: new to knowledge, not new in being. Tertullian reported their meaning correctly: “I know indeed in what sense they vaunt a new God, namely, by means of knowledge” (Marc. 1.9.1). The Latin is agnitione. Our study of Tertullian drew the conclusion: “The Marcionites did not say that their God had begun. They said that he had begun to be known.”

    This chapter builds on Chapter 2, which read the central texts for the doctrine of revelation, and it does not repeat that exegesis. Chapter 2 asked how the Father is made known. This chapter asks what it means to call him unknown, to whom he was unknown, and what that tells us about who he is. The unknownness of the Father is not an accident of history or a defect in human sight. It belongs to the doctrine of God. The Father does not belong to this aeon, and so nothing in this aeon could show him.

    The probable rule applies with force here, because several verses often cited for this doctrine are probable in our edition: 1 Corinthians 2:9–15 TT (“eye has not seen,” “no one knows the thoughts of God,” “the natural person cannot know them”), Colossians 1:24 TT (“the mystery hidden from aeons and generations”), and Laodiceans 3:3–4 TT (“by revelation the mystery was made known to me”). Some of our earlier studies cite them. This chapter does not.

    What “Unknown” Means

    Christian theology has said many times that God is unknown. It has meant different things by it. Four senses must be kept apart.

    1. Unacknowledged. God is known but not honored, as a master is known by a servant who disobeys him. This is the prophets’ complaint: the ox knows its owner, but Israel does not know. Tertullian read our Lord’s saying this way. It is, he says, “a confirmation of the prophetic voice reproaching human ignorance toward God, which has continued right up to the Son” (Marc. 4.25.11).

    2. Obscured. God was shown in his works but our sin has darkened the sight. Calvin argued this with care: “we cannot gather from the sight of the world that he is a Father,” because since the fall the world shows “the curse of God” (Institutes II.6.1). For Calvin the Father was hidden by our fault and is known again when we return.

    3. Partly known. God was known in shadow and promise, and is known fully in Christ. Many readers take “No one knows the Father except the Son” to mean “no one knows him fully.” Our study of other churches’ readings noted the difficulty: “The word ‘fully’ is not in the verse.”

    4. Unrevealed. God was not known at all in this aeon, because he had not shown himself in it, and he is known now because the Son has made him known.

    Our doctrine is the fourth. It is not the first, because the Father had not been known and then disobeyed; he had not been known. It is not the second, because the Father was never shown in the works of this world and then hidden by sin; the works of this world are the Creator’s. It is not the third, because the prophets did not see him in shadow; “the prophets did not see what you see” (Evangelion 6:32 TT).

    Two misunderstandings must be set aside. The Father is not unknowable. He is known now, by the Son’s revealing, and the assemblies call on him by name. And he is not new in being. Tertullian mocked the Marcionites for putting forward “a new god, as if we are ashamed of the old God” (Marc. 1.8.1), but he also reported, correctly, that they meant new “by means of knowledge” (1.9.1). Our study put the distinction in four words: “Hidden is not the same as new.”

    Why was he unknown? Not because he was shy and not because we were stupid. Our study of the word gave the reason: “He is unknown not because He is shy, and not because we are stupid, but because He does not belong to this system.” The Father is not the maker of this world, and he does not rule this aeon. Nothing in it bears his signature. A God who stands outside the world cannot be found by searching inside it. He can only come to it, or send. That is the claim of the next two sections.

    Exegesis: Unknown to Whom

    Our scripture does not say only that “people” did not know the Father. It names, one after another, every level of this aeon, from the nations to the one who made it, and says the same of each.

    The prophets

    “For I tell you, the prophets did not see what you see” (Evangelion 6:32 TT). The church’s Luke says that “many prophets and kings desired to see what you see, and did not see it.” Ours has no desire and no kings. The prophets simply did not see. The reading comes from Tertullian (Marc. 4.25.12); Harnack called it “a tendentious abridgment,” and Zahn printed the short form. The verse before it blesses the disciples: “Blessed are the eyes that see what you see” (Evangelion 6:31 TT). Our study of Tertullian put the contrast exactly: “The disciples are not blessed for seeing what the prophets foretold. They are blessed for seeing what the prophets never saw.” The boundary is dated in the Evangelion itself: “The Law and the Prophets were in effect until John” (Evangelion 10:20 TT).

