Chapter 3 of 5

    The Last Supper

    11 min read

    0:0014:01

    🎧 Listen while you read

    The Cry From His Own Cave

    Late in the afternoon Zarathustra comes home without having found the man whose cry he followed all day. Twenty paces from his cave he hears the cry again, and it is coming from inside. All the men he passed on the road are sitting together there: the two kings, the magician, the pope, the beggar, the shadow, the scholar of the leech, the soothsayer and the ugliest man. The cry of distress was theirs, all of them at once.

    Zarathustra greets them warmly. He offers them safety, and "my little finger. And once you have that, then just take the whole hand as well, go on! and the heart with it!" (IV.11.13). The king on the right answers for them all with a speech of praise. Zarathustra is a tall pine, a high strong will, and many are coming up the mountain to him, "for he himself is on his way to you, the last remnant of God among men" (IV.11.31). The guests are the men of great longing and great weariness who cannot live unless they learn to hope again.

    It is a moving scene, and Nietzsche means it to be. A host has opened his cave to the broken men of his age. If the book ended here it would be close to a parable of our Lord's.

    Not High Enough

    It does not end there. Zarathustra steps back from the king's kiss and tells his guests the truth as he sees it. "You may truly all be higher men, Zarathustra went on: but for me... you are not high and strong enough" (IV.11.37). They stand on sick legs and want to be spared, and he does not spare his warriors. "Nor are you beautiful and well-born enough for me" (IV.11.42). "You are only bridges: may higher ones stride across over you!" (IV.11.45). What he waits for is someone else: "laughing lions must come!" (IV.11.50). He longs for his children, "these trees of life of my will and my highest hope!" (IV.11.54), and the guests are only a sign that they are on the way.

    Set beside this the dinner our Lord told his host to give. "When you host a dinner or banquet, don’t invite your friends, your brothers, your relatives, or rich neighbors" (Evangelion 9:16 TT). "Instead, when you give a banquet, invite the poor, those with disabilities, those who cannot walk, and the blind" (Evangelion 9:17 TT). In the parable that follows, when the first guests make excuses, the master sends his slave into the streets to "bring in the poor, those with disabilities, those who cannot see, and those who cannot walk" (Evangelion 9:24 TT).

    Zarathustra's guests are the failed great men of his age, a pope and kings among them, and he tells them they are only bridges. He wants his own to be "healthy and whole" (IV.12.17). Our Lord's table was set for those who could not repay: "Then you will be blessed, because they have nothing to give you in return" (Evangelion 9:18 TT). And he said of his whole work, "People who are healthy don’t need a doctor; the sick do" (Evangelion 2:26 TT).

    We should say what is fair in Zarathustra here. He does not lie to his guests or flatter them. He tells them they want above all "to be spared" (IV.11.39), and some of them do. There is a false kindness that keeps a sufferer sick by sparing him every truth. But the Son's kindness was not of that kind either. He told the paralyzed man, "I tell you, get up, pick up your stretcher, and go home" (Evangelion 2:23 TT).

    Lambs at the Table

    The soothsayer interrupts: he came for a meal, not for speeches. The kings have brought a whole ass-load of wine. Bread is lacking, and Zarathustra laughs: "But man does not live by bread alone, but also by the flesh of good lambs, of which I have two" (IV.12.9). The lambs are to be slaughtered and spiced with sage. The voluntary beggar bristles at the meat and the wine, and Zarathustra lets him keep to his grain: "I am a law only for my own, I am not a law for all" (IV.12.16).

    Then Nietzsche names the meal. "This, however, was the beginning of that long meal which is called 'the Last Supper' in the history books. At it, however, nothing else was talked about but the higher man" (IV.12.21).

