Chapter 1 of 6

    Known From the Beginning

    10 min read

    0:0013:55

    🎧 Listen while you read

    The Second Volume

    Tertullian begins his second book by explaining why there is a second book at all. Revising his work against Marcion, he decided to give each of the two gods "its own title and volume," and he states the plan for both in one line: "defining the one god as not existing at all and defending the other as worthily God" (2.1.1). The first book had argued that Marcion's God does not exist. The second will defend the God who does.

    Then he says something that matters to a reader on our side. The second book, he admits, ought not to have been necessary. "It should, however, have been enough to argue this one point, that the god who is brought in over the Creator is no god at all" (2.1.2). Once the false god was driven out, the true God should have been accepted "without dispute, whatever his character, as one to be adored rather than judged, to be won over rather than re-examined" (2.1.2).

    Qualemcunque, whatever his character. That is the first principle of Tertullian's defense of the Creator, and it is stated before the defense begins. If there is only one God, his character is not open to question. He is to be adored, not judged.

    The defense that follows is a serious one, and we will give it six chapters. But notice the order. Before any argument is heard, the believer already owes the Creator worship, and owes him no judgment. Everything that follows is offered on top of that rule.

    Never Hidden

    Tertullian's next move is the one this chapter is named for, and it is the foundation of everything he says in the second book.

    "But now, God Almighty, the Lord and Creator of the universe, suffers this trouble, only because, I suppose, he was known from the very beginning, because he was never hidden, because he always shone forth, even before Romulus himself, let alone before Tiberius" (2.2.1).

    The sneer is aimed at Marcion's latecomer God, the theme of the first book. "Now two gods are proposed: the unknown and the known. There is no question about the known: it is agreed that he exists, because he would not have been known unless he existed" (1.9.6). A God who was not known from the beginning, he argued, cannot be God at all. "God will never lie hidden; God will never be lacking. He will always be understood, always heard, even seen, in whatever way He wills. God has witnesses: all this that we are and in which we are" (1.10.4). And he asked the question he thought unanswerable: why did this better God appear "later, and not from the very beginning of things" (1.17.4)? Marcion's God, he concluded, is a god "from Tiberius" and not from eternity (1.22.10).

    We agree with Tertullian about the Creator. He was known from the beginning, and he never hid. Israel knew him by name, heard his voice at Sinai, and kept his calendar for centuries. Nothing in our scripture disputes this.

    What we dispute is that this makes him the Father. Our Evangelion begins with a date: "It was the fifteenth year of Tiberius Caesar's reign, in the days of Pilate" (Evangelion 1:1 TT). Tertullian means "Tiberius" as an insult. It is the date of the revelation. And the revelation is of a Father who was not known before it. "Everything has been entrusted to me by the Father. No one knows the Father except the Son, and no one knows the Son except the Father, and anyone to whom the Son reveals him" (Evangelion 6:30 TT).

    Our commentary on that verse says what is at stake in one sentence: "If the Father were already known from the Law, the sentence would have no work to do." The God who was never hidden cannot be the God whom no one knew except the Son. Tertullian's first defense of the Creator is the clearest statement in his book of why the Creator is not the Father.

    The Sun and the Blind Man

    Tertullian anticipates the reply and answers it with an image. The heretics, he says, are like "a blind man or one with wandering eyes" who wishes "to presume another sun, milder and more wholesome, because he does not see the one he does see" (2.2.1). There is only one sun. "If you are unable to perceive this principle, then you would certainly not have been able to endure the rays of any other sun, had there been one, especially a greater one" (2.2.2). And he presses the point: "For if you are blind toward a lower God, what will you be toward a higher one?" (2.2.3).

    It is a good image, and it assumes something our Paul denies. It assumes that if there were a higher God, he would be seen the way the sun is seen, by looking up at the world. Paul says the opposite. The world looked and did not find him. "For since in the wisdom of God the world did not know the Lord through its wisdom, it pleased God through the foolishness of the message to rescue those who believe" (1 Corinthians 1:21 TT). What God prepared is not visible in the sky at all: "Things that eye has not seen and ear has not heard, and that have not entered into the heart of man, are what God prepared for those who love him" (1 Corinthians 2:9 TT). It comes another way. "For to us God revealed them through the Spirit, for the Spirit searches all things, even the depths of God" (1 Corinthians 2:10 TT).

    The Father is not a second sun in the same sky, missed by people with bad eyes. He is the one no eye had seen, made known by revelation and not by observation.

    Tertullian knew these verses. In the same chapter he quotes the first of them and the verse that follows the last, and turns them against the heretics: the worldly, he says, "having a spirit which, in God's wisdom, does not acknowledge God through wisdom, appear wiser to themselves than to God" (2.2.5), and he asks "as if anyone knows what is in God except the Spirit of God" (2.2.4). Paul wrote those lines to explain how a hidden wisdom became known. Tertullian uses them to rebuke the people who said something had been hidden.

    Known, but Not to Be Judged

    There is a turn in this chapter that has to be read carefully, because it can look like a contradiction and is not quite one.

    Having said that the Creator was never hidden, Tertullian immediately says that he cannot be fully known. The Marcionite, he says, already has in the Creator a God "certain and beyond doubt," whom he knows only "from the aspect where He Himself willed" (2.2.3). The greatness called God would not be greatness "if man could know it in every way" (2.2.3). And he brings in Isaiah and Paul together: "Who has known the mind of the Lord, or who has been his counselor?" and "O the depth of the riches and wisdom of God!" applying them to "the judgments of the judging God" (2.2.4).

    In fairness, this is a real distinction and not a slip. The Creator is known to exist and known in his works, but his mind is beyond us. We do not accuse Tertullian of contradicting himself.

