Chapter 1 of 4

    The Vision and the Riddle

    11 min read

    0:0015:06

    🎧 Listen while you read

    A Wanderer Who Meets Only Himself

    The third part of Zarathustra opens at midnight on a mountain ridge. Zarathustra is leaving the blessed isles and his friends, and as he climbs toward the ship he talks to his own heart. What he says there is the key to everything the third part teaches, though it sounds at first like a passing mood.

    "And whatever may yet come to me as fate and experience, there will be a wandering in it and a mountain climbing: in the end one experiences only oneself" (III.1.3). And a moment later: "It only returns, it comes home to me at last: my own self, and whatever of it has long been abroad and scattered among all things and chances" (III.1.5).

    In the end one experiences only oneself. Nothing arrives that was not already one's own. The sentence is spoken about a man's life, but it is already the shape of the doctrine the third part will unveil, the eternal recurrence of the same. A world in which nothing comes from outside, and everything that comes is only what was already there coming home, is a world with no visitor in it.

    We should be fair to the mood of this opening, because Nietzsche gives Zarathustra more tenderness here than his readers often notice. Standing over the dark sea, Zarathustra wishes he could comfort it: "Gladly, truly, would I redeem you from evil dreams!" (III.1.30). Then he laughs at himself. "Every monster you wanted to stroke" (III.1.33), he says, and he names the weakness exactly: "Love is the danger of the loneliest, love of everything, if only it lives!" (III.1.34).

    There is the strange thing. Zarathustra feels in himself a love for everything that lives, even the monstrous, a love that would comfort the sea and stroke the beast. He laughs at it as a folly, and then, thinking of the friends he has left, he weeps (III.1.35). Nietzsche lets the tenderness stand. But a little earlier on the same ridge Zarathustra had given himself a rule that points the other way: "Now what is mildest in you must yet become the hardest" (III.1.12). "Praised be what makes hard!" (III.1.13).

    We will meet this pattern again and again in the third part. Something close to kindness rises in Zarathustra, and the teaching he gives treats it as the thing to be conquered.

    The Dwarf and the Gateway

    The second speech, On the Vision and the Riddle, is told on the ship to sailors, "the bold searchers and researchers" (III.2.2). Zarathustra tells them of a climb up a mountain path with a dwarf on his shoulders, "the spirit of gravity, my devil and archenemy" (III.2.9). The dwarf mocks him. Every stone that is thrown must fall, and Zarathustra, who threw himself so high, will fall back on himself.

    Zarathustra answers with courage. "Courage is the best slayer: courage slays even pity" (III.2.20). And courage "slays even death, for it says: 'Was that life? Well then! Once more!'" (III.2.21). He adds a formula our Lord used: "He who has ears, let him hear" (III.2.22). Our text has the saying in the parable of the sower: "Whoever has ears, listen!" (Evangelion 4:33 TT). Zarathustra borrows the seal of a hidden teaching and sets it on his own.

    Then he shows the dwarf a gateway. "Behold this gateway, dwarf! I went on: it has two faces. Two paths come together here: no one has yet walked either of them to its end" (III.2.25). One lane runs backward for an eternity, the other forward for another. "The name of the gateway is written above: 'Moment'" (III.2.27).

    The dwarf has an answer ready: "All that is straight lies, the dwarf murmured contemptuously. All truth is crooked, time itself is a circle" (III.2.29). And here Nietzsche does something a careless reader misses. Zarathustra rebukes the dwarf: "You spirit of gravity! I said angrily, do not make it too easy for yourself!" (III.2.30). The thought he is about to speak is no shrug that everything goes round; it is a weight, and he means it to be felt as one.

    So he lays out his argument, and it is an argument, not only an image. "Must not whatever of all things can run have already run this lane once? Must not whatever of all things can happen have already happened once, been done, run past?" (III.2.32). And the decisive step: "And are not all things knotted together so firmly that this moment draws all coming things after it? Therefore... itself as well?" (III.2.34). The conclusion follows: "must we not return eternally?" (III.2.37).

    A Knot With Nothing Outside It

    We want to take this argument seriously, because everything in Book Four turns on it.