    Israel

    Of Israel Paul writes, “For I bear witness that they have a zeal for God, but not according to knowledge” (Romans 10:1 TT), and then, in our text, “For being ignorant of God and seeking to establish their own righteousness, they did not submit to the righteousness of God” (Romans 10:2 TT): ἀγνοοῦντες γὰρ ⸢τὸν Θεόν⸣. The church’s text says they were ignorant “of the righteousness of God.” Ours, rendered back from Tertullian’s Deum ignorantes (Marc. 5.14.6), says they were ignorant of God. We note the reading and do not lean on it alone, because the sentence does not tell us by itself which God their zeal was for. Chapter 3’s referent rule leaves it unresolved. What the verse adds is this: in our text, the people with the Law and the prophets are said not to know God.

    The nations

    Of the Galatians before the message Paul writes, “Formerly, when you did not know God, you were enslaved to those who are gods by nature” (Galatians 4:8 TT). The words the witnesses quote are the last: τοῖς φύσει οὖσιν θεοῖς, “those who are gods by nature,” which Tertullian discusses (Marc. 5.4.5). The phrase “when you did not know God” is Nestle’s wording in an attested verse, so we take its sense. The nations were not without gods. They served real powers, “gods by nature,” the powers of this world. What they lacked was knowledge of God.

    The world and its wisdom

    “For since in the wisdom of God the world did not know the Lord through its wisdom, it pleased God through the foolishness of the message to rescue those who believe” (1 Corinthians 1:21 TT): οὐκ ἔγνω ὁ κόσμος διὰ τῆς σοφίας τὸν ⸢Κύριον⸣. The world had wisdom, and its wisdom did not reach him. Our text’s “the Lord,” where the church’s has “God,” is retroverted from Tertullian and found in no other witness. Either way the sentence answers the old demand that God be proved from his works. The world searched with its wisdom and did not find him. He was made known by proclamation.

    The rulers of this aeon

    “None of the rulers of this aeon understood it; for if they had, they would never have staked the Lord of glory” (1 Corinthians 2:8 TT): ἣν οὐδεὶς τῶν ἀρχόντων τοῦ αἰῶνος τούτου ἔγνωκεν. The powers that govern this aeon did not know the wisdom of God, and their ignorance is part of the story of the stake. Chapter 21 returns to them.

    The powers in the heavenly places

    The heavenly powers learn of the Father only now: “so that the manifold wisdom of God might be made known through the assembly to the rulers and the authorities in the heavenly places” (Laodiceans 3:7 TT), ἵνα γνωρισθῇ ταῖς ἀρχαῖς καὶ ταῖς ἐξουσίαις ἐν τοῖς ἐπουρανίοις. The verb is passive and the means is the assembly. The powers above are taught by the rescued below.

    The God who created all things

    The highest level is the Creator himself. The mystery was “hidden from the aeons from the God who created all things” (Laodiceans 3:6 TT), the reading Tertullian reports as Marcion’s (Marc. 5.18.1). Chapter 2 read the verse; here it completes the ladder. From the nations to their gods, from the world’s wisdom to the rulers of this aeon and the powers in the heavens, and finally to the maker of all things, our scripture says the same thing: the Father was not known.

    This is why the unknownness of the Father is a doctrine about God and not about human failure. If only sinners had not known him, the cure would be repentance. If only the nations had not known him, the cure would be Israel’s teaching. But the prophets did not see him, the rulers did not know him, and his mystery was hidden from the Creator. The only cure is the Son.

