Chapter 3 of 3

    The Tightrope Walker

    10 min read

    0:0012:36

    🎧 Listen while you read

    The Fall in the Square

    While Zarathustra is talking about the last man, the performance he interrupted goes on above him. A tightrope walker steps out onto a rope strung between two towers over the market square. Halfway across, a second figure springs out of the same door behind him, "a motley fellow, like a jester," and comes after him shouting: "'Forward, lame-foot,' cried his fearful voice, 'forward, sluggard, smuggler, pale-face! Lest I tickle you with my heel!'" (P.6.1). When he is one step behind, the jester "let out a cry like a devil and leapt over the one who was in his way" (P.6.1). The walker loses his balance, drops his pole, and falls into the square at Zarathustra's feet.

    The scene is an allegory, and readers have argued about it ever since. The rope is the one Zarathustra has just described, "tied between beast and overman" (P.4.2). The walker is man on the way across. The jester who leaps over him is something faster and crueler, and Nietzsche gives him a devil's cry. We will not pretend to settle the allegory. What matters for our reply is what happens next, at the bottom of the rope.

    No Devil and No Hell

    The fallen man is not yet dead. When he comes to, he sees Zarathustra kneeling beside him, and his first words are about punishment. "'What are you doing there?' he said at last. 'I have long known that the devil would trip me up. Now he is dragging me to hell: will you stop him?'" (P.6.2).

    That is a terrible sentence, and Nietzsche meant it to be. A man has spent his life walking a rope for the amusement of a crowd, and when he dies his first thought is that the devil has come for him. Whatever he was taught about God, it was mostly about hell. We can grant Nietzsche this scene entirely. A religion that leaves a dying man with nothing but the fear of being dragged to punishment has failed him, and the God it preached was a judge before he was anything else.

    Zarathustra's answer is kind, and it is also the clearest statement in the Prologue of what his gospel can and cannot offer. "'On my honor, friend,' answered Zarathustra, 'none of that exists of which you speak: there is no devil and no hell. Your soul will be dead even sooner than your body: so fear nothing any more!'" (P.6.3).

    There is no hell, and there is nothing else either. The fear of punishment is removed by removing the one who might be punished. Zarathustra frees the dying man from the judge by telling him that he will simply stop.

    The man understands at once what he has been given. "'If you speak the truth,' he then said, 'I lose nothing when I lose my life. I am not much more than an animal that has been taught to dance by blows and scant morsels'" (P.6.4). Nietzsche has put the whole religion of the Law into one image: a creature trained by blows and treats, by punishment and reward, to perform for its keepers. We could not describe the Creator's discipline better.

    Zarathustra contradicts him at once, "Not so," and honors the courage of a man who made danger his vocation: "you have made danger your vocation, and there is nothing contemptible in that" (P.6.5). He promises to bury him with his own hands. It is a kind answer, and we do not belittle it. Yet what he offers in place of the animal is still only an honorable end. The man dies reaching for his hand.

    Paul offers the dying another way out of fear. "For you have not received a spirit of slavery again to fear, but we have been received into adoption, crying 'Abba, Father'" (Romans 8:15 TT). "Because you are God’s children, he has sent his Spirit into our hearts, crying, 'Abba, Father.'" (Galatians 4:6 TT). The fear of the trainer is real, and Paul calls it slavery. But he does not answer it with an honorable end. He answers it with adoption. The one who was driven by blows and morsels is taken into a family where he is not driven at all. Our Lord says the same thing to frightened people: "Don't be afraid, little flock, because the Father is pleased to give you the kingdom" (Evangelion 8:26 TT). Zarathustra could take away the fear of hell. He had nothing to put in its place except the end.

    A Catch of Fish

    Night falls on the square. Zarathustra sits beside the corpse until the crowd is gone, and then he speaks to his heart in words that mock a scene from our Gospel. "Truly, a fine catch of fish Zarathustra made today! No man did he catch, but a corpse" (P.7.2).

    The allusion is to the call of the first disciples. After the great catch on the lake, our Lord says to Simon, "Don't be afraid. From now on, you'll be catching people" (Evangelion 2:11 TT). Zarathustra's first day as a fisher of men ends with a dead man. Nietzsche turns the joke against himself, and it is a good joke.

    Then comes an admission we should keep. "Uncanny is human existence, and still without meaning: a jester can become its doom" (P.7.3). The world as Zarathustra finds it has no meaning of its own. A man walking a rope can be killed by a clown, and nothing in the order of things will object. Zarathustra means to supply the meaning himself, "which is the overman, the lightning from the dark cloud man" (P.7.4). But the confession comes first, and it is a confession about the Creator's world made by the man who has just told us to be faithful to it.

    The Good and the Just

    Zarathustra lifts the corpse onto his back and walks out of the town. The jester catches up with him in the dark and whispers a warning: "'Go away from this town, O Zarathustra,' he said; 'too many here hate you. The good and the just hate you, and they call you their enemy and despiser; the believers of the true faith hate you, and they call you the danger of the multitude'" (P.8.1).

    The phrase "the good and the just" will run through the whole book as Zarathustra's name for the respectable and the orthodox. Here they are the ones who hate the teacher. Our Lord said the same of his own: "Blessed will you be whenever people hate you, insult you, and treat your name as something evil because of the Son of Man" (Evangelion 3:25 TT). Marcion's assemblies knew what it was to be called the danger of the multitude by the believers of the true faith. On this point Zarathustra's experience and ours are the same.