    The argument needs two premises. Time behind us is infinite, so everything that can happen has had room to happen already. And all things are "knotted together," verknotet, so firmly that each moment draws every later moment after it. Grant both, and Zarathustra's conclusion is hard to escape. A closed chain of causes, run through infinite time, must repeat.

    The Marcionite does not need to dispute the arithmetic. We dispute the knot. The whole doctrine rests on the claim that there is nothing outside the chain of things, no one who is not already one of its links, nothing that can arrive that was not already on its way. That is a description of the Creator's world with the door shut. It is what Paul calls life "under the elements of the world" (Galatians 4:3 TT), and it is exactly the world our scripture says was entered from outside.

    Our Paul quotes a saying about what God prepared: "Things that eye has not seen and ear has not heard, and that have not entered into the heart of man, are what God prepared for those who love him" (1 Corinthians 2:9 TT). The things the Father prepared had not entered the heart of man. They were not part of the knot. And our Lord states the same thing about the Father himself: "No one knows the Father except the Son, and no one knows the Son except the Father, and anyone to whom the Son reveals him" (Evangelion 6:30 TT). A Father whom no one knew is not a link in the chain of causes. He is the one thing the gateway argument never imagines, a visitor.

    Zarathustra on the ridge had already said it: in the end one experiences only oneself. The gateway turns that confession into a law of the cosmos. We answer that the Evangelion is the news of something that was not oneself, coming in.

    The Shepherd and the Serpent

    While Zarathustra whispers his thought to the dwarf, a dog howls, the gateway and the dwarf vanish, and he sees a young shepherd on the ground. "I saw a young shepherd, writhing, choking, twitching, his face distorted, and a heavy black serpent was hanging out of his mouth" (III.2.45). Zarathustra cannot tear the serpent out, and so he cries out to the shepherd to bite: "Bite! Bite!" (III.2.47).

    Then he turns to the sailors and asks them to read the vision. "For it was a vision and a foreseeing: what did I see then in a parable? And who is it that must one day still come?" (III.2.51).

    The question has the ring of the one John's disciples carried to our Lord: "Are you the one who's supposed to come, or should we wait for someone else?" (Evangelion 4:15 TT). Nietzsche, a pastor's son, knew that question well, and whether or not he meant the echo, Zarathustra asks it about the shepherd. His answer is the shepherd's own act. "But the shepherd bit, as my cry advised him; he bit with a good bite! Far away he spat the serpent's head: and sprang up" (III.2.53). And then: "No longer shepherd, no longer man: one transformed, one surrounded with light, who laughed!" (III.2.54).

    It is a transfiguration, and a self-made one. The one who must come is the man who bites off the head of what was choking him, and is changed by his own bite. Later in Part Three Zarathustra all but tells us what the serpent was: "The great surfeit of man: that choked me and had crawled into my throat" (III.13.40). With it came the cry that even the little man recurs eternally (III.13.45). The redemption he offers is the strength to swallow recurrence by biting through it.

    Set beside this the answer our Lord gave to John's disciples. "Go back and tell John what you've seen with your own eyes and heard with your own ears: blind people are seeing again, the lame are walking, those with leprosy are made clean, the deaf are hearing, the dead are being awoken, and the poor are hearing the good news" (Evangelion 4:16 TT). The one who came is known by what happens to others. Blind people see; the lame walk. Zarathustra's shepherd is known by what he does for himself.

    And our Evangelion has its own shepherd. "Suppose one of you has a hundred sheep and loses one of them. Wouldn't you leave the ninety-nine out in the wilderness and go looking for the lost one until you find it?" (Evangelion 10:1 TT). Nietzsche's shepherd is alone on the cliffs with a serpent in his throat, and the only voice that reaches him tells him to bite. Our shepherd is the one who goes looking.

    The Children He Must Make

    The next speech, On Unwilling Bliss, finds Zarathustra at sea, thinking about his disciples. He says something about them that is worth reading slowly. "Once the creator sought companions and children of his hope: and behold, it turned out that he could not find them unless he first created them himself" (III.3.7).