    Exegesis: How He Is Known

    Through the Son alone

    The central sentence is the one Chapter 2 read in full. “Everything has been entrusted to me by the Father. No one knows the Father except the Son, and no one knows the Son except the Father, and anyone to whom the Son reveals him” (Evangelion 6:30 TT): οὐδεὶς γινώσκει τίς ἐστιν ὁ Πατὴρ εἰ μὴ ὁ Υἱός. For the doctrine of God two features matter. The Father comes first in our text, where the church’s Luke puts the Son first; Tertullian and the Marcionite Megethius both give that order, and Ritschl observed that it puts the Father’s unknownness “in the foreground.” And the knowing passes only one way: from the Son to “anyone to whom the Son reveals him.” There is no second road, through nature, through the Law or through the prophets, by which the same knowledge arrives.

    The verse has a companion in the prayer before it, where the Lord addresses the Father as “Lord of heaven” (Evangelion 6:29 TT). Epiphanius says plainly that Marcion’s text “did not have ‘and of the earth’” (Panarion 42, Scholion 22). The Father is Lord of the heaven from which the Son came. He is not named Lord of the earth the Creator made.

    Through the proclamation

    The Son’s revealing reaches the world as a message. “It pleased God through the foolishness of the message to rescue those who believe” (1 Corinthians 1:21 TT). “For we do not proclaim ourselves but Christ Jesus the Lord” (2 Corinthians 4:2 TT). Tertullian himself granted the route. A God without natural works, he said, “ought to have worked out a revelation of himself by proclamations” (Marc. 1.18.2). That is what the Marcionites said he did.

    The next verse in 2 Corinthians names what the proclamation gives. God “has shone in our hearts to give the light of the recognition of his glory in the face of Christ” (2 Corinthians 4:3 TT): πρὸς φωτισμὸν τῆς γνώσεως τῆς δόξης αὐτοῦ ἐν προσώπῳ Χριστοῦ. The word is γνῶσις, and Tertullian’s Latin for it is agnitio (Marc. 5.11.11), the same word he used for the Marcionite claim that their God was new “by recognition.” The recognition is located “in the face of Christ.” The verse also opens with the God “who said, ‘Light shall shine out of darkness,’” which echoes Genesis, and the Hard Cases section takes that up.

    Through the Spirit’s cry

    The Father is known not only as a fact but as a Father. “But when the time was fulfilled, God sent forth his Son” (Galatians 4:4 TT), and “Because you are God’s children, he has sent his Spirit into our hearts, crying, ‘Abba, Father’” (Galatians 4:6 TT): κρᾶζον Ἀββᾶ ὁ Πατήρ. The first sending happens at a fixed time. The second takes place in the heart, and its sign is a cry. The knowledge of the Father that the Son brings is the knowledge a child has of a parent, and it is given, not deduced. Chapter 29 returns to the cry.

    The image of the invisible God

    Colossians gives the doctrine its most compact form: “He is the image of the invisible God” (Colossians 1:15 TT), εἰκὼν τοῦ Θεοῦ τοῦ ἀοράτου, words the witnesses quote. The Father is ἀόρατος, not seen. The Son is his image. To see the Son is the only way the invisible Father is seen.

    Knowing is not finished

    The assemblies did not reach full knowledge at once. Paul tells the Corinthians, “Sober up rightly and do not sin, for some have no knowledge of God; I say this to your shame” (1 Corinthians 15:26 TT): ἀγνωσίαν γὰρ Θεοῦ τινες ἔχουσιν, the one place our edition uses the noun “ignorance of God.” It is said inside the assembly. The Father who was unknown to the world is not automatically known to everyone who hears his name. He is known as the Son reveals him, and that revealing is the work of a life.

    The Names

    The doctrine has gathered several names, and they do not all do the same work.

    • The Father. This is the Son’s name for him, and it is the name our scripture uses most. “Only one is good: the Father” (Evangelion 12:2 TT). Every other name is a description; this one is an address.

    • The Unknown God. The name says what the world could not do. Our study of the word gave its proper use: “‘Unknown God’ is our liturgy.” It is said in worship, as a confession of what the Father’s coming overcame, not as a complaint about him. The same study adds: “Unknown is not an insult against the Father. It is a confession against the world.”

    • The Stranger. The name says where he comes from. He is not from this aeon and is no part of its household. Our study placed it beside the other: “‘Stranger God’ is our polemic.” It is used in argument, to mark the difference between the Father and the God of this world.

