Glossary

    Questions Readers Ask

    4 min read

    0:005:08

    🎧 Listen while you read

    These are the questions I hear most often when I present this argument. The answers are short, and each points back to the chapter where the matter is treated in full.

    Jesus lived among Jews and taught in synagogues. How can he not be the Jewish Messiah?

    Living among a people is one thing, and being the king their God promised them is another. The first Gospel shows Jesus teaching in Galilee and Judea, and it never gives him a tribe, a family tree or a claim on the throne. The Messiah was defined by descent from David and by what he would accomplish for Israel. Jesus claimed neither the descent nor the task. The question of his origin is the subject of a separate book, Christ Without Bloodline.

    If he is not the Messiah, why call him Christ?

    The word means “anointed,” which is to say chosen and appointed. The Creator appointed kings for Israel, and the prophets expected him to appoint one more. The Father appointed his Son and sent him to everyone. The first Gospel and Paul both use the title for Jesus in that second sense. It is the same word with a different God behind it, as Chapter 6 explains.

    Do the family trees in Matthew and Luke not prove he was David’s son?

    Those two lists are in the church’s Bible and not in the first one. They also disagree with each other. Matthew traces the line from David through his son Solomon and names Joseph’s father as Jacob. Luke traces it through another son, Nathan, and names Joseph’s father as Heli. And both lists lead to Joseph, who according to those same two Gospels was not the father of Jesus. A bloodline that reaches a man by way of someone who was not his father has not reached him.

    Are you saying the Creator broke his word?

    This book makes no charge against the Creator’s sincerity. Its claim is about what the Father has done. A greater God sent his own Son into the Creator’s world, and that Son announced that the Law and the Prophets had been in effect until John. The promise was overtaken by an event the prophets never saw. The five chapters from 16 to 20 set out how.

    Is this replacement theology under another name?

    It is the reverse. Replacement theology says the church has inherited the promises made to Israel. This book says nobody has inherited them. They belonged to Israel, they meant what they said, and the church had no right to them. Chapter 23 takes this up.

    Is the book against the Jewish people?

    No. On the question that has divided Christians and Jews for two thousand years, whether Jesus was the Messiah of the prophets, this book concludes that the synagogue was right. It asks no Jew to accept him as that Messiah. Its one hard claim is that the king Israel was promised will not arrive, and it adds that the Father who sent Jesus means to give life to all people, Israel included.

    Did Marcion not simply remove whatever he disagreed with?

    That was his opponents’ accusation. We hold that the shorter Gospel and the shorter letters are the earlier ones and that the church’s versions were enlarged. But set that dispute aside for a moment, because the central argument of this book does not depend on it. Each of the five reasons in Part Four rests on a passage that stands in the church’s Bible too. The Law and the Prophets were until John (Luke 16:16). The strong man is overpowered and disarmed (Luke 11:21–22). The wall is broken down (Ephesians 2:14). Christ hands the kingdom to the Father and abolishes every rule, and flesh and blood cannot inherit the kingdom (1 Corinthians 15:24, 50). And when men come saying “I am Christ,” the instruction is not to go after them (Luke 21:8). The riddle about David’s son stands there as well (Luke 20:41–44). A reader who rejects Marcion’s text entirely still has to explain those verses.

    Why rely so much on Tertullian, who was Marcion’s enemy?

    For that very reason. A friend might shade the evidence in Marcion’s favor, and Tertullian had every motive to do the opposite. When he reports what stood in Marcion’s Gospel, or how the Marcionites read a verse, he is recording things that were inconvenient to his own case, and he had no reason to invent them. Courts give special weight to testimony of that kind.

    What about the book of Revelation, where Jesus is called the Lion of the tribe of Judah and the Root of David?

    Revelation uses those titles (Revelation 5:5), and the letter to the Hebrews says that “our Lord sprang out of Juda” (Hebrews 7:14, King James Version). Neither book was part of the first Christian Bible. They show what a later generation of the church had come to believe. They are not evidence for what Jesus said or what Paul wrote.

    Will Jesus come again?

    Yes. The first Gospel says people will see the Son of Man coming from heaven with great power, and Paul says the Lord will descend from heaven and his people will meet him in the air. What neither of them says is that he will come to sit on a throne in Jerusalem. Chapter 19 and Chapter 21 cover this.

    Where can I read the first Gospel for myself?

    The Evangelion and the ten letters of Paul are published together as the True Testament by the Marcionite True Testament Assembly. Every quotation in this book marked “TT” can be found there by its book, chapter and verse.