    What matters is where the distinction is used. It is used to defend not the Creator's existence but his conduct. The ways that "no one has shown to him" are the ways questioned by "these censors of the divine, saying, 'God ought not to have done thus,' and 'He ought rather to have done thus'" (2.2.4). The Creator is fully visible when the question is whether he exists, and unsearchable when the question is what he did. It is the rule of his first chapter again: "adored rather than judged" (2.1.2).

    But Marcion was not speculating about the Creator's hidden mind; he was reading what the Creator had made known, his works and his Law, the things Tertullian himself says were never hidden. If the Creator chose to be known "from the aspect where He Himself willed," then that aspect is fair to read.

    There is a further irony in the verses Tertullian uses. Paul's hymn to the depths of God stands in Marcion's own Romans: "Oh, the depth of the riches and of the wisdom of God, and his ways are unfathomable!" (Romans 11:1 TT). In his fifth book Tertullian asks why Marcion had kept it (5.14.10). Here he claims it for the Creator as Judge. Our Paul says the depths of God were searched by the Spirit and revealed to us (1 Corinthians 2:10 TT). The God of the hymn, whose ways are unfathomable, is the God the Son made known.

    Adam the Heretic

    Tertullian ends the chapter with a sharp image. Adam's sin, he says, was the first heresy, because "through it he admitted to choosing his own judgment rather than God's" (2.2.7). But Adam was a mild heretic. "He was a very unsophisticated heretic. He disobeyed, yet he did not blaspheme the Creator, nor did he criticize the Maker, whom he had found good and excellent from his very beginning" (2.2.7).

    The image is meant to make Marcion worse than Adam, and it does. But it also says something Tertullian does not intend. Adam did not criticize his Maker because he had no other God to set beside him. He had never heard of one. The Marcionite judgment of the Creator came only after the Son revealed a Father whom Adam never knew. Paul himself says the natural person "does not receive the things of the Spirit of God" (1 Corinthians 2:14 TT), and Tertullian applies the phrase to Adam (2.2.6). We agree that Adam did not receive them. They had not yet been given.

    The Goodness That Would Not Stay Hidden

    The third chapter of Tertullian's book turns from the knowledge of God to his goodness, and it begins where the second ended. "The primary goodness of the Creator, then, is that God did not wish to lie hidden in eternity, that is, that there not be something by which God might be known" (2.3.2). For Tertullian the first good thing the Creator did was to make himself known. Goodness, for him, is visibility.

    From there he argues that the Creator's goodness is eternal and not "sudden or accidental or adventitious" (2.3.5), and he turns this against Marcion. The goodness of Marcion's God, he says, is "posterior not to beginnings and times, but to the very malice of the Creator" (2.3.5). A goodness that waited until the Creator had done harm, and then appeared, is a goodness that began late.

    Our Paul answers this directly, and in Marcion's own letters. The Father's wisdom was hidden, not late. "But we speak the wisdom of God in a mystery, hidden, which God predetermined before the aeons for our glory" (1 Corinthians 2:7 TT). Paul's task was "to enlighten all as to what the plan of the mystery is, which was hidden from the aeons from the God who created all things" (Laodiceans 3:6 TT), "the mystery that was hidden from aeons and generations but has now been revealed to his holy ones" (Colossians 1:24 TT). Our commentary on First Corinthians puts it directly: the glory in view "was settled before the Creator's aeon had a first day."

    Tertullian has an answer to this, and he gives it in his fifth book. The hidden wisdom was the Creator's own, which "lay hidden even under figures, allegories, and enigmas" in Israel's scriptures (5.6.1). On his premise that is a fair reply. But Paul says the mystery was hidden from the aeons, and Israel's figures belong to the Creator's aeon. A wisdom hidden from the aeons was not on display in their Law. Hidden is not the same as new.

    Goodness in the Garden

    Tertullian then tells the creation story as a hymn to goodness. "Goodness spoke, goodness fashioned man out of mud," goodness breathed in the soul, goodness set man over all things and placed him in paradise (2.4.4). God saw that each work was good, "thereby honoring, confirming, and sealing the goodness of his works with the dignity of his gaze" (2.4.2).

    We do not need to argue that the world is ugly to answer him. The question was never whether the Creator's works are great. It was whether they reveal the Father. Our Lord gives the Father's character in a sentence, and it is not the character of a craftsman admiring his work. "For he is kind even to the ungrateful and the wicked" (Evangelion 3:35 TT). Our commentary on that verse says that it "names the personality of a god the audience has never met."

    And Tertullian's list of goodness ends where the next chapter of our reply must begin. Goodness gave man a law, and goodness attached to it a sentence: "But on the day that you eat of it, you shall surely die" (2.4.6). Tertullian calls the threat kindness, because it warned man of the danger in advance. "For in the kindest manner, it revealed the outcome of transgression" (2.4.6). Whether a God who sets death beside a tree is showing goodness is the question of the fall, and we take it up in the next chapter.

    What the Defense Gives Away

    Tertullian's defense of the Creator starts from three claims. He was known from the beginning. He never hid. His goodness is seen in his works. We accept the first two outright, and the third as far as order and craft go, since our Lord keeps the word good for one: "Only one is good: the Father" (Evangelion 12:2 TT). Each describes a God who is not the Father of our Evangelion. The Father was not known from the beginning. No one knew him except the Son. His wisdom was hidden from the aeons. He is not found by looking at the world, because the world, in all its wisdom, did not find him. Tertullian's best argument for the Creator is that everyone always knew him. That is the best argument we have that he is not the God the Son came to reveal.