    • The alien God. Harnack’s title, Das Evangelium vom fremden Gott, gave the doctrine its modern name. The German fremd means foreign, belonging somewhere else. In English “alien” can sound hostile or monstrous, which Harnack did not mean. We use “stranger” for the same idea.

    • The Lord of heaven. The Son’s address in the prayer of Evangelion 6:29 TT, without “and of the earth.”

    One name we do not use as our own. The church’s book of Acts has Paul at Athens point to an altar inscribed “to an unknown god” and identify that god with the maker of the world. That is not our scripture, and it says the opposite of what our scripture says. In Acts the unknown god is the Creator whom the Athenians worshipped without knowing his name. In our scripture the unknown God is the Father whom no one knew because he was not the Creator. Eduard Norden’s study of the theme (Agnostos Theos, 1913) traced how widely the phrase “unknown god” ran in the ancient world. The phrase is common. The doctrine of our scripture is not.

    We also distinguish our doctrine from the “alien God” of the Gnostic systems as Hans Jonas described them (The Gnostic Religion, 1958). Those systems placed the unknown God at the top of a chain of emanations and made knowledge itself the means of rescue. Our scripture has no chain of emanations, and it rescues by the Son’s death and raising, not by knowledge alone. The Father is unknown until the Son reveals him. He is not reached by learning a secret.

    Hard Cases

    “Knows,” not “knew”

    Our text prints γινώσκει, “knows,” following Tertullian’s nemo scit (Marc. 4.25.10). The past tense, ἔγνω, “no one knew the Father except the Son,” would state the past ignorance outright, and it is reported among the saying’s early readers: Irenaeus says the heretics wrote “No one has known the Father” (Against Heresies 4.6.1), Tertullian once quotes the saying that way himself (Marc. 2.27.4), and Justin has the past tense in one work (1 Apology 63.3) and the present in another (Dialogue 100.1). The past tense was not a Marcionite peculiarity. Ritschl thought the aorist the better reading for Marcion, but Zahn judged that whether Marcion wrote “knows” or “knew” “cannot be determined with complete certainty.” We therefore argue from the present tense our edition prints. An objector says the present is timeless and only claims that the Son’s knowledge is unique. The answer is the next verse. Whatever the tense of 6:30, “the prophets did not see what you see” (Evangelion 6:32 TT) is a statement about the past, and it names the people who should have known if anyone did.

    “Ignorance” as the Creator’s own complaint

    Tertullian’s strongest reply was that the saying confirms the prophets. The Creator’s prophets themselves complained that Israel did not know him, so “no one knows the Father” repeats the Creator’s charge against his people (Marc. 4.25.11). Our Romans 10:1–2 TT can be read the same way, of a people zealous for God and yet ignorant of him.

    The reply depends on reading “unknown” in the first of the four senses: known but unacknowledged. Evangelion 6:32 TT does not allow it. The prophets did not complain that others failed to see; they themselves “did not see.” And the saying does not say that no one obeyed the Father except the Son. It says no one knew who he is. As our study of Tertullian put it: “We only ask Tertullian to let the saying mean what it says, that the Father was unknown, and not only unseen.”

    Whom does the Son reveal?

    Zahn noted that in Marcion’s order the clause just before “and anyone to whom the Son reveals him” is “no one knows the Son except the Father,” so the nearest object of “reveal” could be the Son himself. The grammar allows it. But the saying’s first clause is about the Father, the verse is introduced by the Father’s handing over of “everything,” and the prayer before it praises the Father for revealing what was hidden (Evangelion 6:29 TT). On any reading, knowledge of the Father depends on the Son. If the Son reveals himself, he reveals the one who alone knows him.

    “Without God in the world”

    Laodiceans says the nations “were in that time apart from Christ, alienated from the commonwealth of Israel, strangers to the covenants of the promise, having no hope and without God in the world” (Laodiceans 2:12 TT). Every word is quoted wording. Tertullian argued from it that Israel had God and the covenants were his (Marc. 5.17.12–14). The verse does place Israel’s commonwealth and covenants on one side and the nations, “without God,” on the other.

