Chapter 23 of 24

    What Is Left for Israel

    5 min read

    0:006:23

    🎧 Listen while you read

    We met Justin’s debate with the Jewish teacher Trypho in Chapter 4. It is one of the earliest Christian books written to persuade Jews, and it is polite in tone. But early in it Justin makes a claim that would shape Christian thinking for the next eighteen centuries. The Christians, he tells Trypho, are now “the true spiritual Israel” (Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 11).

    That claim takes a great deal. The promises to Abraham, the covenant at Sinai, the throne of David and the gathering of the exiles had all been made to a particular people. Justin’s claim moved them to a new owner. Israel kept the history, the Law and the scolding of the prophets, while the church took the blessings. The name “Israel” itself was handed over to the Gentiles.

    Scholars call this idea supersessionism, the belief that the church has replaced Israel. Over the centuries it did a great deal of harm. If the church was the real Israel, then the Jews who remained were the people who had lost their place, and generation after generation of Christians treated them that way.

    Why This Book Does Not Do That

    The argument of this book runs in the opposite direction from Justin’s. It does not say the church is the true Israel. It says the promises to Israel belonged to Israel, they meant what they said, and the Jewish reading of the prophets is the correct one. The church never had any right to take those promises, because they were never made to the church. They were made by the Creator to his own people, about a king, a throne and a land.

    That is also why I have to say something hard. If the argument of Part Four holds, then the promise made to David will not be kept, and the people who have waited for it so faithfully are waiting for something that will not arrive.

    I do not say that lightly, and I do not say it with any satisfaction. Earlier generations of Christians often said it with a kind of triumph, as if the Jews’ disappointment proved that the church had won. There is nothing to win here. A promise that will not be kept is a loss for the people it was made to.

    Though He Tarry

    The hope I am describing as closed is one of the most durable things in human history, and it should be heard in its own words. In the twelfth century Moses Maimonides drew up thirteen principles of Jewish faith. The twelfth, in the form found in many prayer books, reads: “I believe with perfect faith in the coming of the Messiah, and though he may tarry, I wait daily for his coming.” Jews have recited that sentence for centuries, through expulsions and massacres that most of us can hardly imagine, and many recite it still.

    Maimonides also set down, in his great code of Jewish law, how the Messiah is to be recognized, and his test is a practical one. The king Messiah does not need to perform miracles. He is to be a king from the house of David who studies the Law, brings Israel back to it and fights its battles. If he goes on to rebuild the temple and gather the scattered people, he is the Messiah beyond doubt. If he fails, or is killed, he was not the one (Maimonides, Mishneh Torah, Laws of Kings 11:3–4).

    That is the promise of Chapter 1 as stated by the most respected authority in rabbinic Judaism, and it has the same parts: a son of David, the Law, the temple and the gathered exiles. On the meaning of the promise he and I are in full agreement. By his test Jesus was clearly not the Messiah of Israel, since Jesus did none of those things and was killed. Where we differ is on whether the wait will ever end.

    What This Book Does Not Ask

    Because the history between Christians and Jews is what it is, three things need to be said outright.

    This book does not ask any Jewish reader to accept Jesus as the Messiah of Israel. The church has demanded that for most of two thousand years, sometimes at the point of a sword. My argument is that he was not that Messiah and never said he was. On that question the synagogue was right and the church was wrong.

    It does not claim Israel’s promises for anyone else. No church, and no assembly of ours, has inherited the throne, the land or the covenants. They were Israel’s when they were given, and nobody has taken them over.

    And it gives no one a reason to think less of the people who are still waiting. Their waiting is faithfulness to a word that was truly spoken to them. If I am right that the word will not be fulfilled, the fault does not lie with those who believed it.

    Israel Is Not Left With Nothing

    But the loss is not the end of the story, and this is where the Father of Jesus differs from every other figure in the Bible.

    Remember why Paul says the Son was sent. “But when the time was fulfilled, God sent forth his Son, so that he might purchase those under Law, that we might receive adoption.” (Galatians 4:4–5 TT). The people who were “under Law” were Israel first of all. The Father sent his Son, before anyone else, for the very people who had lived under the Creator’s Law, to buy them out from under it and make them his own children.

    Paul says the same thing in Laodiceans. Christ “came and proclaimed peace to you who were far away and to those near” (Laodiceans 2:17 TT). The ones far away were the Gentiles. The ones near were Israel. The peace was announced to both.

    And Paul’s hope does not stop with those who heard the message in his lifetime. “For just as in Adam all die, so also in Christ all will be made alive” (1 Corinthians 15:19 TT). The Father means “to reconcile all things to himself, making peace through the blood of his stake, through him, whether things on earth or things in heaven” (Colossians 1:19 TT). No one is left out of that “all,” and Israel is certainly not left out.

    A Throne Lost, a Father Gained

    So the answer to the question at the head of this chapter is this. Israel loses a king. The son of David who was supposed to sit on the throne in Jerusalem will not come, and the restored kingdom the prophets described will not be built.

    What Israel gains is what everyone gains: a Father who was unknown until Jesus revealed him, who is “kind even to the ungrateful and the wicked” (Evangelion 3:35 TT), and who intends to make every human being alive in Christ. That is not a consolation prize. It is a better gift than a throne, because a throne belongs to this world, and this world is passing away.

    Paul wrote about his own people with obvious affection. “For I bear witness that they have a zeal for God” (Romans 10:1 TT). That zeal was real, and so was their faithfulness to the promise. The Father is not going to reward it with the empty throne they were promised. He is going to give them what he gives everyone else, which is himself.