The church’s Bible has Paul call Jesus a descendant of David three times. That is not many for the thirteen letters that carry his name, but three would be enough if they were his. This chapter looks at each of them, and then at what Paul says in the first Bible about knowing Christ by his human descent.
The Opening of Romans
The first stands at the very beginning of Romans. The church’s letter opens by describing “Jesus Christ our Lord, which was made of the seed of David according to the flesh” (Romans 1:3, King James Version). That verse is not in the True Testament.
This is a point where it would be easy to overstate the case. No ancient writer clearly reports what Marcion’s copy of Romans had at this point, and an argument built on what a witness does not say is too weak to carry weight. So I will not rest any part of the argument on this verse.
I do not need to. The passages that are attested, Galatians 4 and 1 Corinthians 15, already tell us what Paul thought. Christ was sent, he came from heaven, and the hope he brings is to bear the image of the heavenly one. The earliest Christian writer gives his Lord an origin in heaven and no human ancestry at all.
For the record, this is how the letter opens in the True Testament: “Paul, a servant of Christ Jesus, called to be an apostle, set apart for the Evangelion of God. Through Christ we received grace and apostleship for the obedience of faith among all the nations, for the sake of his name.” (Romans 1:1–2 TT). The sentence runs from Paul’s calling to his mission without a detour through David’s family.
The End of Romans
The second place is near the close of the same letter. In the church’s fifteenth chapter Paul quotes Isaiah: “There shall be a root of Jesse, and he that shall rise to reign over the Gentiles” (Romans 15:12, King James Version). Jesse was David’s father, so this is the prophecy of the Branch from Chapter 2, applied to Jesus.
Here we do have a witness. Origen of Alexandria, whom we have met twice already, reports in his commentary on Romans that Marcion’s copy of the letter stopped at the words about whatever is not of faith being sin, and had nothing after them. Those words are the last line of Romans in the True Testament: “whatever is not from faith is sin” (Romans 14:4 TT). They fall at the end of the church’s fourteenth chapter. The root of Jesse is in the fifteenth.
The Letter to Timothy
The third place is in the second letter to Timothy: “Remember that Jesus Christ of the seed of David was raised from the dead according to my gospel” (2 Timothy 2:8, King James Version). Timothy was Paul’s younger co-worker. The church’s Bible has two letters addressed to him and one to another assistant named Titus, and together they are called the Pastoral letters.
None of the three was in the first collection of Paul. Tertullian says so himself. He remarks that he is surprised Marcion accepted the short letter to Philemon, which was written to one man, and yet had neither of the letters to Timothy nor the one to Titus (Against Marcion 5.21). A great many modern scholars, working from the vocabulary and style of these letters and with no interest in Marcion, have concluded that they were written in Paul’s name after his death.
So the tally is this. Of the three places where Paul is made to call Jesus the seed of David, one stands in an opening for which we have no clear witness, one stands in a chapter that Origen says the first Bible did not have, and one stands in a letter that Tertullian says it did not have. In the ten letters as Marcion published them, Paul never says it.
The Other Seed
Seed of David is not the only line of descent the church’s Paul gives to Christ. In the church’s Galatians he argues that God’s promises were made “to Abraham and his seed,” and that the seed “is Christ” (Galatians 3:16, King James Version). He ends the chapter by telling his readers, “if ye be Christ’s, then are ye Abraham’s seed, and heirs according to the promise” (Galatians 3:29, King James Version). On this account the blessing given to the father of the Jewish nation runs down a family line to Jesus, and from Jesus out to the church.
Neither verse is in the True Testament, and Tertullian confirms the difference. He complains that the mention of Abraham is missing from this part of Marcion’s letter (Against Marcion 5.3). In the first Bible, the third chapter of Galatians moves from the curse of the Law to this: “For you are all children of faith.” (Galatians 3:13 TT). Paul’s readers are children of faith, and nothing is said about their being anyone’s seed.
The pattern is the same as with David. Wherever the church’s Paul ties Christ into an Israelite family tree, whether Abraham’s or David’s, the first Bible does not have the tie.
Known by the Flesh No Longer
What Paul does say on the subject is in his second letter to the Corinthians, and it is blunt. “So from now on we know no one by the flesh; and though Christ was once known by the flesh, we know him so no longer. Therefore, if anyone is in Christ, he is a new creation; the old things have passed away, and all things have become new.” (2 Corinthians 5:12–13 TT).
To know someone “by the flesh” is to know them by the ordinary human markers of family, nation and descent. Paul says he has stopped identifying anyone that way, and he singles out Christ. There was a time when Christ was thought of in those terms, and Paul no longer thinks of him so.
“Son of David” is as pure a case of knowing someone by the flesh as could be invented. The title has no content apart from descent. It says who a man’s ancestors were and what that entitles him to. Paul’s sentence rules it out as a way of knowing Christ, and the reason he gives is that the old things have passed away.
A Stumbling Block
Paul knew what his own people were looking for, and he says so in one line. “For Jews seek signs and Greeks seek wisdom, but we proclaim Christ on a stake, to the Jews a stumbling block and to the nations foolishness” (1 Corinthians 1:22–23 TT).
The signs were the signs of the Messiah: enemies routed, exiles returning, a king enthroned. Paul had none of those to offer. He had a Christ on a stake, and he knew that for anyone waiting on the prophets this was the opposite of a credential. Under the Law a man hung on a tree was under a curse, and Paul quotes the line himself: “Cursed is everyone who hangs on a tree.” (Galatians 3:9 TT).
The church’s solution was to argue that the prophets had predicted a suffering Messiah all along. Paul never tries that. In the first Bible he calls the stake a stumbling block to those who expected the Messiah, and he lets it remain one. He does not say that the stake proves Jesus is the son of David. He says that to those who are called, whether Jew or Greek, this Christ is “the power of God and the wisdom of God” (1 Corinthians 1:24 TT).
The Rulers Who Did Not Understand
Paul also tells us why Christ was put to death, and his answer has nothing to do with a contest over a throne. “None of the rulers of this aeon understood it; for if they had, they would never have staked the Lord of glory.” (1 Corinthians 2:8 TT).
An aeon is an age, a long era of the world with its own powers in charge. The rulers of this present age did not recognize who Christ was. If he had been the Creator’s anointed king, they would have known him at once, because they had been told to expect him. They did not know him because he did not come from their world.
That brings us to the heart of the book. If Jesus was not the Creator’s Messiah, is that Messiah still on his way? Marcion thought so. The rest of this book explains why I think the answer is no, and why the words of Jesus and Paul close that door.