    The parody is precise and worth answering exactly. At Zarathustra's supper two lambs are killed for the guests and the host talks about the men who will replace them. The Lord's supper was a Passover meal, and there was a lamb at that table too. But when it was eaten, the host spoke about himself: "He took bread, gave thanks, broke it, and gave it to them, saying, “This is my body, which is given for you.”" (Evangelion 14:8 TT). Our Lord had sent his disciples out "like lambs among wolves" (Evangelion 6:20 TT). Our Apostle said it outright: "For Christ our Passover was sacrificed" (1 Corinthians 5:7 TT). At that table the true lamb was the host, given for the guests.

    The bread line deserves a note too. The saying that man does not live by bread alone comes from the Creator's law in Deuteronomy, and the other Gospels put it in the story of the temptation in the desert, which our Evangelion does not have. Zarathustra is parodying a page we do not read. What we do read is that the Lord took the bread he had and gave it away.

    Before God We Are All Equal

    The long speech on the higher man follows at the table. It begins in the marketplace of the Prologue, where the rabble blinks and says "'You higher men,' so blinks the rabble, 'there are no higher men, we are all equal, man is man, before God... we are all equal!'" (IV.13.5). Zarathustra's answer is the heart of the speech. "Before God! But now this God has died! You higher men, this God was your greatest danger. Only since he has lain in the grave have you risen again" (IV.13.7, IV.13.8). And: "God died: now we will: that the overman live" (IV.13.10).

    In this speech the death of God is good news for one reason above all: it ends equality. While God lived, the king and the beggar stood level before him. With God in the grave, the higher man can become lord. Then Zarathustra says the sentence that, of all the book, is the most exact inverse of our Gospel. "The overman lies close to my heart, he is my first and only, and not man: not the neighbor, not the poorest, not the most suffering, not the best..." (IV.13.12).

    Not the neighbor, not the poorest, not the most suffering. Our Apostle summed up the whole Law in the opposite words: "For the whole Law has been fulfilled in you: “You shall love your neighbor as yourself.”" (Galatians 5:14 TT). And our Lord's Father is the one who is kind to those who are neither the best nor the grateful. Zarathustra knows what he is rejecting. He calls "for the neighbor" the virtue "only of the small people" (IV.13.56), people who say one hand washes the other.

    That last charge is fair against a certain kind of morality, but not against ours. One hand washing the other is the very thing our Lord forbade at table: don't invite those who will "just invite you back and repay you" (Evangelion 9:16 TT). The love of neighbor he taught was not a trade among the small. It was a gift to those who could give nothing back, which is exactly the kind of gift Zarathustra himself praises when he speaks of the overflowing giver.

    Better and More Evil

    "'Man is evil': so all the wisest told me, for my comfort. Ah, if only it is still true today! For evil is man's best strength" (IV.13.25). "'Man must become better and more evil': so I teach" (IV.13.26).

    A careful defender will say that Nietzsche's word here, böse, is the word he elsewhere says the weak use for the strong, so that it means the dangerous drives the small people fear. That is fair, and we will not read him as praising cruelty for its own sake. But he goes on: "It may have been good for that preacher of the small people that he suffered and bore the sin of man. But I rejoice in great sin as my great comfort" (IV.13.27).

    Here we answer plainly. Our Lord did not bear the sin of man because it was good for him. He bore it because it was good for us, and because his Father willed our freedom: he "gave himself for our sins so that he might deliver us from the present evil aeon according to the will of God the Father" (Galatians 1:4 TT). Zarathustra takes comfort in great sin because great sin proves great strength. We take comfort in a deliverance that came for the weak. Then Zarathustra adds what the comfort costs: "Ever more, ever better ones of your kind shall perish" (IV.13.31). The higher men are told, at the supper, that more of them must die. The Son told his disciples that his body was given for them.

    The Desert Saints

    Nietzsche turns next to the saints of the desert, and here his blow falls closer to us than to most. A man whose fathers loved women and strong wine and wild boar would be a fool to demand chastity of himself, and if he founded monasteries Zarathustra would call them a house of correction. "In solitude grows whatever one brings into it, the inner beast as well" (IV.13.70). "Has there been anything filthier on earth until now than desert saints? Around them not only was the devil loose, but the swine as well" (IV.13.71).