    On the road Zarathustra knocks at a lonely house, and an old hermit gives him bread and wine. "'This is a bad region for the hungry,' he said; 'that is why I live here. Beast and man come to me, the hermit'" (P.8.8). The hermit feeds whoever knocks, without asking what they deserve. It is the gentlest moment in the Prologue, and it is a picture of giving without merit, the door that opens to anyone who knocks. Our Lord said, "knock, and the door will be opened to you" (Evangelion 7:8 TT). Nietzsche, who mocks so much of the Gospel, lets this old man keep his door open.

    Companions, Not a Herd

    Zarathustra sleeps in the forest and wakes at noon with a new truth. "A light has dawned on me: I need companions, and living ones, not dead companions and corpses that I carry with me wherever I will" (P.9.2). And then: "Rather, I need living companions who follow me because they want to follow themselves, and who go where I will" (P.9.3).

    Here Zarathustra rewrites the call to discipleship. Our Lord says to a would-be follower, "Let the dead bury their own dead. But you go and proclaim the kingdom of God" (Evangelion 6:16 TT). Zarathustra, too, leaves the dead behind, and he says so: "I shall be no shepherd, no gravedigger" (P.9.15). But his followers do not follow him. They follow themselves, and happen to go his way. He wants no herd and refuses to be a shepherd: "Zarathustra shall not become the shepherd and dog of a herd!" (P.9.4).

    Our Gospel keeps the shepherd, and it keeps him for a reason. The shepherd in our Evangelion is not the keeper of a herd that thinks alike. He is the one who goes looking for the sheep that wandered off (Evangelion 10:1 TT). Zarathustra pictures shepherds only as the clergy who keep the herd in order, and he wants to lure sheep away from them. He never considers a shepherd who goes out after the one that is lost.

    The Breaker of Tablets

    Then Zarathustra says something that a Marcionite cannot read without a start. "Behold the good and the just! Whom do they hate most? Him who breaks their tablets of values, the breaker, the lawbreaker: but he is the creator" (P.9.7).

    The breaker of the tablets. Marcion was hated by the good and the just of his day for separating the Gospel from the Law, and our Evangelion records the charge brought against our Lord himself: "We found this man misleading the people, opposing the Law and the Prophets" (Evangelion 15:20 TT). On this much Zarathustra and we agree. The tablets of the Law are not the last word, and those who break them are hated by the people who live by them.

    But read the next sentence. "The creator seeks fellow creators, those who write new values on new tablets" (P.9.9). Zarathustra breaks the old tablets in order to carve new ones. He remains a man of tablets. The word he uses for this creator, der Schaffende, means a human maker, not the Creator of the world, and we should not blur the two. Yet the pattern of his work is the pattern of Sinai: values written on stone, and a people to keep them. Paul speaks of a letter written "not on tablets of stone but on fleshy tablets of the heart" (2 Corinthians 3:1 TT), and Chapter 16 will return to it. Paul's answer to the old tablets is to stop writing on stone altogether.

    Zarathustra also widens his charge in a way we should not avoid. "Behold the believers of all faiths! Whom do they hate most? Him who breaks their tablets of values" (P.9.8). All faiths, he says, and that includes ours. Any community that hates the one who breaks its rules stands under that sentence, and we accept the warning.

    Over the Hesitant

    The new truth ends with a vow. "I go toward my goal, I go my own way; over the hesitant and the laggards I will leap. Thus let my going be their going under!" (P.9.18).

    It is hard to read that sentence without remembering the jester. He leapt over a slower man on the rope, and the slower man fell to his death. Now Zarathustra promises to do the same to everyone who hesitates. We do not think Nietzsche meant it as a call to violence, and we will not read it that way. But the figure of the leap came from the jester, and it leaves the slow behind. Paul's God makes a different choice. "God chose the least, the low-born, and the despised, the nothings, to nullify the things that are" (1 Corinthians 1:28 TT). The laggards Zarathustra leaps over are the people Paul says were chosen.

    The Eagle and the Serpent

    The Prologue ends at noon. Zarathustra hears a cry overhead and looks up: "An eagle swept through the air in wide circles, and from it hung a serpent, not like prey but like a friend: for she was coiled around his neck" (P.10.1). These are his animals, the proudest and the cleverest under the sun, and he rejoices to see them.

    The serpent coiled in a ring, the eagle flying in circles: Nietzsche has already planted the images of the teaching he will reveal in his third part, the eternal recurrence of all things in a ring. And he has made a friend of the serpent of Eden, the cleverest creature in the Creator's garden. "Would that I were cleverer! Would that I were clever through and through, like my serpent!" (P.10.7). The prophet who began by blessing the sun ends by wishing for the serpent's cleverness. Both belong to the world as it was made.

    The last line of the Prologue repeats the first: "Thus began Zarathustra's going under" (P.10.10). He has announced the death of God, preached faithfulness to the earth, buried a man he comforted with oblivion, and chosen the eagle and the serpent as his guides. He has done all of it inside the world, with the world's own lights and creatures for company, and he has not yet asked whether there might be a God who was not part of that world at all. His speeches begin in the next part of his book, in a town called the Motley Cow, with three transformations of the spirit. The last of them is a child, who says a sacred Yes.