Chapter 9 of 16

    Canon

    5 min read

    0:006:56

    🎧 Listen while you read

    “For I neither received it from man nor was I taught it, but I received it through a revelation of Christ Jesus.” (Galatians 1:11)

    A canon is a measuring stick. The Greek word means a rod, a ruler, a standard against which things are checked. When the early Pauline congregations spoke of the canon, they did not mean a list of books. They meant the rule the books had to meet. The list came later. The rule came first.

    That order matters. The orthodox tell the story backwards. They say the canon is the set of twenty-seven books their councils approved in the late fourth century, and that those books are scripture because the church declared them so. That is a definition of canon as decree. A bishop signs a list, the list is binding, the books on it are scripture, the books off it are not. We do not work that way and we never have.

    The Earliest Collection

    Marcion’s collection of one Gospel and ten letters is the earliest closed Christian collection we have clear evidence for. Its exact date and setting are debated, and so is its relation to anything gathered before it. Whether to call it the “first canon” depends on what you mean by canon, and we do not claim that no writing had authority before it.

    His collection drove much of the later argument over which books counted. The fourfold Gospel and the wider New Testament did not come from that one reaction alone, but the twenty-seven-book settlement is later than Marcion, and that much is not in dispute.

    Our Canon Is the Same Canon

    We have not changed it. The True Testament Assembly’s canon is the Evangelion and the Apostolikon, eleven books. Those are the eleven books Marcion published, and they are the eleven we hold now. We added no book and removed none. The wording is another matter. No Marcionite manuscript survives, so the text of those books is a reconstruction from hostile witnesses, with some lines well attested and some supplied, and we say so.

    This is one of the cleanest claims in our faith. Most religious bodies have to defend a canon that grew in their hands. Catholics have to explain why their canon is larger than the Protestant one. Protestants have to explain why theirs is smaller than the Catholic one and why both are larger than the second-century Christian one. We do not have those problems. Ours is the earliest closed Christian canon the record shows. Our defense is the historical record.

    What the Canon Excludes, and Why

    Our canon excludes the Old Covenant. Genesis, Exodus, the Law, the Prophets, the Psalms, the Wisdom literature, none of it is scripture for us. We do not call it sacred. We do not cite it as binding. It is the Creator’s library, useful for understanding the system Christ came to deliver us out of, but it is not the Father’s word and it is not the rule we measure by.

    Our canon excludes the other three gospels, Matthew, Mark, and John. We hold that they are later books, assembled to soften or counter what the Evangelion already said. We do not curse them and we do not burn them. We simply do not read them as scripture. They are not the standard. The Evangelion is.

    Our canon excludes the Pastorals, First and Second Timothy and Titus. They are forgeries in Paul’s name. They were written after his death to put commands in his mouth he never spoke. We do not cite them. When someone uses one of them against us, we say what they are and we move on.

    Our canon excludes the Catholic epistles, James, the letters of Peter, the letters of John, and Jude, along with the Apocalypse of John. They were written in a different stream, by different authors, in a different theological key. Some of them are direct attacks on Paul’s teaching. James in particular reads as a deliberate counter-argument to Galatians. We let them be what they are: documents of the Jewish-Christian compromise the Pauline congregations did not join. They are not in our canon.

    Our canon excludes Acts. Acts is a second-century historical novel written to harmonize Paul with the Twelve and to install the Creator’s God as the same God whom Paul preached. It is the merger doctrine in narrative form. It is also where the familiar story of a “Jerusalem council” comes from, a story Paul himself tells very differently in Galatians 2, where he goes up by revelation, meets privately with those of reputation, and does not yield for an hour. We do not use Acts. Not as history, not as scripture, not as background. The only thing we will say about the Twelve after the staking is what the Evangelion and Galatians 1–2 allow us to say. Everything else is fiction.

    The Canon Is a Rule, Not a Vault

    This is where we differ from the orthodox use of the word. They treat their canon as a vault, twenty-seven books, sealed, untouchable, anything outside the vault is excluded by definition. We treat ours as a rule. The eleven books are the standard because they preserve the Evangelion Paul preached. If a sentence inside one of those books contradicts the Evangelion, we measure it against the rule and find it added. If a sentence outside the eleven happens to preserve a true word, a hostile witness quoting Marcion accurately, for example, we can recognize it as a true word without admitting it into the canon.

    The rule is older than the list. The list serves the rule. We hold the eleven books because they hold the message; we do not hold the message because we have decreed eleven books.

    “Canon” Against “Bible”

    We do not use the word Bible among ourselves either, and the printed True Testament does not use it: its subtitle is The Restored Marcionite Canon. Bible is a Greek plural, the books, and it became the orthodox name for a bound volume that contains the Creator’s library and the Apostolic library glued together. To call our scripture a Bible is to accept that gluing. We do not accept it. We say the True Testament when we mean our complete scripture in print, one Evangelion plus the Apostolikon, and we say canon when we mean the rule that decides what counts.

    What You Do With This Word

    When someone asks, “What is your canon?”, give them the straight answer. Eleven books. The Evangelion and the ten letters of Paul. No Old Covenant. No other gospels. No Pastorals. No Hebrews. No Catholic epistles. No Acts. No Apocalypse. The same canon Marcion published around 140, recovered from under the orthodox edits.

    And when they say, “That is a smaller canon than ours,” say yes. It is smaller on purpose. We do not receive the conventional twenty-seven books as one divine library. The Father spoke one Evangelion through His Son and one body of letters through Paul. The rest is the Creator’s literature and the orthodox library. We do not need it. We have what He sent.