    This blow lands on the old assemblies. Their discipline was famous: they baptized the unmarried and the continent, kept a sparing table, and refused to serve the Creator's command to multiply, though, as we said in Chapter 6, they made a law of what Paul called a gift. Nietzsche would have mocked them too.

    We say two things in their defense, and leave the rest to the reader. Their discipline was never meant to tame an inner beast in a desert cell. It was a refusal to keep feeding the Creator's machinery of birth and death, chosen by people who lived among their neighbors in towns, not in caves. And Nietzsche's warning about solitude is one we accept. A man who carries his beast into the wilderness will find it waiting for him. Our Lord did not send his disciples to the desert. He sent them "in pairs ahead of him to every town and place he planned to visit" (Evangelion 6:19 TT).

    Woe to Those Who Laugh

    Now comes the charge about laughter that we first met in Chapter 8. "What has been the greatest sin here on earth until now? Was it not the word of him who said: 'Woe to those who laugh here!'" (IV.13.82). "He... did not love enough: otherwise he would have loved us too, the laughing ones! But he hated and mocked us; wailing and gnashing of teeth he promised us" (IV.13.84). "He came from the rabble" (IV.13.85).

    The woe is in our text. Our Lord said it: "How terrible for you who are laughing now, because you will grieve and cry" (Evangelion 3:27 TT). So is the weeping and gnashing: "There will be weeping and clenching your teeth in despair when you see all the righteous in the kingdom of God, while you yourselves are shut outside" (Evangelion 9:15 TT). Our text keeps both verses, and we will not explain them away.

    But read them in their places. The woe on those laughing now stands in a sermon whose blessing two verses earlier is a promise of laughter: "Blessed are those who weep, because they will laugh" (Evangelion 3:24 TT). Our Lord did not hate laughter. He promised it to those who had none, and he warned those who already had theirs, the full and the rich: "But how terrible for you who are rich, for you have already received your comfort" (Evangelion 3:26a TT). The laughter he warned against was the laughter of the comfortable, who have their comfort already.

    And look at whom the clenched teeth are for. They are for those who see "all the righteous in the kingdom of God" (Evangelion 9:15 TT) while they themselves are shut outside, and the same chapter fills the master's house with the poor, those with disabilities, those who cannot see, and those who cannot walk (Evangelion 9:24 TT). Zarathustra has just told his guests that they are bridges for better men to walk over. If the verse threatens anyone at that supper, it threatens the one who looks down.

    We grant Zarathustra two sentences in this passage, gladly. "How rich this earth is in small, good, perfect things" (IV.13.80). And: "No great love wants love: it wants more" (IV.13.86). The second is near to our Lord's command to love without expecting a return. But Zarathustra applies it against our Lord, as if the Son had raged because he was not loved. The Son on the stake did not rage. He prayed: "Father, forgive them, for they don’t know what they’re doing" (Evangelion 15:32 TT).

    The Crown He Set on His Own Head

    The speech ends with a coronation. "This crown of the laughing one, this rose-wreath crown: I myself have set this crown upon my head, I myself have pronounced my laughter holy" (IV.13.94). At the close he throws the crown to his guests: "Laughter I have pronounced holy; you higher men, learn... to laugh!" (IV.13.108).

    Napoleon once set the crown on his own head with the pope looking on. Zarathustra does the same with holiness. Our Lord gave the rule for crowns in the parable of the Pharisee and the tax collector: "For everyone who exalts himself will be humbled, and everyone who humbles himself will be exalted" (Evangelion 11:30 TT). Zarathustra crowns himself because, he says, he found no one else strong enough to do it. The guests at his supper have no one to crown them either. They will try to find someone before the night is out, and the next chapter tells us whom they chose.