    What it does not say is that Israel knew the Father. It describes the map of this aeon as the nations stood on it: outside Israel’s covenants, without hope, without God. Our Galatians tells us whose covenants those were: “two revelations: one from Mount Sinai, for the synagogue of the Jews according to the Law, bearing children for slavery” (Galatians 4:16 TT). And the same chapter of Laodiceans goes on to the Law of commandments abolished (Laodiceans 2:15 TT). The nations lacked God in the world. Israel had the Creator’s covenants. Neither had the Father until the Son came to both.

    Vengeance on those who do not know God

    2 Thessalonians speaks of the Lord “coming to bring vengeance on those who do not know God and on those who do not obey the Evangelion” (2 Thessalonians 1:4a TT). If the Father was unknown, how can anyone be punished for not knowing him? We do not explain the verse away. Two things limit it. The two phrases are joined, so the ignorance in view is that of people to whom the Evangelion has come and who refuse it, not that of the prophets before the Son. And the verse belongs to the hardest passage in our scripture on judgment, which Chapter 6 set aside for Part 14 and which Chapter 18 meets first.

    “Light shall shine out of darkness”

    The God who shone in our hearts is the God “who said, ‘Light shall shine out of darkness’” (2 Corinthians 4:3 TT), and the words echo Genesis. Tertullian and Epiphanius both claimed the verse for the Creator. Hilgenfeld thought Marcion took the light to be spiritual, not the light of the first day. The verse comes directly after the god of this aeon who “has blinded the minds of the untrusting” (2 Corinthians 4:1 TT), and the contrast in the passage is between that blinding and this shining. Chapter 2 read the verse, and Chapter 16 takes it up with the god of this aeon. We record here that it is the strongest single objection to our reading of 2 Corinthians 4.

    The prophet’s question

    “For who has known the mind of the Lord, or who has been his counselor?” (Romans 11:2 TT) is Isaiah’s question, and 1 Corinthians 2:16 TT quotes it too. Tertullian took it for the Creator’s unsearchable judgments (Marc. 2.2.4), and he could argue that a God can be known and unsearchable at once. Under the rules of Chapter 7 a quotation is a witness, and this one testifies to what the world cannot reach. It does not tell us whose mind the prophet meant.

    Why so late?

    Tertullian’s sharpest question was why the better God appeared “later, and not from the very beginning of things” (Marc. 1.17.4), a god “from Tiberius” (1.22.10), and whether leaving people without the means to believe was not “malice” (1.12.3). “New by recognition” answers the charge that the Father began to exist. It does not answer the charge of delay.

    We answer as far as our scripture does and no further. The Son was sent “when the time was fulfilled” (Galatians 4:4 TT), at the Father’s choosing and not at the world’s. The charge of malice assumes that the Father owed this world a revelation from the start, as its maker would. He was not its maker. That he came at all to a world that was not his is the theme of Chapters 14 and 23. Why he came then and not before, our scripture does not say, and we do not invent an answer.

    Ancient Witness

    Irenaeus

    The clearest ancient statement of this chapter’s thesis comes from an opponent. Irenaeus writes of those “who wish to be more expert than the apostles” that they “write it thus: No one has known the Father except the Son, nor the Son except the Father, and he to whom the Son has willed to reveal him; and they interpret it as if the true God had been known by no one before the coming of the Lord, and they say that the God who was announced by the prophets is not the Father of Christ” (Against Heresies 4.6.1). Zahn thought Irenaeus may have known Marcion’s order of the clauses and had it in view. The report is hostile, but it describes the doctrine exactly: the Father known by no one before the Lord came, and not the God the prophets announced.

    Tertullian

    Tertullian gives both the Marcionite claim and the strongest case against it. The claim: a God whom “a certain Jesus Christ, and he himself new, among old names, revealed him, and no other before this” (Marc. 1.8.1), new “by means of knowledge” (1.9.1). The case against: “God will never lie hidden; God will never be lacking. He will always be understood, always heard, even seen, in whatever way He wills. God has witnesses: all this that we are and in which we are” (1.10.4). The Creator “was known from the very beginning, because he was never hidden, because he always shone forth, even before Romulus himself, let alone before Tiberius” (2.2.1). Our study of Tertullian answered in one line: “The God who was never hidden cannot be the God whom no one knew except the Son.” And it drew the conclusion: “Tertullian’s best argument for the Creator is that everyone always knew him. That is the best argument we have that he is not the God the Son came to reveal.”

