Chapter 4 of 5

    The Separation of Law and Gospel

    10 min read

    0:0014:09

    🎧 Listen while you read

    A Short Proof From Dates

    Tertullian's next chapter opens with the Marcionite reply, that the Father, though not from the beginning and not through creation, was revealed by himself in Christ (1.19.1). Tertullian promises to answer the claim properly later. "A book will also be given concerning Christ in all his circumstances," he says, and for now he will show "with few words" that Christ brought no God other than the Creator (1.19.1). What he offers here is a short proof from dates, and a longer one from the Law.

    The Marcionites' Own Arithmetic

    The proof from dates begins with a sneer and ends with a number. "In the fifteenth year of Tiberius, Christ Jesus deigned to descend from heaven, a spirit of salvation" (1.19.2). Marcion came from Pontus some time under Antoninus Pius, Tertullian says, and he has not troubled to find out exactly when. "From Tiberius to Antoninus is about 115 and a half years, plus a half month. They place the same amount of time between Christ and Marcion" (1.19.2).

    Tantundem temporis ponunt. Tertullian says they set this interval. It fits no span of reigns, since neither Tiberius' accession nor his fifteenth year lies 115 years before Antoninus came to power. But it does run from the fifteenth year of Tiberius, about the year 29, to the year 144. Harnack therefore took it as the Marcionites' own dating of their church, and placed Marcion's break with the Roman church in July of 144, as Appendix D sets out.

    Tertullian's conclusion from the same number is the opposite. "Therefore, since Marcion first introduced this god under Antoninus, as we have proven, the matter is immediately clear to anyone with understanding" (1.19.3). The god first preached under Antoninus was not revealed under Tiberius, and so "not revealed by Christ, since it is established that he was first preached by Marcion" (1.19.3).

    Sicut probavimus, as we have proven. But the one thing the Marcionite claim at 1.19.1 denies is that Marcion first preached this God. They said Christ revealed him. Tertullian answers the claim by restating his own position and calling it established. The dates prove that Marcion came long after Christ, which no one disputed. They do not prove what Christ taught.

    To be fair to him, Tertullian offers this only as a preliminary answer. The weight of his argument falls on what comes next.

    His Proper and Principal Work

    "To demonstrate now that this is consistent, I will take what remains from the opponents themselves" (1.19.4). And what he takes from them is the most useful description of the Marcionite assemblies anywhere in his five books.

    "The separation of the Law and the Gospel is Marcion's own proper and principal work, and his disciples will not be able to deny what they have in their chief instrument, by which indeed they are initiated and hardened in this heresy. For these are Marcion's Antitheses, that is, opposing juxtapositions, which attempt to set the Gospel at odds with the Law, so that from the diversity of the opinions of each instrument they may also argue for a diversity of gods" (1.19.4).

    We have no reason to deny any of it. The Antitheses was the book the Marcionite assemblies used to bring people in, and its method was to set the Law beside the Gospel and let the difference speak. Tertullian has named the center of our teaching correctly.

    What he has not shown is that the separation began with Marcion. Our Paul draws the line in the plainest words he has. "We know that a person is not justified by works of Law but through faith in Christ Jesus; and we have believed in Christ Jesus so that we may be justified by faith in Christ and not by works of Law, because by works of Law no flesh will be justified" (Galatians 2:13 TT). "For Christ is the end of the Law for righteousness to everyone who believes" (Romans 10:3 TT). And our Lord gives the boundary a name: "The Law and the Prophets were in effect until John. Since then, the kingdom of God is being announced, and everyone is pushing to get in" (Evangelion 10:20 TT).

    Tertullian does not deny that boundary either. When he reaches the saying in his fourth book, he accepts it at once. "As if we too do not acknowledge John as a certain boundary constituted between the old and the new, at whom Judaism would cease and from whom Christianity would begin" (4.33.8). What he denies is that another power stands on the far side of it.

    So the dispute is not whether the Law and the Gospel were separated. It is whether the same God stands on both sides of the line.

    Restored, Not Invented

    Tertullian knew the Marcionite answer to his proof from dates, and he reports it. "For they say that Marcion did not so much innovate the rule of the separation of the Law and the Gospel as he restored it after it had been adulterated in the past" (1.20.1).

    The Latin is recurasse. Marcion did not find a new rule. He restored an old one that had been spoiled. Tertullian's reply is a cry of mock pity. "O Christ, most patient Lord, who for so many years endured the subversion of your preaching until, of course, Marcion should come to your rescue!" (1.20.1).

    It is a good line, but it is not an argument. That the gospel was attacked from inside within a generation is no Marcionite invention but Paul's own report. "It was because of false brothers who came in secretly to spy on the freedom we have in Christ, in order to enslave us" (Galatians 2:4 TT). Paul says that attempt failed: "But we did not yield in submission for an hour, so that the truth of the Evangelion might remain with you" (Galatians 2:5 TT). The Marcionite claim is that the party of the Law did not stop trying. Christ's patience is not evidence that it never succeeded.

    What the False Brothers Wanted

    "For they also bring up Peter himself and the other 'pillars of the apostleship' as having been rebuked by Paul" because they did not walk straight toward "the truth of the gospel" (1.20.2). Our text gives the scene in full. "But when Peter came to Antioch, I opposed him to his face, because he stood condemned" (Galatians 2:9 TT). "For before certain men came from James, he used to eat with the nations; but when they came, he withdrew and separated himself, fearing those of the circumcision" (Galatians 2:10 TT).

