Chapter 5 of 8

    Questions for Methodists

    6 min read

    0:008:00

    🎧 Listen while you read

    You are the heirs of John Wesley. Your church teaches that grace changes a life as well as a verdict, and your Articles of Religion say something I believe with you: that a person “cannot turn and prepare himself, by his own natural strength and works, to faith” (Article VIII). Paul says the same in Philippians 2:13:

    For it is God which worketh in you both to will and to do of his good pleasure.

    I want to ask whether Wesley’s warm heart and Wesley’s Articles belong together. The quotations are from his Articles of Religion, his Journal and the King James Bible.

    1. Which books were never doubted?

    Article V defines the Bible as those canonical books “of whose authority was never any doubt in the church,” and then receives all the books of the New Testament “as they are commonly received.”

    The first half is a clear test, and the New Testament received in the second half does not pass it. Eusebius, the church’s first historian, writing in the early 300s, lists James, Jude, 2 Peter, and 2 and 3 John as disputed books, and reports doubts about Hebrews and Revelation. Twelve centuries later Luther set four of those same books apart at the back of his New Testament. By the Article’s standard, at least seven books of your New Testament fall short. The earliest fixed list that history knows of, our eleven books, contains none of the seven.

    May I ask: which books would be left if Article V were applied as it is written?

    A Methodist might say the doubts were settled in time. Doubts that were settled in time are still doubts, and the Article says never.

    2. Not contrary?

    Article VI says that “the Old Testament is not contrary to the New.” The first chapter showed Jesus quoting the Law and commanding the reverse. Paul speaks to it as well (2 Corinthians 3:9):

    For if the ministration of condemnation be glory, much more doth the ministration of righteousness exceed in glory.

    The Article says the two testaments agree because both offer everlasting life by Christ. It does not deal with the places where they differ. Paul calls what was “written and engraven in stones” a ministration of death and of condemnation, and he sets it against the ministration of righteousness. Having said “not contrary,” the Article owes some account of that, and gives none.

    May I ask: what would Paul have had to call the Law before you would count it as contrary?

    Methodists often call revelation progressive, the Old preparing the way for the New. Paul does speak of a lesser glory and a greater one. But the names he gives the two ministrations are condemnation and righteousness, and those are opposites.

    3. Who divided the Law?

    Article VI goes on to say that the ceremonies and civil rules of Moses do not bind Christians, but that “no Christian whatsoever is free from the obedience of the commandments which are called moral.” Paul writes of the Law (Galatians 5:3 and Colossians 2:16):

    For I testify again to every man that is circumcised, that he is a debtor to do the whole law.
    Let no man therefore judge you in meat, or in drink, or in respect of an holyday, or of the new moon, or of the sabbath days:

    The Article does not say who calls them moral. The division of the Law into moral, civil and ceremonial parts is not found in Moses, in Jesus or in Paul. It comes from the theologians of the Middle Ages. Paul speaks of “the whole law.”

    May I ask: where does Scripture divide the Law into the part that binds you and the part that does not?

    The moral law, Methodists say, reflects God’s unchanging character. The Sabbath is one of the Ten Commandments, so it must reflect that character too. Yet Paul lists the Sabbath with food and feast days as something no one may judge you for, and your church does not keep the seventh day.

    4. Does grace give free will back to everyone?

    Wesley taught that grace goes before every person and restores enough freedom to accept or refuse God. Your Article VIII calls it “the grace of God by Christ preventing us.” Paul’s picture of the person before rescue is different (Ephesians 2:1 and Romans 7:14):

    And you hath he quickened, who were dead in trespasses and sins;
    For we know that the law is spiritual: but I am carnal, sold under sin.

    Article VIII agrees with Paul that no one can turn himself to God. But Wesley also wanted every person to have a free choice, so he taught that a universal grace has already given that choice back to everyone. The texts he gave for it do not say so. Paul says “dead” and “sold.”

    May I ask: which verse says that every person has already been given back the power to choose the Father?

    Methodist writers cite your John 1:9, the light that lights every man, and your Titus 2:11, the grace that has appeared to all men. One speaks of light and the other of grace appearing. The restored will is in neither.

    5. Perfect in this life?

    Wesley taught that a believer can be made perfect in love in this life. Paul tells the Galatians (5:17):

    For the flesh lusteth against the Spirit, and the Spirit against the flesh: and these are contrary the one to the other: so that ye cannot do the things that ye would.

    Wesley took the voice in Romans 7 to be a man before conversion, and I too hear in it one not yet rescued. Galatians cannot be read the same way. There Paul is writing to people who already have the Spirit, and the King James has him tell them: “ye cannot do the things that ye would.” The flesh and the Spirit are still contrary in them.

    May I ask: who among us has done better than the Galatians, whom Paul told that the flesh and the Spirit were still at war in them?

    A Methodist will point to the verse before: “Walk in the Spirit, and ye shall not fulfil the lust of the flesh.” Paul gives that as a command to people still in the fight. In verse 24 he says that those who are Christ’s “have crucified the flesh,” and in the next breath he is still telling them to walk in the Spirit.

    6. What warmed Wesley’s heart?

    Of a meeting in Aldersgate Street in 1738, Wesley wrote, “I felt my heart strangely warmed.” He tells us what he was listening to. Someone was reading Luther’s preface to Romans, on the change God works in the heart through faith in Christ. What reached him, by his account, was trust in Christ alone, with no commandment in view. Paul once asked an assembly how the Spirit had first come to them (Galatians 3:2 to 3:3):

    This only would I learn of you, Received ye the Spirit by the works of the law, or by the hearing of faith? Are ye so foolish? having begun in the Spirit, are ye now made perfect by the flesh?

    In the True Testament the question reads (Galatians 3:2 to 3:3 TT):

    This only I want to learn from you: Did you receive the Spirit by works of Law or by hearing through faith? Are you so foolish? Having begun in the Spirit, are you now being completed in the flesh?

    A few years after Aldersgate, Wesley read Luther’s commentary on Galatians and condemned the way Luther spoke of the Law. The Articles he later gave his church bind every Methodist to the moral commandments. That is the road Paul describes in the verses above: begun in the Spirit, finished in the flesh.

    May I ask: Wesley’s heart was warmed by faith in Christ, with no commandment in view. Why did he then bind his church to the commandments “which are called moral”?

    Wesley feared lawless living. Paul faced the same fear in Romans 6:15: “shall we sin, because we are not under the law, but under grace? God forbid.” He answered it without putting believers back under the Law. Where he quotes a commandment, he hangs no curse on it.