Chapter 8 of 8

    Questions You May Ask Us

    6 min read

    0:008:02

    🎧 Listen while you read

    I have asked a good many questions in this book, and you will have some for us. Here are six that we are often asked. I answer each one and then ask one in return.

    1. Aren’t you Gnostics?

    No, though we have been filed under that name for a long time. The Gnostic teachers, the Valentinians above all, had a heavenly Fullness peopled with thirty Aeons, a fallen Wisdom called Sophia, a higher class of spiritual people, and salvation through secret knowledge. We have none of that. We do share with them the belief that the maker of this world is not the Father. In their systems he is a botched offspring of the heavenly world. In ours he is no one’s offspring. He is the other God.

    We have faith in a good Father who rescues people who did nothing to earn it, and who asks them to learn no secret first. Our scriptures are public. Anyone may read them. In your Bible Paul says of the rescued (Galatians 3:26):

    For ye are all the children of God by faith in Christ Jesus.

    Our text is shorter: “For you are all children of faith” (Galatians 3:13 TT).

    Then may I ask: when you read our eleven books, where do you find a Fullness of thirty Aeons, a fallen Sophia, a higher class of spiritual people or a secret knowledge?

    2. Isn’t it antisemitic to reject the Old Testament?

    No. We say that the God of the Law is not the Father of Jesus Christ. That rejection is real. What we deny is the step from rejecting a god to rejecting a people. The line we draw runs between two Gods and their covenants, and people of every nation stand on both sides of it. The Creator’s Law binds Jew and Gentile alike, and the Father’s rescue is for both alike. Paul’s rule is our rule (Galatians 3:28):

    There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither bond nor free, there is neither male nor female: for ye are all one in Christ Jesus.

    It was the churches that kept the Old Testament, declared themselves its true heirs, and, as early as Justin Martyr, taught that they had taken Israel’s place. We make no claim on another people’s scriptures, and we do not tell the Jewish people that their own books were secretly about us.

    Then may I ask: which is harder on the Jewish people: an assembly that leaves their scriptures to them, or a church that takes those scriptures and says they were about the church all along?

    3. Where were you for two thousand years?

    We were banned, our meeting places were seized and our books were hunted out, and still we lasted for centuries. Marcionite assemblies spread from Rome into Syria, Persia and Armenia, and a family resemblance surfaced again among the Paulicians, the Bogomils and the Cathars, though those movements were not ours. After the last Marcionite assemblies in the East the line cannot be traced, and I do not claim an unbroken succession. What survived was the text: Paul’s letters in every Bible, and enough of the Evangelion in the books of its opponents to rebuild it.

    When an empire silences an assembly, that shows who held power. It does not show who was right. Protestants already grant this, because Luther’s case depended on it. His movement claimed to recover a gospel that had been buried for more than a thousand years, and no Protestant thinks the thousand years prove Luther wrong.

    Paul’s test in Galatians 1:8 is that even an angel from heaven is to be refused if he brings another gospel. By that test a message is judged by what it says. Its age and the number of people who hold it do not settle it. A Catholic or Orthodox reader counts unbroken succession as evidence, and I have put my questions about that succession in the chapter written to Catholics.

    Then may I ask: if a thousand years of silence did not disprove Luther, why would it disprove us?

    4. Didn’t Marcion just cut up the Gospel of Luke?

    That is what his opponents said, and they are the only source for the charge. We hold that Marcion received the Evangelion and published it, that he neither wrote it nor trimmed it, and that Luke is the Evangelion with material added. Most scholars still hold the older view, that the Evangelion is a shortened Luke. Some scholars now argue the reverse, that the Evangelion came first and Luke was built upon it. Others think both came from an earlier gospel. The question is still being argued.

    Like your Mark, the Evangelion has no manger and no genealogy. It begins (Evangelion 1:1 to 1:2 TT):

    It was the fifteenth year of Tiberius Caesar’s reign, in the days of Pilate. That’s when Jesus descended into Capernaum, a town in Galilee. Every Sabbath, he taught the people there.

    We read that opening as the gospel’s true beginning.

    Then may I ask: if scholars are still arguing which came first, why is the charge repeated as settled fact?

    5. Do you say Jesus was only a phantom?

    We do not. Marcion’s opponents wrote that he called Christ’s body a phantom. That is their report, and our gospel does not say it. Christ’s body was real. He died, he was wrapped in linen and laid in a tomb, and after he was awakened he ate in front of his disciples. Our gospel and yours agree on this. Here is yours (Luke 24:42 to 24:43), and then ours (Evangelion 16:32 to 16:33 TT):

    And they gave him a piece of a broiled fish, and of an honeycomb. And he took it, and did eat before them.
    They gave him a piece of broiled fish. He took it and ate it in front of them.

    Our gospel has no birth. We hold that Christ came down and was not born, and Paul says the Father sent him “in the likeness of sinful flesh” (Romans 8:3). The body was real flesh that could be touched and could die. It did not come from a womb or a bloodline.

    Your Bible has verses of Paul that say otherwise. The two clearest are Galatians 4:4, “made of a woman,” and Romans 1:3, “made of the seed of David according to the flesh.” Our text of the first ends at “God sent forth his Son” (Galatians 4:4 TT), and our Romans does not have the second.

    Then may I ask: where does Paul speak of Christ’s mother, birth or childhood in a passage both our Bibles have?

    6. Do you believe everyone is saved? Is there no judgment?

    We believe the Father will leave no one behind, and we believe there is a judgment. We do not teach hell. We teach that every soul is born perishing in this present aeon, and that the Father is taking souls out of it and will finish the work, so that no soul is lost forever. Paul speaks of the perishing and of the reconciling (1 Corinthians 1:18 and Colossians 1:20):

    For the preaching of the cross is to them that perish foolishness; but unto us which are saved it is the power of God.
    And, having made peace through the blood of his cross, by him to reconcile all things unto himself; by him, I say, whether they be things in earth, or things in heaven.

    The perishing is real, and it is happening now. The reconciling is also real, and Paul says it reaches all things. Our teaching differs from what is usually called universalism, in which one God made everyone, judged everyone and in the end relents.

    Paul still says we must all appear before the judgment seat of Christ, where the work of each life is shown for what it was (2 Corinthians 5:10). There are losses there, and rewards. That judgment does not sort the rescued from the lost, and the Father does not punish there.

    Then may I ask: Paul says the Father will “reconcile all things unto himself.” What do you say He will fail to reconcile?

    A last word

    I do not expect one small book to change what you believe. I hope it sends you back to your Bible with questions you did not have before.

    Our scriptures are open to read at TrueTestament.org.

    Grace to you, and peace.

    W. C. Muenchow IV