    Tertullian has two answers. The first is that Paul was young in the faith, "by that same Paul who was still an amateur in grace" (1.20.2), and that he objected to the apostles' conduct "still fervently, like a neophyte" (1.20.3), only about how they lived and not about what they preached. Chapter 16 will take up the distinction between conduct and preaching. As for the neophyte, Paul himself dates the Jerusalem visit that precedes Antioch. "Then after an interval of fourteen years I went up to Jerusalem with Barnabas, taking Titus also" (Galatians 2:1 TT). A man at least fourteen years into his preaching is not a beginner. And the rebuke at Antioch does not stay with table manners. It runs straight into doctrine, in the same passage: "I do not set aside the grace of God, for if righteousness comes through Law, then Christ died for nothing" (Galatians 2:18 TT).

    The second answer is the more interesting, because in it Tertullian grants a good part of the Marcionite account. Paul did write of false brothers who wanted to move the Galatians to another gospel, he says, but "he himself thereby demonstrates that that adulteration of the Gospel did not intend to transfer them to the faith of another God and Christ, but to preserve the discipline of the Law" (1.20.4). The false brothers, he goes on, were caught "asserting circumcision and observing the times and days and months and years of Jewish ceremonies" (1.20.4).

    Adulterium illud evangelii. That adulteration of the Gospel. The false brothers vellent, wished, to move the Galatians, and Tertullian grants that in the apostles' own time a party of the Law tried to adulterate the gospel, and that what it wanted was to bring the Law back into it. The difference between us is what happened next. Tertullian holds that the attempt failed. At 1.21.4, arguing from the Marcionite claim that the truth was corrupted after the apostles, he says the apostolic tradition suffered no falsification in its own time "concerning the rule of God" (circa dei regulam). The corruption he grants at 1.20.4 was about the Law, not about God. The Marcionites held that the Law's party did not go away, and that Marcion's work was to take out again what it had later put in.

    Tertullian's defense of the Creator here is the one he gives at length in his fourth and fifth books: the Creator himself had foretold through his prophets that the old ceremonies would end, so Paul, in setting them aside, was carrying out the Creator's decree (1.20.4-6). Chapter 22 returns to that defense. We note only what our Paul calls the thing being set aside. "Stand firm, then, in the freedom with which Christ freed us, and do not again submit to the yoke of slavery" (Galatians 5:1 TT). That is not how one describes a decree of one's own God reaching its appointed end.

    No One Debated About God

    Then comes his strongest argument in this part of the book, and we should state it at full strength. If Paul had preached a new God, he asks, "why does he prescribe nothing about the new God, but only about the old law" (1.21.1)? A new God would have made the old Law simply irrelevant. "For the very novelty and difference of God would have removed not only the question of the old and alien Law, but all mention of it. But here lay the whole point of the question, that, although the same God of the Law was proclaimed in Christ, His Law was nonetheless abrogated" (1.21.2). The churches of Paul's day argued about many things: "some disputed about eating idol offerings, others about the veiling of women, others still about marriage or divorce, and some even about the hope of resurrection, but no one debated about God" (1.21.3). If that question had been raised, it would be in the apostle, "especially since it is so foundational" (1.21.3).

    Notice first what he grants on the way. Legi eius derogaretur. His Law was set aside. The whole question in the apostolic churches, he says, was how the Law of the God who was preached could be set aside. That is consistent with what he said earlier. The peace he said held from Christ to Marcion (1.19.5) was a peace about one God of both Law and Gospel, and he admits that conduct and discipline wavered while faith in the Creator stood (1.21.3). By his own account, then, the first generation fought hard about the Law and not at all about God.

    Then consider the argument itself. It assumes that if the Father were preached to people raised on Moses, the Law would at once cease to matter to them. Many of the first people to hear Paul's message were Jews, or people of the nations who had gathered around the synagogues. For them the Law ordered their food, their calendar and their bodies. Any message that set them free from it would have to fight about it first, and fight about it for years. A dispute about the Law is no evidence that no new God was preached; it is the form that preaching had to take in its first generation.

    Nor is Paul as silent about God as the argument needs. Chapter 2 set out his "so-called gods" and his "one God, the Father." Chapter 21 will show Tertullian moving a comma so that the god of this aeon would not be a second god, and Chapter 22 will show how he handled Paul's "gods by nature." An argument from silence is weaker when the arguer has to work so hard to keep certain verses quiet.

    We grant him this much. Paul's letters do not set out two Gods in the form of the Antitheses, side by side, sentence against sentence. That was Marcion's work, and Tertullian is right to call it his. What Paul left was the separation itself, and the language of freedom and slavery around it. Marcion drew the conclusion.

    The Roster

    Tertullian ends with a challenge. "And you will find no church of apostolic origin that does not worship the Creator as Christian" (1.21.4). "Present, then, one from your roster of apostolic authority" (1.21.5).

    Chapter 16 will answer the appeal to the apostolic churches when Tertullian makes it again in his fourth book. Here it is enough to say that the proof asks which churches can trace a line back to an apostle and agree with Tertullian, and never what the apostle wrote. A Marcionite answer, as far as we can reconstruct it, would rest on the apostle's letters, the same letters Tertullian quotes against them.

    Proper and Principal

    Tertullian's proof comes to this. Marcion appeared long after Christ, by a reckoning Tertullian says the Marcionites themselves set. The separation of Law and Gospel was the center of his teaching. His followers claimed he had restored it. And in the apostles' own time, by Tertullian's own account, a party of the Law tried to adulterate the gospel. We accept those facts, and we differ on what followed. Tertullian calls the separation of the Law and the Gospel Marcion's "proper and principal work" (1.19.4). It was Paul's first. Marcion's work was to say outright whose Law it was that Christ had ended.