    On the saying itself he concedes what matters. He reports the Marcionite conclusion, “And so, Christ proclaimed an unknown God” (4.25.10). He grants that “not even the prophets had seen what was being seen under Christ” (4.25.12). And he argues that the mention of the prophets proves Christ’s continuity with them: “For if Christ were not mine, neither would He have placed a mention of the prophets in this passage” (4.25.13). In our text the prophets are mentioned in order to say that they did not see.

    Epiphanius and the Dialogue

    Epiphanius reports that Marcion’s text of Luke 10:21 “did not have ‘and of the earth’” (Panarion 42, Scholion 22). The Marcionite Megethius in the Dialogue gives Luke 10:22 with the Father first, within one of his antitheses (1.23).

    Calvin

    Calvin is the theologian who came closest. “We cannot gather from the sight of the world that he is a Father” (Institutes II.6.1). He explained it by the fall and by the curse that now lies on creation. Our study of Calvin agreed with the fact and declined the explanation: the Father is not obscured by our sin but was never shown by the world at all.

    Scholarly Conversation

    Harnack named the doctrine in his title, The Gospel of the Alien God (Marcion: Das Evangelium vom fremden Gott, 1921), and argued that the Father’s strangeness was the center of Marcion’s faith: a God who owed this world nothing and came to it anyway. He also judged several of the readings in Luke 10:21–24 to be Marcion’s own “tendentious” changes. We print the readings the witnesses give and state his judgment.

    Albrecht Ritschl (Das Evangelium Marcions und das kanonische Evangelium des Lucas, 1846) argued that the Marcionite order and the aorist of Luke 10:22 were older than the church’s, and that the order puts “God’s being unknown hitherto” in the foreground. Theodor Zahn (1892) thought the agreement in order accidental and the tense undecidable. Dieter Roth (The Text of Marcion’s Gospel, 2015) weighs the evidence verse by verse and is more cautious than either.

    Eduard Norden (Agnostos Theos, 1913) traced the language of the “unknown god” through ancient religion and philosophy, and showed how common it was. Hans Jonas (The Gnostic Religion, 1958) made the “alien God” a category for the Gnostic systems. Our doctrine shares the word and not the system, as the previous section explained.

    A modern parallel deserves mention. In the same years as Harnack’s Marcion, Karl Barth’s commentary on Romans (second edition, 1922) spoke of God as “wholly other,” a phrase Rudolf Otto had made famous (Das Heilige, 1917). Barth did not divide the Creator from the Father, and he rejected Marcion. But he saw, as Marcion had, that a God who could be found by extending human thought or reading the world would not be the God of the Evangelion. Our doctrine takes the further step Barth refused: the God the world shows is not the Father, because the world is not his.

    Judith Lieu (Marcion and the Making of a Heretic, 2015) warns that the “unknown God” of the sources is partly the construction of opponents. We accept the warning. The doctrine of this chapter rests on our scripture’s own sentences, not on the opponents’ summary of them.

    Objections and Replies

    Objection 1. Paul says God’s invisible attributes are clearly seen in the things he made (Romans 1:19–20). God is known from creation.

    That passage is not in our Romans. Our text passes from the wrath revealed from heaven (Romans 1:6 TT) to the next chapter, and Harnack and Zahn took the intervening verses as absent because Tertullian passes over them. By the absence rule of Chapter 11, we do not rest a doctrine on that absence alone. We rest it on what our text does say: “the world did not know the Lord through its wisdom” (1 Corinthians 1:21 TT). A world that searched with its wisdom and did not find him did not see him clearly in the things that were made.

    Objection 2. If the Father was unknown, then Abraham, Moses and the prophets worshipped a false god.

