Introduction

    Introduction: Which Messiah

    4 min read

    0:004:41

    🎧 Listen while you read

    If you have ever sat through a Christmas Eve service, you know the moment. The lights go down, the candles come out, and someone walks to the front to read from the prophet Isaiah. A child is born, a son is given, and he will reign “upon the throne of David, and upon his kingdom” (Isaiah 9:7, King James Version). Then everyone sings about a baby in a manger, and nobody in the room seems troubled that the baby never sat on a throne, never ruled a kingdom and never governed so much as a village.

    This book is about that gap. It makes one serious claim, and the claim belongs on the first page.

    The title says the Messiah is not coming. I do not mean Jesus. Jesus came. He came in the fifteenth year of the emperor Tiberius, he taught, he healed, he died and he was raised, and everything good I have to tell you depends on that. The Messiah I mean is a different figure: the king from the family of David whom the God of Israel promised to his people, the one who would take the throne in Jerusalem, gather the scattered nation and rule it in peace. That king is the one who is not coming.

    To see why those are two different people, you need one idea that most churches never teach. The earliest Christians we can name who gathered the writings of Paul into a single collection did not believe that the God who made this world and gave Israel its Law was the same as the Father whom Jesus made known. They believed there were two. One is the Creator, the God of the Hebrew scriptures, who made the heavens and the earth, chose Israel and promised it a king. The other is the Father, who was unknown to anyone until Jesus revealed him. Jesus said so himself: “No one knows the Father except the Son, and no one knows the Son except the Father, and anyone to whom the Son reveals him.” (Evangelion 6:30 TT).

    The man who taught this most clearly was Marcion of Sinope, a shipowner from the coast of the Black Sea who came to Rome around the year 140. He published the first Christian Bible we know of. It had one Gospel, which he called simply the Evangelion, the Greek word for “good news,” and ten letters of Paul. The scripture quoted in this book comes from the True Testament, our English edition of that Bible, and it is marked “TT.” Its chapters and verses are numbered in its own way, so where it helps I also give the place in the Bible you may have at home.

    Once you can tell the two Gods apart, two questions follow, and this book is built around them.

    The first question is whether Jesus was the Messiah the Creator promised to Israel. The church says yes, and it reads the prophets at Christmas to prove it. I will show you that the first Gospel says no. In its pages Jesus never claims the throne of David. When other people hand him the title, he quiets them, and the one time he brings up the subject himself, he does it to take the title apart.

    The second question is the one on the cover. If Jesus was not that Messiah, is that Messiah still on his way? Many people have assumed so, including Marcion himself. I am going to argue that he is not coming at all, and I will give you every reason I have, drawn from the words of Jesus and of Paul.

    Nothing in this book is written against the Jewish people. As you will see, the Jewish reading of the prophets is the one I think is correct. The prophets promised a king, a throne and a restored nation, and the people who kept waiting for that understood their own scriptures better than the church did. My argument is with the promise and with the God who made it. It has never been with those who believed him.

    The book has five parts. Part One sets out what Israel was promised, what the Jews of the time of Jesus expected, and how the church later reshaped the promise to fit him. Part Two reads the first Gospel scene by scene to see what Jesus did with the title of Christ and what he meant by the kingdom of God. Part Three turns to Paul. Part Four is the center of the book. It gives five reasons, taken from Jesus and Paul, why the Messiah of Israel is not coming, and then takes up the two strongest replies the church can make. Part Five asks what all of this means for Israel and for you.

    I have tried to write so that a reader with no background can follow every step. Every person is introduced when he first appears, every unfamiliar word is explained, and a list of people and terms is at the back. When I quote the church’s Bible I use the King James Version, because it is the one most English readers have heard, and because nobody can say I picked a translation to suit my case.

    We will start where the promise started, with a king, a prophet and a house that was supposed to last forever.