    The creator in this sentence is a man, the human creator of values, not a maker of worlds. But the shape of the thought is the Creator's own. He loves what he made: "For from the ground up one loves only one's child and work" (III.3.9). He tests what he made, to see "whether he is of my kind and descent" (III.3.15). And the virtue he tests for is precise: he wants a disciple who is "yielding in such a way that in giving he takes" (III.3.15).

    The Father of our scripture does the opposite in every point. He does not wait to love until he has made his children; he adopts children who were not his. "So that he might purchase those under Law, that we might receive adoption" (Galatians 4:5 TT). "For you have not received a spirit of slavery again to fear, but we have been received into adoption, crying 'Abba, Father'" (Romans 8:15 TT). Adoption is a word that assumes the children did not come from the one who takes them in. And the Father's giving does not take. "For he is kind even to the ungrateful and the wicked" (Evangelion 3:35 TT).

    Zarathustra cannot find children he did not make. The Evangelion is the story of a Father who found children he did not make, and bought them out.

    Before Sunrise

    The fourth speech is a hymn to the sky before dawn, and it contains the sentence that most complicates our reading of Part Three. We should set it out fully.

    Zarathustra praises the open sky because it frees things from purpose. "'Of Haphazard': that is the oldest nobility in the world; I gave it back to all things, I redeemed them from bondage under purpose" (III.4.27). The German is von Ohngefähr, an old word for chance, made into a noble title. He goes on: "This freedom and heavenly cheerfulness I placed like an azure bell over all things when I taught that over them and through them no 'eternal will'... wills" (III.4.28).

    Here Nietzsche denies the very thing a defender of the Creator would most want to keep, an eternal will that rules through all things and assigns them their purposes. A Marcionite can hear this with some sympathy. We also refuse to make the Father the will that runs the world's machinery. When Zarathustra says that compulsion, purpose and guilt "steam like rain" far beneath the clear sky (III.4.11), he is seeing the Law's world from above, and seeing it truly as weather beneath something higher.

    But notice what he puts in place of that will. Over all things stand "the heaven Chance, the heaven Innocence, the heaven Haphazard, the heaven Exuberance" (III.4.26). The sky is "a dance floor for divine accidents" (III.4.33). And in the same breath in which he praises chance, the gateway speech has already told us that all things are knotted together so firmly that each moment draws every later moment after it (III.2.34). The last song of Part Three will join the two: a "heavenly necessity which compels even chances to dance star-dances" (III.16.16). Chance and necessity are not opposites for Zarathustra. They are two faces of one closed world. What he will not admit is a will that is not the world's own, a love that comes into it rather than ruling through it.

    There is one more line in this hymn we should read in its place. Zarathustra says that a teaching fell to him from the bright sky: "'whoever cannot bless shall learn to curse!'" (III.4.21). The curse is aimed at the lukewarm, not at enemies: "the soft-steppers and half-and-halfers and doubting, hesitating passing clouds" (III.4.20), and Zarathustra would rather have storm-curses than their calm. Our Lord's word about blessing and cursing has a different object: "Speak blessing over those who curse you, and pray for those who insult you" (Evangelion 3:30 TT). Zarathustra goes on to call himself "one who blesses and a Yes-sayer" (III.4.22), and he blesses every thing without distinction: "to stand over every thing as its own heaven, as its round roof, its azure bell and eternal security" (III.4.24). It is a beautiful blessing. It is the blessing of a sky, which covers everything and goes nowhere.

    What the Riddle Leaves Out

    The first four speeches of Part Three lay down everything the rest of the book will build on. One experiences only oneself. Love of all that lives is a danger to be overcome. All things are knotted together, and so all things return. Redemption is the bite of the one who saves himself. The creator loves only what he made. And over all of it stands a sky that blesses everything and stands in for no one.

    Nietzsche saw clearly that the God of purpose and statute, the eternal will that runs the world and keeps its accounts, was not worth worshipping, and he said so with more courage than most theologians. What his riddle leaves out is the one possibility our scripture announces: that the knot of causes is not all there is, that someone came into it from outside, and that the one who came did not bite his own way free but went looking for what was lost.

    The next chapter follows Zarathustra back to the cities of men, where he hears how the old gods laughed themselves to death.