    They worshipped the Creator, who is real and who made himself known to them. Our doctrine does not call him a false god or them idolaters. It says that the God they knew was not the Father, whom no one knew except the Son. What becomes of those who lived before the Son came is a question for the doctrine of rescue and of the end (Parts 11 and 14), and we will not answer it here by assertion.

    Objection 3. A God who is unknown is no God. A God must be proved by his works.

    That was Tertullian’s rule (Marc. 1.11.2), and Chapter 1 answered it. Tertullian himself granted a second way of knowing God, “by doctrine from his proclamations” (1.18.2), and said that God can be known only “through Himself” (1.18.3). That is the way our scripture describes: the Father known through the Son and the proclamation of the Son.

    Objection 4. Our Evangelion speaks of “the kingdom of God” and “God” many times. Which God is that, if the Father was unknown?

    Chapter 3 set the referent rule for exactly this question. A sentence that names “God” without qualification is read by its explicit qualification, then by the act it describes, then by its relation to the Law, then by its relation to the Son. Where the sentence does not settle it, it carries no doctrine. The doctrine of the unknown Father rests on the sentences that do settle it: Evangelion 6:30 and 6:32 TT, Laodiceans 3:6 TT.

    Objection 5. The doctrine is a counsel of despair. If the Father was unknown for so long, the world was abandoned.

    The world was not empty of God. It had its maker and its rulers. What it did not have was the Father, and our scripture’s message is that he came. Our study of the word put it in the form that belongs in worship: “Unknown is not an insult against the Father. It is a confession against the world.” The doctrine of the unknown God is the background of good news, not its substance. The substance is the next three chapters: the Father is good, his mercy comes first, and he goes looking for the lost.

    Textual Table

    Verse (TT) Our reading Church’s reading Witnesses Status
    Evangelion 6:30 (Luke 10:22) Father before Son; γινώσκει Son before Father Marc. 4.25.10; Dialogue 1.23 quoted; ἔγνω reported but not printed
    Evangelion 6:29 (Luke 10:21) Κύριε τοῦ οὐρανοῦ … καὶ τῆς γῆς Pan. 42, Scholion 22 absence reported
    Evangelion 6:32 (Luke 10:24) “the prophets did not see” “many prophets and kings desired to see … and did not see” Marc. 4.25.12 retroverted; Harnack: tendentious
    Romans 10:2 (Rom 10:3) ἀγνοοῦντες ⸢τὸν Θεόν⸣ ἀγνοοῦντες τὴν τοῦ Θεοῦ δικαιοσύνην Marc. 5.14.6 retroverted
    1 Corinthians 1:21 τὸν ⸢Κύριον⸣ τὸν Θεόν Marc. 5.5.7 retroverted
    Galatians 4:8 τοῖς φύσει οὖσιν θεοῖς τοῖς φύσει μὴ οὖσιν θεοῖς Marc. 5.4.5 (manuscripts divided) quoted; disputed
    Laodiceans 3:6 (Eph 3:9) τῷ Θεῷ ἐν τῷ Θεῷ Marc. 5.18.1 quoted; Tertullian’s charge
    Romans 1:19–2:1 (church) absent God known from creation Harnack and Zahn from Tertullian’s silence decided absence
    Romans 16:25–27 (church) absent the mystery revealed through prophetic writings Origen (Rufinus) reported absence

    Terms

    • Agnitio / γνῶσις (recognition). Tertullian’s word for the Marcionite sense of “new”: new to knowledge (Marc. 1.9.1); the same word renders γνῶσις at 2 Corinthians 4:3 TT.

    • Unknown God. The Father as not known in this aeon until the Son revealed him; the name of worship.

    • Stranger. The Father as not belonging to this aeon; the name of argument.

    • Fremd. Harnack’s word for the Father: foreign, from elsewhere.

    • ἀόρατος (invisible). The Father, of whom the Son is the image (Colossians 1:15 TT).

    • ἀγνωσία Θεοῦ (ignorance of God). Said within the assembly (1 Corinthians 15:26 TT).

    • Four senses of “unknown.” Unacknowledged, obscured, partly known, unrevealed. Our doctrine is the fourth.